Originally Posted by Rob B.
Originally Posted by Fdemetrio
No i couldn't go back, that's how long he's been using suno. Thats what he's capable of without AI, so in no position to judge my writing

Dom,
The recording you just rediscovered was never presented as a radio-ready production. It was a quick draft, something musicians and studio people create all the time while developing ideas. But you couldn't know that.

I've spent more than 30 years working in studios with producers, engineers, and musicians all around the world. I've been using AI music tools for only a small fraction of that time. So when you present a rough draft from 2024 as if it represents the full extent of my abilities, you're creating a false picture. People who have followed my work over the years know what I've done, both before AI and after AI. They can judge for themselves.

You're entitled to dislike my songs and criticize my recordings. But bumping up an old demo and pretending it defines my capabilities isn't a serious argument. Honestly, you're making a fool of yourself.

Neither was any of my songs presented as radio ready but oh wait that different.....

Look, John doesnt know, but , when entering lyrics into Ai, its using the lyrucs to create a melody and arrangement, haven't heard any Ai couch songs aside from the few he posted here, which were kinda clumsy to me.

Haven't heard anything recent, there's always a learning curve with tech

But he is a vivid lyricist, ai is capable of interpreting those lyrics into a audio visual.
His Meter and structure are always good, that night be another reason.

If im doing pop music, you dont get that dynamic, its just conversation.

If you look at my story songs, you can hear a whole different landscape. Such as, " before you think one night"

It places you in the gulf of Mexico.

It has nothing to do with articulating prompts. Prompts may fine tune it, but it's narrative driven.

Its also having an ear.

Not all songs achieve the same things

Last edited by Fdemetrio; 1 hour ago.