Hi Ted:

I'd use an acoustic for this song. smile

You might also play around with the EQ on the guitar track as Louis suggested. See if you can find the frequency where that rumble is at a maximum and make a cut there - and hope it doesn't affect the guitar sound too much smile

I know you use audacity to record and mix. But how do you get the sound into your computer? Is it through the computer's sound card or do you have an external audio interface?

Scott