Everett,

That is not nessasarily true. YOU might feel that it is separate but your co-writer might feel totally differently. It is one more reason that there are almost no songs written in Nashville where one person does the lyrics and another does the music. Everyone is involved in everything and 98% of the songs are made up on the spot.

The less finished you have something, i.e.bringing in a lyric with no melody, or vice versa, the more you open yourself up to missed communications and hard feelings.

You have seen over and over on these posts about people who have submitted lyrics to these companies that "set your lyrics to music" and do demos and you hear over and over the dissapointment, and bad feelings that engenders. People have their own ideas when they write things and it is hard to get inside someone else's mind. But anyone that puts creative time into something are going to feel entitled to part of that, whether the other one does or not.

Conversly, those of us who do this for a living like things that are "less finished", in other words, we don't want you to bring in a total lyric or musical piece. That puts us in a box and doesn't allow for our own creativity to come into place.I don't ever write that way. I like senarios, scenes, pieces of actual conversation, before I committ to writing a song. Much like a story line or script outline. I fill in all the blanks and dialogue. And with the co-writers, I will go back and forth as we develop a roadmap, tweaking and re-writing as we go.They are involved in every step of the way and if there are dissagreements, those are addressed LONG before we get a finished product together.

So my suggestion is to get to know people, write with them as personally as you can and learn to give and take. Depending on who you are working with, it all can get very confusing very quickly.And don't hire "Services" to interpret what you are doing. Provide them with what you hear. Or be satisfied with the results.

MAB