Hi again, Roy and fellow JPF'rs:

Roy, your question depends on the oral or written understanding you have with your co-writers. In my opinion, it's always a good thing when all partners have agreed to be brutally honest (without being snide or picky) and to be "up front" with each other's work. If you don't care for the melody, ask him/her to change the part you don't like. If you don't care for anything they've done, suggest something that might sound like what you believe the song should become. If it's unsalvageable in your opinion, challenge them to write another version (or two) and be willing to change your lyrics to suit the new creation.

It's alot about "give and take" and having the talent and tenacity to get your point across without offending your "podnuh." (Texan for Partner... LOL!)

Most "seasoned" lyricists and composers (songwriters) are willing to try different directions or versions. After all, you should both be all about trying to crack the charts with a real show-stopper... and make a gazillion, quadrillion bucks in the process. Art is wonderful but pecuniary reward is what I'm looking for... and looking... and looking... still looking!

If I did not answer your question (you too, Glyn) please explain it to me one more time. Forgive me, tomorrow is golf day and I'm trying to figure out a way to beat my pal Randy into the ground without bending any rules. I fired a 78 at him the other day and he "put me to rest" on the last hole with a killer putt and a result of 77. Drat!

All my best,

Dave