Recently, there was a flurry of news items about a professor who caught a substantial number of his students cheating on an exam. He gave them an ultimatum: Admit it or fail! I still cringe at an on line interview with a student at this school. He said, "It's just a witch hunt! Get serious! Everyone does it. Everyone cheats."
Music has a certain shelf life. The authors of the music have, in most cases, a limited career. Hundreds of thousands of people like that student have no comprehension of the damage they do to the creators of the music they steal. "it's only one download, the label who's ripping me off deserves it, the artist will make it up on her tour, and besides, if I share this tune with my friends, maybe they'll go pay for the album (not that I ever will). . . by the way, what's a songwriter?"
All a crock of [naughty word removed]. It's stealing creative property. If the government appears heavy handed with this, I'd rather it be here than somewhere else. Who's complaining? The people who are stealing. My heart does not go out to their "rights" to "due process". Did they give a rat's ass about the rights of a musician to their own creation?
Just finished reading "Les Miserables", by Victor Hugo. The protagonist ended up in the galleys for 19 years for stealing a loaf of bread. These days internet theives are punished by losing the websites that enable their theft. The fact that they complain goes from irony, to the absurd, to the ridiculous.
Ott