You do NOT have to accept any collaborator's product.

A contract consists of an 'offer' and an 'acceptance'.

You enter into a 'tentative contract' by 'offering' a lyric.

They 'accept' that tentative contract by offering a musical treatment, a melody and/or arrangement.

You then have the option to 'accept' their 'offer' or not.

If you 'offer' to sell your car and someone 'accepts' but only wants to pay you $10.00 you don't have to 'accept' their offer. The parties to the contract have to come to an agreement as to the price YOU will accept. The parties have to agree on the 'marriage' of their respective 'offerings'.

If the parties agree on this clause in the contract, an 'option to reject', in the initial dealings between you, both parties know that either party can withdraw their 'offering.'

If you accept each others' offerings, THEN the lyric and melody/arrangement can become 'married' 'til copyright expiration do you part. ??

Simply tell them you don't care for what they've offered and, if you think they might have more to offer, allow them to try again on this or another lyric. If not, withdraw your offer of the lyric, and politely end the relationship.


There will always be another song to be written. Someone will write it. Why not you? www.garyeandrews.com