I had a similar problem with the CD player in my Renault Grand Scenic car.....turns out it did the same "INTERMITTENT THING" with all makes and types of CD some would play others would not.....I insisted that the garage who supplied the car put in a new CD player and never had the prob again. Sometimes players had a dodgy laser or decoder. Sometimes the PC reader/burner can occasionally kick out a dodgy disc...like anything they need regular servicing or need cleaned or replaced eventually.