John,

I really like this "Americana feel" song; good melody especially and a nice concept lyrically. Love the harmonica intro and the mandolin within the song.

Nice balance in your mix as well for the instrumentation being used. I would actually prefer hearing more piano in place of the organ and a few more harmonica bursts as I think the song would feel even more Americana without that organ "rhythm bed." (Not that it sounds bad mind you), and JMO should you want to emphasize a more Americana genre.

The half empty glass line in Ch 1 a little "wordy" prososdy-wise, might experiment there with the phrasing. I like the Bridge melody and like the last line, but not sure about the "turn me" line-maybe a bit vague on that 1st line, as I know you don't mean "literally" turn me. (Turn me from what)? Musically, I really like what your Bridge is doing.

I know It looks like I'm picking on you, not so........I think this is a great tune with potential, but room for improvement, and all of us with our songwriting can be improved for sure.

I'm not sure you need to hold some of the notes earlier in the song as long as you do vocally--a little polish and experimenting with prosody and you'll have a great song! I really enjoyed your music!

Just some thoughts......use/try or lose.

steady-eddie.