Who's Online Now
3 members (Everett Adams, Gary E. Andrews, texritter), 191,556 guests, and 5,880 robots.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Register Today!
Welcome to the Just Plain Folks forums! You are currently viewing our forums as a Guest which gives you limited access to most of our discussions and to other features.

By joining our free community you will have access to post and respond to topics, communicate privately with our users (PM), respond to polls, upload content, and access many other features. Registration is fast, simple, and absolutely free; so please join our community today!
ShoutChat
Comment Guidelines: Do post respectful and insightful comments. Don't flame, hate, spam.
What's Going On
Ana Schon
by Gary E. Andrews - 11/16/26 12:11 AM
::: SEXY LADY :::
by bennash - 11/15/26 06:08 PM
The Legend of Martha's Bridge
by texritter - 11/13/26 06:40 PM
Beato back at it
by bennash - 11/10/26 06:37 PM
Lot Long
by Gary E. Andrews - 11/10/26 11:20 AM
Jefferson Thomas
by Gary E. Andrews - 11/10/26 10:43 AM
Everything But The Girl
by Gary E. Andrews - 11/10/26 10:08 AM
Paris Is Burning
by bennash - 11/10/26 04:10 AM
Alacranes RVA Richmond VA
by Gary E. Andrews - 11/09/26 11:39 PM
Earth Libraries, Rock Creek SK
by Gary E. Andrews - 11/09/26 12:10 PM
Truths To Expensive
by bennash - 11/08/26 10:50 PM
Politics HERE only!
by bennash - 11/08/26 02:43 AM
McVie Miller Tribute
by Gary E. Andrews - 11/07/26 11:05 PM
Will We Still Have Songwriters in the Year 5000?
by Fdemetrio - 11/06/26 02:08 PM
SPACE FREQ, Beckley, Charleston WVa
by Gary E. Andrews - 11/05/26 11:49 PM
Blind Pig, Ann Arbor
by Gary E. Andrews - 11/04/26 09:47 AM
Live at The Complex, Dear Banshee
by Gary E. Andrews - 11/04/26 09:28 AM
Just say no to Suno
by Pat Hardy - 11/03/26 02:00 AM
Ian Stahl, Burbank
by Gary E. Andrews - 11/02/26 07:50 AM
This is insane
by bennash - 11/01/26 11:19 AM
Just Another Copyright Lawsuit...
by bennash - 10/29/26 03:19 PM
Radio Is A Box Of Fairy Tales
by bennash - 10/29/26 08:50 AM
Momentum Studios
by Gary E. Andrews - 10/27/26 11:56 PM
Anthony Gomes, Romania
by Gary E. Andrews - 10/27/26 11:47 PM
Vern Riffe Center For The Arts, Motown, Portsmouth
by Gary E. Andrews - 10/27/26 10:56 PM
Vern Riffe Center For The Arts, Motown, Portsmouth
by Gary E. Andrews - 10/27/26 10:55 PM
Andy Frasco
by Gary E. Andrews - 10/27/26 10:08 PM
ConnieConverse
by Bill Draper - 10/27/26 12:21 PM
Dakota Free, The Tape Cassettes
by Gary E. Andrews - 10/27/26 01:34 AM
Benny Sidelinger, Anacortes WA
by Gary E. Andrews - 10/24/26 09:07 PM
Top Posters
Calvin 19,858
Travis david 12,380
Kevin Emmrich 10,943
Jean Bullock 10,330
Kaley Willow 10,240
Two Singers 9,649
Fdemetrio 9,239
Joice Marie 9,186
Mackie H. 9,003
glynda 8,688
Mike Dunbar 8,574
Tricia Baker 8,318
couchgrouch 8,240
Colin Ward 7,911
Corey 7,357
Sunset Poet 7,230
Vicarn 6,916
Mark Kaufman 6,589
ben willis 6,114
Lynn Orloff 5,788
Louis 5,725
Linda Sings 5,608
KimberlyinNC 5,210
Neil Cotton 4,909
Derek Hines 4,893
DonnaMarilyn 4,700
bennash 4,655
Blake Hill 4,528
Bob Cushing 4,389
Roy Cooper 4,303
MFB III 4,237
Bill Osofsky 4,199
Tom Shea 4,195
Cindy Miller 4,178
TamsNumber4 4,172
nightengale 4,096
E Swartz 4,029
beechnut79 3,878
Caroline 3,865
Kolstad 3,845
Dan Sullivan 3,710
Dottie 3,427
joewatt 3,411
Bill Cooper 3,279
John Hoffman 3,199
Skip Johnson 3,027
Pam Hurley 3,007
Terry G 3,005
PopTodd 2,901
Nigel Quin 2,891
Harriet Ames 2,870
MidniteBob 2,764
Nelson 2,616
Tom Tracy 2,558
Jerry Jakala 2,524
Al Alvarez 2,499
Eric Thome 2,448
Hummingbird 2,401
Stan Loh 2,263
Sam Wilson 2,247
Wendy D 2,236
Judy Hollier 2,232
Erica Ellis 2,202
maccharles 2,134
TrumanCoyote 2,096
Rob B. 2,069
Marty Helly 2,041
DukeWill 2,009
floyd jane 1,985
Clint Anglin 1,904
cindyrella 1,888
David Wright 1,866
Clairejeanne 1,851
Cindy LaRosa 1,824
Ronald Boyt 1,675
Iggy 1,653
VNORTH2 1,652
Noel Downs 1,633
Rick Heenan 1,608
Cal 1,574
Bill Draper 1,570
GocartMoz 1,559
Jack Swain 1,554
Pete Larsen 1,537
Ann Tygart 1,529
Tom Breshers 1,487
RogerS 1,481
Tom Franz 1,479
David Gill 1,464
IronKnee 1,455
Chuck Crowe 1,441
Ralph Blight 1,440
Rick Norton 1,435
Kenneth Cade 1,429
Deej56 1,419
bholt 1,411
Letha Allen 1,409
in2piano 1,404
Stan Simons 1,402
mattbanx 1,384
Jen Shaner 1,373
Charlie Wong 1,347
KevinP 1,324
Vondelle 1,316
Tom W. 1,313
Jan Petter 1,301
scottandrew 1,294
lane1777 1,280
Gerry 1,280
DakLander 1,265
PeteG 1,242
Ian Ferrin 1,235
Glen King 1,214
IdeaGuy 1,209
AaronAuthier 1,177
summeoyo 1,174
ckiphen 1,162
Diane Ewing 1,162
joro 1,082
BobbyJoe 1,075
S.DEE 1,040
yann 1,037
9ne 1,035
WesRyan 1,018
Tony A 1,016
argo 986
peaden 984
90 dB 964
Wolvman 960
Jak Kelly 912
krtinberg 890
Petra 883
RJC 845
Brenda152 840
Nadia 829
ant 798
Juan 797
TKO 784
Dayson 781
frahmes 781
teletwang 762
Irwin 757
Andy Kemp 751
Andy K 750
tbryson 737
Jackie444 731
Pat Hardy 706
3daveyO3 704
Dixie 701
Joy Boy 695
Knute 686
Moosesong 679
Lee Arten 678
Katziis 652
R.T.MOORE 638
quality 637
CG King 622
douglas 621
R&M 614
Mel 614
NaomiSue 601
Shandy 590
Ria 587
TAMERA64 583
qbaum 570
nitepiano 566
pRISCILLA 556
Tink2 553
musica 539
BB Wilbur 536
deanbell 528
RobertK 527
BonzaiWag 523
Roderic 522
goodfolks 499
Zeek 487
Stu 486
Steve P. 481
KathyW 462
allenb 459
MaxG 458
Philjo 454
fanito 448
trush48 448
dmk 442
Rob L 439
arealrush 437
DGR 436
avweek 435
Stephen D 433
Emmy 431
marquez 422
kit 419
Softkrome 417
kyrksongs 415
RRon 408
Laura G. 407
VNORTH 407
Debra 407
eb 406
cuebald 399
EdPerrone 399
Dannyk1 395
Hobart 395
ddreuter 394
Davyboy49 393
Smile 389
GJShades 387
Alek 386
Ezt 384
tone 380
Marla 380
Ann_F 379
iggyiggy 378
coalminer 377
java 374
spidey 371
sweetsong 370
danny 367
Jim Ryan 360
papaG 353
Z - man 350
JamesDF5 348
John K 348
Jaden 344
TheBaz 340
Steggy 339
leif 339
tonedeaf 336
rickwork 334
Eddie Ray 332
Johnboy 328
Bob Lever 328
Helicon1 327
lucian 326
Muskie 321
kc 319
Z. Mulls 318
ptondreau 313
ONOFFON 312
Chris B. 310
trush 304
ed323 297
Ellen M 294
markus-ky 294
lizzorn 291
nicnac49 290
Char 286
ktunes 285
Top Likes Received
bennash 148
Rob B. 103
Fdemetrio 103
VNORTH2 68
Previous Thread
Next Thread
Print Thread
Rate Thread
Page 1 of 3 1 2 3
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 823
J
Serious Contributor
OP Offline
Serious Contributor
J
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 823
I'm a little confused by quite a few posts I've read where people ask for critiques of a "song" they've written--and it turns out to be just words.

I don't mean any disrespect to anyone. I just think it's better to call things what they are if we want to communicate well with each other.

This is my understanding of the correct terminology:

If you write a poem, you are a poet. A poem is intended to be read aloud for best effect.

If you write music, you are a composer.

If you write words and music together, you are a songwriter.

If you take other people's songs and make a new version musically, you are an arranger.

If you write words that are intended to be sung, but you don't write the music for them, you are a lyricist.

I personally have a hard time evaluating a lyric by itself, without hearing the music. Different criteria come into play depending on whether the words are a poem to be read aloud, or a lyric to be sung. So much depends on the melody, the rhythm, the chord progression. How can I decide if the lyric sounds good as part of a song, if the rest of the song is missing? (I'm a singer/songwriter, and I've decided not to critique any lyrics alone on this board because I don't do it well. I end up reading the words like a poem, and I'm afraid my comments will reflect that perspective. I'll leave that up to the lyricists here.)

I have a great deal of respect and admiration for good lyricists. There are many who impress me, in many different styles of writing and styles of music. Just as one example, I think the Gershwin brothers did great together, and Ira's lyrics were so clever, packed with meaning, perfectly rhymed, and a perfect marriage with his brother George's melodies. They were a great songwriting team. However, if I try to read Ira's lyrics as poetry, they don't sound so great--they belong with music, and they fit perfectly with the music they were written for. Just an example.

It seems to me that, in considering the words and the music as two main elements of a song, the music will always be a little more important. Even though the two work together and have an effect on each other (they can be equal, or one can drag the other down or make the other soar), a lyric can only be a part of a song at best, whereas the music can be a song all on its own if the composer wishes.

Any thoughts on this? --JL

Joined: Jun 2001
Posts: 527
R
Serious Contributor
Offline
Serious Contributor
R
Joined: Jun 2001
Posts: 527
According to strict denotation (dictionary meaning) a lyric or poem can be referred to as a 'song'. So technically speaking, yeah, everyone's a songwriter on this bus. [Linked Image]

But I think you have a point, that in the real world, words are cheap and music is dear, i.e., many more can come up with competent words than music.

After all, from the age of four we all learn to write and speak, but how many get schooled in music theory, composition, or even just playing an instrument?

Economy 101 - the more rare a thing is, the more valuable.

As you noted, good/great lyricists are nothing to sneeze at, and are well-respected within the industry.

But good/great composers are absolutely lionized. Rightfully so, or would someone argue that Schiller deserves equal credit for the Ninth Symphony of Beethoven? Last I checked, it was universally referred to as Andrew Lloyd Webber's "Phantom Of The Opera" (quick, who wrote the lyrics?)

(I'm sure there are a handful out there who know off the top of their head, or can do a quick Google search, so consider it a rhetoric question).

Some still argue that lyrics are 'just as important', but until I hear LYRAK in an elevator, or see a thriving business in Nashville of "Send Us Your Melodies, And We'll Add Our Song/Poems" song sharks, I'll take the other side of the debate.

Just look on any songboard - sure the occasional composer will solicit for lyricists, but those kind of posts are outweighted 20 to 1 (or greater) by lyricists looking for composers.

Personally I think it's because music goes directly to the heart, whereas words first have to make a stop for processing at the brain, figuratively speaking. I read a study once that said the average listener can pick up the general musical gist of a song and hum/whistle it after two listens, whereas even after 10 listens not many of the lyrics were remembered beyond a hook phrase or title.

Try it yourself. Pick a song we've all heard hundreds of times, like the Sound Of Music or My Favorite Things or Bye Bye Blackbird or Stairway To Heaven, and then try to sing it correctly.

Yet few would have trouble hearing the music in their heads and whistling/humming most of the above.

Still think that words are just as important? Maybe, but the burden is on you to prove that the sold-out houses at the Met all understand Italian and German. [Linked Image]

[This message has been edited by RobertK (edited 02-13-2004).]

Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 823
J
Serious Contributor
OP Offline
Serious Contributor
J
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 823
RobertK--

Thank you for your reply on this--very interesting and just the kind of thoughtful response I was hoping for!

I would like to add something: I'm a music lover. I also enjoy words and language. There are people who love words more than I do--poets, novelists, writers of all kinds. I would guess that to some of them, words could be more important than music in their lives.

In a poem, words are everything. (Well, delivery counts, too. Some people can take a poem and recite it in a way that is just amazing, using skills related to acting.)

I hope it was clear in my original post that I was referring to the relative importance of music and words IN A SONG, not comparing their value in general.

I think it's really cool how words and music can work together for us to make something different from music or words alone. We have poetry, we have music, we have songs--all sort of unique, all very creative endeavors. I'm also glad we as people can enjoy things that we can't do--like other people's poetry or music or songs! It must be thrilling for both parties when a great lyricist and a great composer who admire each other's work get together and create a wonderful song.

I guess that's partly what JPF tries to facilitate. I'm probably never going to experience that since any lyrics that come out of me are already attached to music, but I'm glad for other people who are able to find each other and create something as a team. Thank you, Brian!

--Jean

[This message has been edited by JL (edited 02-13-2004).]

Joined: Mar 2002
Posts: 2,096
T
Top 100 Poster
Offline
Top 100 Poster
T
Joined: Mar 2002
Posts: 2,096
Words or melody? Which is more important? The question itself is the problem. There is no answer. RobertK makes a good case for the music he mentions. I would concur that melodies reign in show tunes, Tin Pan Alley standards, etc. Yes, Rice may may defer to Webber, and Sondheim to Bernstein, but what does that prove? One could cite Dylan, Chuck Berry and others (Nashville writers in particular) where the lyric is king. What does that prove? Only that the criteria are different for every song.

No, we will not likely see Lyrak in elevators, but did you ever notice that Musak tends to utilize only those songs that have strong, identifiable melodies? They just ignore the thousands of songs that rely primarily on lyrics for their artistry.

Lyricists are respected and composers are lionized. Good defensive shortstops are respected and sluggers are lionized. All that proves is that the public--those who do the lionizing--don't know much about either music or baseball. The truth is that each element all critically important to the team. Sometimes Sammy Sosa wins the game. Sometimes it's Ozzie Smith. Some songs have stronger lyrics. Some have stronger melodies.

If I had to guess, I would say that a greater number of songs succeed because of great melodies than because of great lyrics. But not, by any means, all of them.

As to who should be called what, I don't see the importance of the distinction. If someone writes lyrics and wants to be called a songwriter, it's ok with me.

[This message has been edited by TrumanCoyote (edited 02-13-2004).]

[This message has been edited by TrumanCoyote (edited 02-13-2004).]

Joined: Sep 2003
Posts: 4,199
B
Top 100 Poster
Offline
Top 100 Poster
B
Joined: Sep 2003
Posts: 4,199
Just a reply to some of Robert's points. The next time you go to a sold out concert of Tim McGraw, Faith Hill, Kenny Chesney, etc., see how people can tell you who wrote the music (or the lyrics). Unfortunately, anyone who can speak thinks they can write lyrics. And there are plenty of amateur lyricists, but when you're talking about pro level talent, the field narrows down quite a bit. The folks who write top-notch lyrics probably aren't a lot greater in number than the folks who write top-notch music. What we've gotten with this "lyrics don't matter" attitude is a generation of self-contained packages that neither write lyrics, music or sing at the the level of a "specialist". And I will agree that music is probably more important to the package than lyrics are. But before we lionize composers, let's compare the number of people who go to hear symphonies to the number who go listen to rap music. If instrumental music was such a hot item, there would be more than one station per city playing it. And that station is most likely paid for with public funds.

Bill

------------------
We too often throw around the word "great" like it was a frisbee, instead of the manhole cover it should be.


Joined: Jun 2001
Posts: 527
R
Serious Contributor
Offline
Serious Contributor
R
Joined: Jun 2001
Posts: 527
Just a reply to some of Robert's points. The next time you go to a sold out concert of Tim McGraw, Faith Hill, Kenny Chesney, etc., see how people can tell you who wrote the music (or the lyrics).

It doesn't matter if they don't know the name of the songwriters - they know the MUSIC. The crowd is swaying, clapping, stomping, etc. to the sound of instruments and voices, and only secondarily (if at all) focused on the lyrics. The performance and the sound, that's what's putting the fannies in the seats, not the words.

But before we lionize composers, let's compare the number of people who go to hear symphonies to the number who go listen to rap music. If instrumental music was such a hot item, there would be more than one station per city playing it.

Missing the point, again - why does "music is more important" have to mean "no words at all"? Composers mean those who write music, whether it's to a symphony or to a pop hit.

Often the singing of the words is almost as if another instrument is being enjoyed, that instrument being the human voice, without people paying attention to or absorbing the specific words. Otherwise how can you explain the success of songs like Con Te Partiro (aka, Time To Say Goodbye) - I'm sure the vast majority of the people who made that song a hit on both sides of the Atlantic don't understand Italian, but are nonetheless mesmerized by the voices of Brightman and Bocelli. And when you read a translation of the words, assuming you have a burning need to understand the lyric, you'll find it's actually quite trite.

And if you think the listeners to rap are getting off on the gobbledy-gook being spoken/sung rather than the voices as percussive instruments themselves, the driving relentless beat and the electricity of the performers and the crowd, well...



[This message has been edited by RobertK (edited 02-13-2004).]

Joined: Nov 2002
Posts: 539
T
Serious Contributor
Offline
Serious Contributor
T
Joined: Nov 2002
Posts: 539
Keeping strictly to the initial question, I'd say it's a simple yet obviously excusable slip when somebody refers to their lyric as a "song".
While some folks are strictly lyricists, most writers of lyrics have a "song" in mind as they are writing, such is the intent, such is the effort, and often one has the music buzzin' inside the head while writing the lyric, some have probably bounced back and forthe to their instrument in the process of writing the lyric/song... so... in their minds they are writing a song, and most folks will likely NEVER write an actual score for their song anyway.

[Linked Image] -gary

Joined: Jun 2001
Posts: 527
R
Serious Contributor
Offline
Serious Contributor
R
Joined: Jun 2001
Posts: 527
Lyricists are respected and composers are lionized. Good defensive shortstops are respected and sluggers are lionized. All that proves is that the public--those who do the lionizing--don't know much about either music or baseball. The truth is that each element all critically important to the team. Sometimes Sammy Sosa wins the game. Sometimes it's Ozzie Smith.

It proves that, what the SS does is worth about $3M/yr, assuming he can hit at least .275, and what the slugger does is worth $13M+/yr.

Each element is NOT critically important, otherwise...

Side note: The baseball analogy between defense/offense and words/music is not a bad one.

The .275 hitting defensive magicians would be paid the same as the .300+, 40 HR+, 100 RBI+ sluggers or the 20 victory a year pitchers.

They're not, and it has nothing to do with the public's lack of baseball savvy. It has to do with excitement and who's putting the fans in the seats. (And the fact that, no matter how solid your defense and pitching, if you can't score runs you're going to struggle for every win, whereas monster offense will cover a lot of defensive holes - there's a reason folks say "The best defense is a good offense".

And often we hear about an offensive player "carrying a team", sometimes for weeks at a time - when was the last time a defensive star received the same accolade?

Same with lyricist and composer.

There are plenty of great hits with so-so and even poor lyrics, but I can't think of too many great lyrics that carried mediocre tunes.

Let's revisit my previous challenge. Take a popular song that has 'great lyrics', i.e., where the lyrics are allegedly more important than the music, and see how many people can sing the lyrics to any great extent, even though having heard the song innumerable times.

If the lyrics are what are allegedly 'selling' certain songs, then people would be able to recall them as quickly as the more mediocre music for a given "great lyrics" song, right?

Aside from the Star Spangled Banner and Happy Birthday (or that interminable American Pie), the words, even the 'great lyrics' are not remembered by many, even the more astute listeners.

I reiterate: this is not to say that words mean nothing. The combination of great music and words make magic indeed, the bedrock of much of what survives the test of time.

But it's still the music that brings the most to the table.

[This message has been edited by RobertK (edited 02-13-2004).]

Joined: Sep 2003
Posts: 4,199
B
Top 100 Poster
Offline
Top 100 Poster
B
Joined: Sep 2003
Posts: 4,199
Hey Robert,

I see you had this same arguement in Aug. 2001. In fact you could have cut and pasted a lot of what you said. Even declared yourself the winner. Looks like you do it just for the sport of it. Must be an attorney. [Linked Image] See ya around.

Bill

------------------
We too often throw around the word "great" like it was a frisbee, instead of the manhole cover it should be.

[This message has been edited by lijemtu (edited 02-13-2004).]


Joined: Mar 2002
Posts: 2,096
T
Top 100 Poster
Offline
Top 100 Poster
T
Joined: Mar 2002
Posts: 2,096
[QUOTE]Originally posted by RobertK:

It proves that, what the SS does is worth about $3M/yr, assuming he can hit at least .275, and what the slugger does is worth $13M+/yr....

The .275 hitting defensive magicians would be paid the same as the .300+, 40 HR+, 100 RBI+ sluggers or the 20 victory a year pitchers.


RobertK, you are an intelligent person and I refuse to buy that you actually believe that salary determines intrinsic value. I just do not accept that anyone really believes that.


They're not [equal in salary], and it has nothing to do with the public's lack of baseball savvy.


It has everything to do with it. You are talking about the business of baseball and I am talking about the game.

It has to do with excitement and who's putting the fans in the seats.

Couldn't have said it better myself.

And often we hear about an offensive player "carrying a team", sometimes for weeks at a time - when was the last time a defensive star received the same accolade?

You keep circling back to the same point. Yes...the public lavishes praise on the slugger, the quarterback, the guy who stays on the island the longest, the girl who eats the most maggots,...and composers. We get that.


There are plenty of great hits with so-so and even poor lyrics, but I can't think of too many great lyrics that carried mediocre tunes.


Rap and hip-hop music. Almost all blues music. Most bluegrass and a lot of country music. Dylan. Chuck Berry. Must I go on?


If the lyrics are what are allegedly 'selling' certain songs, then people would be able to recall them as quickly as the more mediocre music for a given "great lyrics" song, right?


No. Not right. Recall is not what makes a hit record. People LIKING it is what makes a hit record.


But it's still the music that brings the most to the table.


SOMETIMES it is. Sometimes not. And that has been my point all along.

Joined: Jul 2001
Posts: 4,372
Top 100 Poster
Offline
Top 100 Poster
Joined: Jul 2001
Posts: 4,372
Sorry Robert..

In todays world, people react emotionally more to the words than the music...

Sure they move to the music, but they mouth the words at the same time.

I've been watching people from the stage for almost 45 years...trust me on this one.

And let's see....what was the last "instrumental" hit record ?.....

Hmmmm...

I seem to remember you raising this point a while ago too......

Well.....

You were wrong then....you're wrong now...

Nice try kid..
Better luck next time

bob Young

Joined: Aug 2002
Posts: 7,172
Likes: 29
Top 40 Poster
Online Content
Top 40 Poster
Joined: Aug 2002
Posts: 7,172
Likes: 29
I think both are important.The words paint a picture and tells a story,the music is the frame for the painting and the back ground for the story to ride on.If you are talking country or Gospel songs the words are the most important,if it's pop or rock the music is king.Music alone will not get a sinner to come to the altar,but the message in the words will.Words alone will not get a person to dance but music will,so which is most important,I guess it depends on what you are trying to do with a song.

There are millions of words and only seven notes in music,it's how they work together that's magic and makes hits.Which is more important to a chicken farmer,the chicken or the eggs.He'd have a job making a living without the two(unless he is raising chickens for meat only)LOL.


The more you taste the bitterness of defeat, the sweeter final victory will be

May the flowers of love forever bloom in your garden of life

http://www.soundclick.com/newsflashsounds

http://www.soundclick.com/newsflashgospel

www.cdbaby.com/all/eca333

www.showcaseyourmusic.com/newsflashsounds
Joined: Sep 2001
Posts: 10,330
Top 10 Poster
Offline
Top 10 Poster
Joined: Sep 2001
Posts: 10,330
Outside of Big Band Music, I can only think of a few instrumentals that were popular music hits on the radio in my lifetime so far: Walk Don't Run, Wipe out (which technically has words. An insane laugh and the words "Wipe Out"), Dueling Banjos, Classical Gas and maybe some of Herb Alperts hits like Tiajuana Taxi (I don't know if that had words or not.

The majority of major hits on the radio have sung lyrics. People love to hear the human voice which is the most exquisite instrument of all.

Language itself has a rhythm and musical quality. That is why great poetry should be read aloud. Great poems don't always make great songs. There is something more to take into consideration in language used for lyrics. Certain combinations of letter sounds allow the voice tremendous expression. Songwriters who sing are aware of this probably more than the songwriter who isn't. Because of the pleasing sounds of the words themselves, combined with the singers vocal abilities, we are able to enjoy songs in languages we don't understand. So that is one of the important aspects of lyrics.

In languages we do understand, lyrics are even more significant. Sometimes it is the content of the song that endears a song to people rather than the sound of the words or music itself.

I remember the day when my dad brought home a single of Ed Ames' hit, "My Cup Runneth Over With Love." Dad had stopped off at a music store. He walked into the house, put the record on the stereo, turned the volume up and walked over and held my mother as she listened to it.

It's a beautiful song, beautiful lyrics and beautiful vocal. That isn't what made my mother cry sweet tears. It was the message. My dad couldn't tell my mother how he felt and so he let the song do it for him. People use songs as messages all the time. The popularity of dedicating songs to people on radio shows is a good example of this.

The content of the song doesn't always have to be mindbendingly profound either. There can be great beauty in simplicity and it isn't always that simple to acheive it.

As for people forgetting some of the words, there are plenty of people who can't remember the melody correctly either. However most do remember the parts of the lyrics and melody that pleased them the most which is often the first line of the verses and the chorus. (Which is why songwriting teachers tell us to pay special attention to those areas.)

Often great music is shaped by lyrics. If I am not mistaken, Ode To Joy was written that way. Many great operatic works were written to the libretto. Bach, Schubert and Gounod all wrote beautiful melodies to the Ave Maria.

Even when the method of songwriting is switching back and forth between lyrical and musical ideas, the lyric and melody are equally important in the shaping of the song.

I suspect one of the reasons lyrics are less skillfully written nowadays is a direct result of poor education and budget cuts in the humanities. When I was young, a great deal of attention was given to classic literature. Poetry was studied more extensively. In the late 60's blank verse became the thing and the study of metered and rhymed verse was abandoned along with other essential language elements. It is no wonder a lot of people aged 45 and younger have difficulty writing English lyrics which require a certain amount of structured meter and rhyme.

Great songs have great lyrics and great music. When the songwriter settles for just "good enough" the end result is often mediocrity.

Too many writers settle for that nowadays and the "hits" on the radio are often the result of marketing strategy. People have little choice but to go for the best of what is available to them and great songs are not always available.

The internet is already changing the music industry and as more people become computer savy, that will change. Imagemaking will become less important and singers and songwriters who don't fit the current industry mold will be able to make a living off their music.

JeanB



[This message has been edited by AKA JeanB (edited 02-14-2004).]


Please visit my facebook EZ3D PopUps for free papercraft templates. Great for beginners of all ages.

Favorite Sites:
http://facebook.com/EZ3DPopUps
http://ez3dpopups.blogspot.com/
http://harrietschock.com
http://jpfolks.com
http://phillipmartin.com


Joined: Sep 2003
Posts: 686
K
Serious Contributor
Offline
Serious Contributor
K
Joined: Sep 2003
Posts: 686
There were actually quite a few instrumental hits back in the late 50's, primarily guitar melodies and a few piano leads.

Link Ray had a major guitar hit with "Rumble." There were others, but my memory has faded regarding the specifics of atrists who didn't come from my neighborhood. Then there were Roger Williams piano instrumental hits, one after another.

Since the subject of this thread is "why are lyrics called songs?" perhaps the most unbiased answer comes directly from the Copyright Office. Lyrics alone are not songs. They can be classified as "tone" poems, assuming anybody knows exactly what that means, or poetry. Until both lyric and music in the form of a lead sheet or actual musical recording are submitted, there is no song, just words.

P.E. Knudsen


P.E. Knudsen
Joined: Mar 2002
Posts: 2,096
T
Top 100 Poster
Offline
Top 100 Poster
T
Joined: Mar 2002
Posts: 2,096
Quote
<font face="Verdana, Arial" size="2">Originally posted by Knute:
There were actually quite a few instrumental hits back in the late 50's, primarily guitar melodies and a few piano leads.

</font>



There have been others since, but they ARE rare. Herb Alpert had a few: "A Taste Of Hoeny," Spanish Flea," and a big one in the 80's called "Rise."

Chuck Mangione had a big hit with "Feel's So Good."

I seem to remember several tv or movie themes that were hits, like the theme form "St. Elsewhere," the theme from "Rockford Files," and "Axel F" from Beverly Hills Cop. Was the theme form Hill Street Blues a hit? I remember hearing it on the radio. Jan Hammer had a hit with the Miami Vice song, too.

Oh, yeah...and there was that disco version of the Star Wars theme. And "TSOP," the theme from Soul Train (there was some background vocals in that one).

I sure can't think of anything in the last ten years, though.

Joined: Sep 2003
Posts: 686
K
Serious Contributor
Offline
Serious Contributor
K
Joined: Sep 2003
Posts: 686
Truman:

I just remembered my all-time favorite instrumental circa the early 80's, I think. It was "Baker Street" with a tenor sax lead. Oh, that reminds me, let us not forget Kenny G. He has had some hit albums in the 90's and they definately were instrumental.

P.E. Knudsen


P.E. Knudsen
Joined: Apr 2001
Posts: 8,574
JPF Mentor
Offline
JPF Mentor
Joined: Apr 2001
Posts: 8,574
Knute,

I thought Baker Street, by Gerry Rafferty, had lyrics. Maybe there was an istrumental version?

On Rafferty's song, that was British saxaphonist, Phil Kenzie, currently living here in Nashville. Phil played on songs by Rafferty, Al Stewart "Year of the Cat," the Eagles, and the Beatles. I've heard him play in an R&B cover band here, he played alto, and everything he played was a hook.

All the Best,
Mike

------------------
Mike Dunbar Music


You've got to know your limitations. I don't know what your limitations are. I found out what mine were when I was twelve. I found out that there weren't too many limitations, if I did it my way. -Johnny Cash

It's only music.
-niteshift

Mike Dunbar Music

Joined: Nov 2002
Posts: 539
T
Serious Contributor
Offline
Serious Contributor
T
Joined: Nov 2002
Posts: 539
Quote
<font face="Verdana, Arial" size="2">Originally posted by Knute:
[<<<Since the subject of this thread is "why are lyrics called songs?" perhaps the most unbiased answer comes directly from the Copyright Office. Lyrics alone are not songs. They can be classified as "tone" poems, assuming anybody knows exactly what that means, or poetry. Until both lyric and music in the form of a lead sheet or actual musical recording are submitted, there is no song, just words.>>>

P.E. Knudsen [/B]</font>


Actually your answer is still invalid towards the actual question. The instigator of the thread has asked *why* people refer to their lyrics as songs (not what the definition of lyric is via the Copyright Office).
I remain to suggest it's a simple issue of people presenting the lyrics to songs they are working on, and they subsequently ask you to check out a song, yet offer only a lyric. It's a simple slip in terminology, and this whole thread is making a mountain out of a molehill.
[Linked Image]

-gary

Joined: Sep 2003
Posts: 686
K
Serious Contributor
Offline
Serious Contributor
K
Joined: Sep 2003
Posts: 686
Mike:

Actually "Baker Street" did have a lyric, sort of. Still, all I remember about it is the sweet sax melody. But I am primarily an arranger and composer, not a lyricist, so no surprise there.

Gary:

A lyric alone is not a song, but may well lead to one. I look at many lyrics and hear music, but many others I see only poetry. "Lyric" writers can call their creation a song if they choose, but somewhere along the line a composer and arranger will have to agree with them.

P.E. Knudsen


P.E. Knudsen
Joined: May 2001
Posts: 5,581
Top 50 Poster
Offline
Top 50 Poster
Joined: May 2001
Posts: 5,581
Yeah the subject of which is more important, lyrics or music has come up many times on this and other boards. But wasn't the original post on this thread thus: "I'm a little confused by quite a few posts I've read where people ask for critiques of a "song" they've written--and it turns out to be just words"? With that alone in mind as opposed to the lyrics vs. music argument I must admit that I've often been puzzled by how one can call a lyric that has not been put to music a song.

Now if a lyricist who doesn't play an instrument has a head tune to the lyric at the time of writing the lyric surely it is indeed a song because it does have a melody, the quality of the melody being another matter. They are posting on a lyric critique site and are asking for feedback on the lyric itself. Perhaps later they will find a collaborator who will work with them and compose a new melody or an improvement of the head tune the lyricist had when writing. In that case it is still a song but with a different melody.

My question and the one I believe the original poster was posing is concerning a lyricist who posts a lyric that was written with no intention of a melody, probably hoping someone who composes music/melody will take an interest somewhere along the line and add music/melody. In this case I don't see how the lyric can be correctly designated a song. It might be an excellent lyric that really cries out for added music making it a complete song but at that point is it not merely a prospective part of what might end up being a song? I think that is the distinction of the question posed. And of course, unless I am familiar with the lyricist him/herself and know they only write lyrics from a form or rhythmic perspective I have no way of knowing if there is at least a head tune involved at all. Or if they clue us in when they post the lyric.

I guess it is equally true that a composer with a piece of music that cries out for lyric content is not yet a song either but an instrumental piece, piece of music or however it should properly be designated at that point. When that musical piece is married to words it would then be a true song. That is what makes sense to me concerning the original question here. Anyway that's my take. The argument of which is more important, lyric or music/melody it seems to me, is another mater altogether.

Steve Biederman


I'm the only person here who is not unique.
Joined: Jul 2001
Posts: 4,372
Top 100 Poster
Offline
Top 100 Poster
Joined: Jul 2001
Posts: 4,372
Cisco Kid (GarY) has it right..

(We do grow 'em smart in Illinois !)

A song is lyrics and melody (or melody only)
To be a song (tecnically) there must be some melodic content of some kind..

BUT..

I would certainly agree that if a lyricist wants to call their work a "song", that's fine...there is no law involved,,,they can call it whatever they want...it's really just semantics and something else to occupy our minds so we don't have time to think about dying !

It's fun to see how far we can digress from the original intent of a thread..
I certainly plead guilty...

It's kewl !

Can anybody here sing "Song of Songs" from the Bible ?

I'm hearing a minor kind of deal...maybe..oh...94bpm..with lots of little drum sounds and bells.....

Yeah.....

bob Young

Joined: Nov 2002
Posts: 539
T
Serious Contributor
Offline
Serious Contributor
T
Joined: Nov 2002
Posts: 539
[QUOTE]Originally posted by bob young:
[B]Cisco Kid (GarY) has it right..

(We do grow 'em smart in Illinois !)>>>


A tip-o'-the-hat and big thank ye to Mr. Young I reckons!

And ya know, all this brings a "song" to my mind--- by the greatest musician of all time... wait..the greatest writer...no.. I'm confused..but here's the "song":

-outro-
"I am music... and I write the soooooooooooooooongs!"

....exceptin' fer when I'm only a-writin' a dad-gum lyric, o'course


[Linked Image] -gary

Joined: Aug 2002
Posts: 139
S
Serious Contributor
Offline
Serious Contributor
S
Joined: Aug 2002
Posts: 139
It is interesting to me that many of you have responded that the melody is the hard part, or at least harder than lyrics. I find coming up with catchy music is a piece of cake. I can typically come up with a couple of melodies an evening, and hooks are easy. But I'm lucky if I can come up with 3 or 4 decent sets of lyrics a year. Yet many of you are implying that lyricists are a dime a dozen.

Of course, maybe it is how we define a decent set of lyrics. Many of the lyrics I've heard or read, even for "hit" songs, either don't say anything or say the same thing as many others have said many times before and are rather trite. Maybe we have different standards for what is a decent set of lyrics and what is a decent melody. To me, what makes either the melody or lyrics decent is that I find myself wanting to play or say them repeatedly. If I catch myself doing it unconsciously, that's even better. Using this test, many "lyrics" fail miserably.

For me, I don't really have to make an effort to write music for good lyrics. With good lyrics, the music automatically comes just in reading the lyrics, due to the phrasing of the lyrics, where the accented and strong words fall, rhyming patterns, the syllable counts, etc. If the lyrics aren't already suggesting a melody, then maybe the lyrics need improvement.

------------------
Stone Marmot
www.stonemarmot.com
Stone Marmot on Soundclick
Alternative pop-rock music:
Definitely rock, somewhat pop, but a bit more experimental.


Stone Marmot
http://www.stonemarmot.com
Alternative pop-rock music:
Definitely rock, somewhat pop, but a bit more experimental.
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 191
H
Serious Contributor
Offline
Serious Contributor
H
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 191
I would rephrase that, poets are a dime a dozen. Poetry in motion is a song. I know many people that write poetry and have no idea about song writing. So many times I have been handed a poem and asked to put music to it. Very difficult. Most of the time when I write a song I have the phrasing in my mind which is a direct path to what the melody will be.

As far as which is more important, words or melody, I think a lot of that depends on the genre.

For me, the lyrics are harder than the melody. I can write a song every ten minutes, but, 99.9% of them would be junk.
Coming up with a unique idea, or a new approach to an old idea, and writing a flowing story with a catchy hook is not easy.

I used to write every song I thought about.
Every idea went down on paper. And I would say that it was good practice, but now I write only the ones that I feel have some merit in possibly being used commercially.
I have folders full of garbage, but my catalog consists of about 10% of my overall write.

Joined: Mar 2002
Posts: 212
E
Serious Contributor
Offline
Serious Contributor
E
Joined: Mar 2002
Posts: 212
I agree with those who say that lyricists only seem to be a dime a dozen. Maybe lyricists are, but good lyricists are not. But I am biased.

http://hometown.aol.com/easyhero/index.html

I would like to suggest that, in general, music is better at getting attention, which tends to make the music more responsible for creating "hit" songs. But I think great songs are songs with great lyrics, and I think they are what make the "song" endure. Trying humming one of the Psalms.


Award-winning, original acoustic songs with "the kind of lyrics that make Nashville writers salivate."
Joined: Jun 2001
Posts: 527
R
Serious Contributor
Offline
Serious Contributor
R
Joined: Jun 2001
Posts: 527
Quote
<font face="Verdana, Arial" size="2">Originally posted by lijemtu:
Hey Robert,

I see you had this same arguement in Aug. 2001. In fact you could have cut and pasted a lot of what you said. Even declared yourself the winner. Looks like you do it just for the sport of it. Must be an attorney. [Linked Image] See ya around.

Bill

</font>


Didn't know anyone would be interested in keeping track of such an archive... that sort of attention to detail is normally commendable, but in this case I'd say (since you decided to make it personal) that you really ought to get some sort of life.

Good discussions, like good stories, sometimes bear retelling. Assuming of course the points, and not the man, are addressed. Con Te Partiro, kid.

Joined: Aug 2002
Posts: 139
S
Serious Contributor
Offline
Serious Contributor
S
Joined: Aug 2002
Posts: 139
I agree with EasyHero's last points: It takes a strong melody and/or strong musical hook to originally get someone's attention, but for repeated listens, you need strong lyrics.

Of course there are exceptions. We were just doing "Barracuda" by Heart the other day and I had to do the backup vocals. This was the first time I ever really paid attention to the lyrics. Even though I always loved the song, after finally reading the lyrics completely for the first time, the lyrics are rather obscure and not that great. Still like the song, though.

------------------
Stone Marmot
www.stonemarmot.com
Stone Marmot on Soundclick
Alternative pop-rock music:
Definitely rock, somewhat pop, but a bit more experimental.


Stone Marmot
http://www.stonemarmot.com
Alternative pop-rock music:
Definitely rock, somewhat pop, but a bit more experimental.
Joined: Jun 2001
Posts: 527
R
Serious Contributor
Offline
Serious Contributor
R
Joined: Jun 2001
Posts: 527
RobertK, you are an intelligent person and I refuse to buy that you actually believe that salary determines intrinsic value. I just do not accept that anyone really believes that.

Intrinsic, schminsic... the market value determines the salary (hence 'worth'), and while in many cases in our current society crap is rewarded with big bucks, that doesn't mean that the basic principle of more money = more value is undermined. It's more often true and as good a yardstick as any, and like I say, a slugger or quarterback is the "big-name" player for a very good reason. He CAN carry a team on his back and win games, whereas a good defensive player (valuable though he may be) is not of the same worth.

Same as a composer versus a "poor cousin" lyricist, an amusing term I find others using on a different thread.

You keep circling back to the same point. Yes...the public lavishes praise on the slugger, the quarterback, the guy who stays on the island the longest, the girl who eats the most maggots,...and composers. We get that.

Then why do you keep disputing it? I think you're more enamoured of the 'strained corelation' than you are of the truth, otherwise why would you make the snide attempt to compare people who actually produce (sluggers, composers) with 15 minutes of fame reality shows?

There are plenty of great hits with so-so and even poor lyrics, but I can't think of too many great lyrics that carried mediocre tunes.

Rap and hip-hop music. Almost all blues music. Most bluegrass and a lot of country music. Dylan. Chuck Berry. Must I go on?

Puh-lease! Yes, keep going on until you make a valid point. Chuck Berry's musical style carried his songs, not his lyrics (ever hear of the Beach Boys or even the Beatles "Back In The USSR" type of homages?) Same with blues. People love that three chord progression, not the 'message behind the music'. Rap and hip-hop songs are not "carried by the words", they are hits because of the excitement of the performer and the relentlessly driving rhythm that carries that entire genre. Bluegrass? Merely niche, and again, it's the music that people like (though it all sounds the same) and they're not clapping their hands and tapping their toes to the words, are they? Or are you saying that people like bluegrass because of the lyrics? Most people couldn't name a bluegrass song on a bet, but if you told somebody to "quick, gimme some bluegrass" they probably could play air banjo and dee-da-dee-dee voice out something like The Beverly Hillbillies or Dueling Banjos.

Dylan approaches a more rational example to the other side of this debate. But he's got a long way to go before his example can prove the point of lyrics being 'as important', mainly because I think he's more of an industry darling in his recent grammy successes, and his previous salad days of the the sixties was more being in the right place at the right time and married to that generation. I believe one of his biggest hits was Rainy Day Women, aka "Everybody Must Get Stoned". Great lyrics for one of his biggest hits, eh? It's the personality of the performer and reputation that sometimes carries the fame far beyond what the actual work merits. Additionally, the fact that he writes and performs his own music provides a tremendous help to getting his lyrics 'out there'. Admittedly, he at least has a handful of cuts from other artists doing his material, and that's one true sign of a good/great songwriter. But is that because of the lyric or the music? I still can't make out all the words when listening to All Along The Watchtower by Hendrix... wonder what made that song so popular, hmmmmmmmmm?

If the lyrics are what are allegedly 'selling' certain songs, then people would be able to recall them as quickly as the more mediocre music for a given "great lyrics" song, right?

No. Not right. Recall is not what makes a hit record. People LIKING it is what makes a hit record.

ARGH! And the reason they LIKE it is because the music, first and foremost, and the words only secondarily, if at all.

But it's still the music that brings the most to the table.

SOMETIMES it is. Sometimes not. And that has been my point all along.

Well, I didn't think I'd have to keep belaboring the obvious by saying TRUE, nothing is ALWAYS the case, but my point all along is that you're wrong when you say SOMETIMES, because the vast majority of the time it is, just like SOMETIMES a great defensive play wins a game, but MOST of the time it's hitting or passing or running.

And that's been my point. Look, I'm sorry if the opinion that music is more important sticks in the craw of many "lyrics only" people, but that's the way it is.

Hence, if someone truly has the burning desire to be a 'songwriter', he/she would do well to consider getting themselves some musical training to the point where they can communicate their ideas to 'real musicians' and/or concentrate on networking HARD with people who can compose music, rather than dreaming that they are such impressive wordsmiths that by merely posting on internet boards, savvy composers are going to come a-knocking.

Chr!st Almighty, when he likes of a national treasure like Jimmy Webb can't get arrested for years in NYC, and has the courage to write "The market for 'lyrics only' is non-existent", who are any of us to gainsay him?



[This message has been edited by RobertK (edited 02-17-2004).]

Joined: Dec 2000
Posts: 774
O
Serious Contributor
Offline
Serious Contributor
O
Joined: Dec 2000
Posts: 774
The original question is an easy one [for me]...
A lyric is just a lyric. When it's wedded with a musical arrangement, it's a song.

Which element is more important? That's up to each individual's prejudices/quirks/strengths/weaknesses/mindsets. Music is "harder" for me, but I don't tend to "value" one element over the other. (BTW, I feel that balance makes for the "strongest" songs.)

------------------
Ozone
http://www.soundclick.com/bands/1/ozonepetemusic.htm

Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 304
G
Serious Contributor
Offline
Serious Contributor
G
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 304
Just curious, are y'all arguing about this to escape the terror of the empty page in front of ya?

How many lyrics can dance on the head of a pin? Who cares?

Shut up and write something. Song, lyric, music, broadway show, sonnet, sea chanty, I don't care. Or if you only care to argue, I guess that's fine too, I just won't be checking this thread anymore.

Later, guys, have fun.

Joined: Mar 2002
Posts: 2,096
T
Top 100 Poster
Offline
Top 100 Poster
T
Joined: Mar 2002
Posts: 2,096
"...Rap and hip-hop songs are not "carried by the words"..."

Yikes, this may be the single silliest comment I've ever read on a message board. No...the second silliest.

The funny thing is, I agree with your POV except to degree. I, too, think the melody, more often than the words, pulls in listeners. But I think your "vast majority" comments, and your refusal to accept that "sometimes" the lyric is more important, is just argumentative, rather than sincere.

You stick to your opinion, I'll stick to mine, and have a nice day.

Joined: May 2001
Posts: 13,618
Top 10 Poster
Offline
Top 10 Poster
Joined: May 2001
Posts: 13,618
I call them lyrics until I make a noise with them.
Actual have noted. The people who call a lyric a song are quite often those who couldn't carry a tune in a bucket.
Mostly in their early writing days.
Most figure it eventually and change.
Most times when I critique one that is called a song and is still tuneless, I make a point of saying something like " toward your lyric" hoping the penny will drop.
It is really no big deal.
Just a matter of learning which is the right word to use.
A lesson any one hoping to be a Lyricist has to learn sooner or later.
Graham


------------------
http://www.soundclick.com/bands/2/grahamhendersonmusic.htm

Joined: Sep 2001
Posts: 10,330
Top 10 Poster
Offline
Top 10 Poster
Joined: Sep 2001
Posts: 10,330
I am not a lyrics only person. I write both lyrics and music. When people come up to compliment me on my songs (often they don't even know they are my songs) they always mention that they enjoy both the music AND the lyrics and often stress how important the words are to them.

A person specializing in lyrics is stronger if they have studied music to some degree and understand the challenges they may present to the composer. Likewise a composer is stronger for having studied poetry and lyric writing. It gives both parties a better idea of what can or cannot be done with words and music.

As more and more people become computer literate and acquire the means to download the songs they like rather than the songs they are force fed by music industry marketing, perhaps then we can track which songs are really the most popular and learn the forumula for success. It's an exciting new age.


Please visit my facebook EZ3D PopUps for free papercraft templates. Great for beginners of all ages.

Favorite Sites:
http://facebook.com/EZ3DPopUps
http://ez3dpopups.blogspot.com/
http://harrietschock.com
http://jpfolks.com
http://phillipmartin.com


Joined: Aug 2002
Posts: 7,172
Likes: 29
Top 40 Poster
Online Content
Top 40 Poster
Joined: Aug 2002
Posts: 7,172
Likes: 29
A song is a marriage of music and words,if both are strong you have a hit,even one or the other being strong can bring success,if both are weak you have a flop.The same happens in people's marriages,if both are pulling in the same direction success is assured,one strong partner can still keep it together but if both are flakes the chances of failier greatly increase.

So who is the most important in keeping a marriage together, the man or the woman or the strongest and most determined.The same with lyrics and music.So what makes a person great?It's one that knows he's great but never crowes he's great,a little humility goes a long way in making a great person even greater in other peoples eyes.Chest pounding only gives you a sore chest.Great music inspires great word and vice versa.


The more you taste the bitterness of defeat, the sweeter final victory will be

May the flowers of love forever bloom in your garden of life

http://www.soundclick.com/newsflashsounds

http://www.soundclick.com/newsflashgospel

www.cdbaby.com/all/eca333

www.showcaseyourmusic.com/newsflashsounds
Joined: Jun 2001
Posts: 527
R
Serious Contributor
Offline
Serious Contributor
R
Joined: Jun 2001
Posts: 527
and your refusal to accept that "sometimes" the lyric is more important, is just argumentative, rather than sincere.

Sheesh. Throughout these posts I've allowed that "sometimes" the lyric is more important.

The main dispute was with the statement that "sometimes" the music is more important, to which I maintained the "vast majority" of the time the music was more important.

Since you want to throw around words like "silliness" and such (who's being argumentative?), let me repost some of the quotes of my previous posts:

I reiterate: this is not to say that words mean nothing. The combination of great music and words make magic indeed, the bedrock of much of what survives the test of time.

But it's still the music that brings the most to the table.


Note "most" <> "all".

Well, I didn't think I'd have to keep belaboring the obvious by saying TRUE, nothing is ALWAYS the case, but my point all along is that you're wrong when you say SOMETIMES, because the vast majority of the time it is, just like SOMETIMES a great defensive play wins a game, but MOST of the time it's hitting or passing or running.

Note that "vast majority of the time" does allow that "sometimes" the opposite can occur (namely, lyrics carry the music).

And if you think it's "silly" to say that in the rap and hip-hop genres it's not the words that carry the song, but the driving rhythm of the song and the excitement of the crowd and dynamics of the performer, next time you're in a room of people frenetically jumping up and down to the likes of one of the latest hits, as soon as the song is over, ask a few of the folks to repeat even two lines of what they just heard. (I'd try the experiment myself, but I'd look "silly" in such a club).

Maybe it's biased of me to even say it, but using rap and hip-hop as an argument for the importance of lyrics over music is beyond silly.

And for some of the other posters who seem to be harping on 'instrumentals', early on in one of the first posts that issue was answered, to wit:

Missing the point, again - why does "music is more important" have to mean "no words at all"? Composers mean those who write music, whether it's to a symphony or to a pop hit.

It's nice to have 45 years experience, but only if it doesn't appear to be 5 years experience 9 times over.


[This message has been edited by RobertK (edited 02-19-2004).]

Joined: Sep 2003
Posts: 4,199
B
Top 100 Poster
Offline
Top 100 Poster
B
Joined: Sep 2003
Posts: 4,199
Robert,

You demean only yourself by insulting someone of Bob Young's ability in such a flippant manner



------------------
We too often throw around the word "great" like it was a frisbee, instead of the manhole cover it should be.


Joined: Jun 2001
Posts: 527
R
Serious Contributor
Offline
Serious Contributor
R
Joined: Jun 2001
Posts: 527
Quote
<font face="Verdana, Arial" size="2">Originally posted by lijemtu:
Robert,
You demean only yourself by insulting someone of Bob Young's ability in such a flippant manner
</font>


Yeah, it's okay when you and your cronies turn this discussion into a personal insult fest at my expense (e.g., "You were wrong then....you're wrong now...Nice try kid..
Better luck next time" which was not only condescending, but especially inane since he mentions the 'instrumentals' issue that had already been addressed) but...

When I reply (and with more restraint than those who direct their barbs at me personally) then I'm demeaning myself.

I thought I told you to go get a life.

And since the most vocal opponents would rather aim their Rooney rifles at me rather than read the entirety of what is being written and address the points with some sort of rational specifics of their own, let's just agree to disagree and move on - I've already spent too much effort on this thread. Adieu.

[This message has been edited by RobertK (edited 02-19-2004).]

Joined: Jul 2001
Posts: 4,372
Top 100 Poster
Offline
Top 100 Poster
Joined: Jul 2001
Posts: 4,372
RobertK..

I've been insulted many times..

that's OK..

But you're just so Completely wrong headed that it's hard to take you seriously.

I was there when Chuck Berry was first coming along..
First of all, you should know that Chuck didn't have any monster hits in his early days.
Johnny B Goode barely cracked the top 10.
Sweet little 16 and so many more languished in the mid to upper top 40.
The songs have become classics over time..

Their key to success is ALL about the words...the music is run of the mill Rhythm and Blues,.
It haed been around for years..hell..Chucks signature lick goes back to Louis Jordans guitar player (can't think of his name) from back in the early 40's.

Much of what "is" in music is that way because it used to be that way.

Music is a real conservative art form, especially "popular" music.

There certainly was a time when instrumental music was more important and more commercially successful than vocal music.

That time has passed.

Eventually musicologists will catch up.

Those of us that live by what music is and not what it purports to be (like you, I'm afraid) have caught up to the logic already.

A 45 year career 5 years at a time..hmmmmm..interesting concept,,, but I think my current audience would not find my machinations of 45 years ago very entertaing.

I do suggest that I just may have learned something on this road.

It has been said by others on this thread that determining which is essential to the success of a piece (words or music) is impossible.

I agree...once a song has moved into the "hit" area it becomes an impossibiblity to credit the words or the music as the key ingredient.

If you asked Elton if he could go back and write all that music to someone other than Bernie Taupins words but that he would have to live by the result...
I'm sure Elton would say "Thanks but no thanks"

And I think Rainy Day Women was a fine song...it's part of my acoustic act and people young and old love it...and you know what...I play the chords all wrong..nothinkg like Dylans, and they don't knowe the difference.
They all know how to sing "Everybody MUST Get Stoned" and that's all they care about.

God Bless 'Em..
They've got it right..

My advice is..
Take a lesson from them.

And try some Decaf for Crissakes !

Bob (still smiling) Young

Joined: Jun 2001
Posts: 527
R
Serious Contributor
Offline
Serious Contributor
R
Joined: Jun 2001
Posts: 527
Now I know how Michael Corleone felt in GFII ("I keep tryin' to get out, and they keep draggin' me back in!")

I've been insulted many times..

I don't doubt that. [Linked Image]

But you're just so Completely wrong headed that it's hard to take you seriously.

But one who argues that Chuck Berry's words were more important that his music is to be taken seriously?

Let's see: first, a song can be considered a 'hit' or at least popular when it breaks into the top 40. Whether it made #1 or not is immaterial.

Second, whether they were his signature guitar licks first or not, that's what everyone remembers and likes about his songs (and Johnny B. Goode can arguably be considered his signature song), which are now considered classics of rock regardless of how they did on the charts when they first appeared.

But you would have us believe that, say, a chorus like

"Go, Johnny, go... go, go, go Johnny go..., go, go, go Johnny go... go, go, go Johnny go... go... go... Johnny B. Goode"

is what carried that song, and not those guitar licks and driving rhythm?

And surprise, surprise, the other chart-topper with that song, one Johnny Winters, happened to have been a star for his guitarmanship! Not even sure people could understand the words when he sung it.

As I said in a previous post, people love the blues, and those simple "run of the mill" three chords have carried more songs than either of us can count.

Another of his more famous tunes, Sweet Little Sixteen; gee, I recall the Beach Boys borrowing the music from that one and having a monster hit of their own "Surfin' USA". Don't remember them using or wanting the words.

As a matter of fact, after the legal battles died down, take a look at who got the writing credit on Surfin' USA. (Chuck Berry, though he wrote not one word of that lyric). Brian Wilson always did grouse about that.

So, keep arguing the importance of the words, my friend (and yes, I'm still smiling too).

I do suggest that I just may have learned something on this road.

I'm sure you've learned many things in your 45+ years, except one important thing, perhaps the most important... how to admit when you're wrong.

I agree...once a song has moved into the "hit" area it becomes an impossibiblity to credit the words or the music as the key ingredient.

I think unless you can prove that the upwards of 12 million sales of Con Te Partiro all occurred in Italy, that the music and the voices (which in effect are instruments when one doesn't understand the language) played the dominant role on that song.

How about "Achy Breaky Heart"? "Louie, Louie"? "Na, Na, Hey, Hey (Kiss Him Goodbye)"? "Macarena", "Who Let The Dogs Out"? Etc., Etc., Etc., Etc.

People remember the title/hook and/or simple chorus, and that's it, on most popular songs.

Even on the hits with good/great lyrics.

If you asked Elton if he could go back and write all that music to someone other than Bernie Taupins words but that he would have to live by the result...
I'm sure Elton would say "Thanks but no thanks"


This has nothing to do with anything. Of course not, because he's already had a success with those words as the composer and performer. This doesn't prove the words were just as important as his music and his musical persona. Has he had other hits with other lyricists? Mmmm, either they were just as good as Mr. Taupin or there's something about Elton's compositions and his playing of them that makes his songs popular, regardless of who comes up with the words.

And I think Rainy Day Women was a fine song...it's part of my acoustic act and people young and old love it...and you know what...I play the chords all wrong..nothinkg like Dylans, and they don't knowe the difference.
They all know how to sing "Everybody MUST Get Stoned" and that's all they care about.


I would have thought that in 45 years of musical experience one could master the simple chord progression of that bit of fluff, but nevertheless...

As I said in my very first post, people don't remember the words for most songs BEYOND A TITLE, HOOK, or CATCH PHRASE. The fact that everybody likes to join in to sing that hook is you making my point for me. You could do that song a capella in most clubs and people would joyously shout out the key phrase. Proves nothing about the lyrics, just a simple catch phrase that tickles the masses, much as "In Heaven There Is No Beer".

I understand people nowadays follow up Neil Diamond's "Sweet Caroline" chorus intro with the sing-a-long trailer "f!cking sl!t" and have a grand old time.



[This message has been edited by RobertK (edited 02-21-2004).]

Joined: Jul 2001
Posts: 4,372
Top 100 Poster
Offline
Top 100 Poster
Joined: Jul 2001
Posts: 4,372
OK..Robert....

Obviously fact and logic have no place in your world...

So I'll just leave you to enjoy it..

Have a nice ride, and enjoy the music..

I guess I could learn the "right" chords to Rainy Day Women
Maybe you think George Shearing should play the "right" chords to everything as well..
Crosby Stills and Nash have a wonderful new recording of..I think it's "God Bless America"..anyway.;.they don't play any of the "right" chords thru the whole piece

Apparently your grasp of music doesn't include the concept of toying with the changes...or what we musicians call reharmonizing...

If I had more time and/or the inclination I could explain it to you..
I thought that explainig the story of the "driving beat" or whatever in the Chuck Berry songs had been around and done to death long before Chuck got here..that it was indeed the brilliance of the words that carried those songs..
But I guess I didn't make it simple enough for you...
And..yes...Go Johnny Go was brilliant...
If there ain't nothing to it..maybe you'll play us a few of your "hits"
You know...the ones with the beautiful music and the great words...the ones you've been holding back..

But....Hey...I said I was just gonna go and here..

I've said too much already...

Bob ( how could I have been so wrong all these years) Young

[This message has been edited by bob young (edited 02-21-2004).]

Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 346
N
Top 500 Poster
Offline
Top 500 Poster
N
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 346
Hello Everyone, I am a lyricist/songwriter whatever you want to call me. I write words first. I do write the music also, but I prefer others to do that for me. Just to keep the argument going, I do know of a song for which the lyrics are more important than the music, in fact I would be willing to say that the song could've been cut without music and still would've had nationwide impact and still been a #1. The song is Alan Jackson's "Where Were You". Listen to that song again and tell me the words aren't more important. I am not a biased person, I simply think we all feel that out part(s) of whatever are more important than others. We think this because we are human. I appreciate all music and all genres. In fact, I usually write my country lyrics while listening to rap. I'm just a weird duck. I just believe that music and words are usually both required of a song to make it great. Would that #1 hit still be #1 if it didn't have words? The same goes if it didn't have music... This is the never-ending discussion where there is not real right answer. Thanks for reading.



------------------
Nick

Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 6
Y
Casual Observer
Offline
Casual Observer
Y
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 6
Quote
<font face="Verdana, Arial" size="2">Originally posted by NHolbrook:
Hello Everyone, I am a lyricist/songwriter whatever you want to call me. I write words first. I do write the music also, but I prefer others to do that for me. Just to keep the argument going, I do know of a song for which the lyrics are more important than the music, in fact I would be willing to say that the song could've been cut without music and still would've had nationwide impact and still been a #1. The song is Alan Jackson's "Where Were You". Listen to that song again and tell me the words aren't more important. I am not a biased person, I simply think we all feel that out part(s) of whatever are more important than others. We think this because we are human. I appreciate all music and all genres. In fact, I usually write my country lyrics while listening to rap. I'm just a weird duck. I just believe that music and words are usually both required of a song to make it great. Would that #1 hit still be #1 if it didn't have words? The same goes if it didn't have music... This is the never-ending discussion where there is not real right answer. Thanks for reading.

</font>


I can't believe any song would be released as a single never mind become a hit with no music. In country music the lyric is king (even though there are plenty of hit country songs with very cliche and unoriginal lyrics) however, without music and melody you don't have a song and no publisher artist, etc., will give you the time of day. At either the ASCAP or BMI website there is a link to a round table discussion with Nashville Publishers and the number one most important thing they were looking for was a great lyric followed by a great melody. There have been songs with no lyrics which have been hits, such as songs by Kenny G and Edgar Winter and songs with no instruments like "Don't worry be happy" but never a song with no melody. The official definition of a song includes the word poem, but in the real world a song contains music and/or melody and 99% of the time lyrics. Lyrics alone are words on a paper not a song, no matter how we spin it.

[This message has been edited by Ynot (edited 02-27-2004).]

Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 346
N
Top 500 Poster
Offline
Top 500 Poster
N
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 346
Hey Ynot, I was simply stating my opinion that they are both equally important in their own right. We could argue about it all day long. The bottom line is that without words, commercial music is non-existant and without music the same would happen. We need both. I write with a melody in my head and there is nobody else in the world that can hit that melody 100% like it is in my head. I hear this the minute i sit down to write a song. And I do write songs, but I prefer to only write lyrics. This is definately a hot topic and I agree with all perspectives. I only belive that you have to have both sitting on the same pedistal for either to be worth a damn.

------------------
Nick

Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 6
Y
Casual Observer
Offline
Casual Observer
Y
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 6
Nick,
I wasn't harping on you, only stating that there have been hit songs with no lyrics, but never a hit song with no melody. But 99% of the time you need both. The only thing I didn't agree with you about was that a song could be a hit with no music, which I took to mean no melody, my bad.

Joined: Mar 2002
Posts: 2,096
T
Top 100 Poster
Offline
Top 100 Poster
T
Joined: Mar 2002
Posts: 2,096
Quote
<font face="Verdana, Arial" size="2">Originally posted by Ynot:


I wasn't harping on you, only stating that there have been hit songs with no lyrics, but never a hit song with no melody..
</font>



Actually, this is not quite true. Songs without melodies (called recitations) were once rather common, especially in country music. There was a whole sub-genre of "truck driver" songs where recitations were very popular. Porter Waggoner and Bill Anderson used to do a lot of recitations, too.

I can only think of a couple recent examples of a no-melody hits. One was a huge hit that I cannot remember the name of, or the artist, but it was a hit 2 or 3 years ago and it was like a commencement speech, with some stuff about using sunscreen, spoken over a music bed. Alan Jackson also had a recitation hit last year or maybe the year before that. I cannot remember the name of it. Certainly someone will want to claim that these records HAD MUSIC, and that is true, but they HAD NO MELODY, and that is the point.

Joined: May 2003
Posts: 419
K
kit Offline
Serious Contributor
Offline
Serious Contributor
K
Joined: May 2003
Posts: 419
not to be contrarian...

but are people seriously worried about this issue?



------------------
kit malone
http://www.kitmalone.com

Joined: Mar 2002
Posts: 2,096
T
Top 100 Poster
Offline
Top 100 Poster
T
Joined: Mar 2002
Posts: 2,096
Quote
<font face="Verdana, Arial" size="2">Originally posted by kit:
not to be contrarian...

but are people seriously worried about this issue?

</font>


Not me. Are you worried about our discussing it? [Linked Image]

Joined: Sep 2003
Posts: 4,199
B
Top 100 Poster
Offline
Top 100 Poster
B
Joined: Sep 2003
Posts: 4,199
People need to be aware and honest about their strengths and weaknesses. As a lyricist, I could sit down with a musician and direct him to the melody I've got for any lyric I write. But I lack the melodic feel that a great composer has and don't trust that my melody is the strongest possible for my lyrics. But good musicians often have no qualms about attaching their own lame lyrics to their melodies. Put me together with a great, and watch out. Elton John was smart enough to know his limitations. Billy Joel had none. But there aren't very many like him.

Bill

------------------
We too often throw around the word "great" like it was a frisbee, instead of the manhole cover it should be.

[This message has been edited by lijemtu (edited 02-27-2004).]


Joined: May 2001
Posts: 13,618
Top 10 Poster
Offline
Top 10 Poster
Joined: May 2001
Posts: 13,618
I don't know Noel.
I call myself a writer. Not a songwriter. Not a lyricist. Not a composer.
I just write.
In the field of songs, I really class myself as a lyricist even though I have written and recorded to demo stage over 100 songs.
And six of the seven cuts I have are my music.
It is the words that most often comes first, and the imprortant bits to me.
One of the cuts I have, I am on the credits as the keyboard player, because the studio used the midi keybopard backing I wrote as was, for the bed track.
This does not make me want to call myself a musician.
Just something that happened along the way.
I don't see any looking down on somebody by calling them a lyricist if they do words only.
If they can take those words and sing, hum , or whistle a tune they fit to, they are a songwriter in my book.
Same as I don't see anything demeaning in someone being called a composer when they only write music.
There are some great instrumentals out there that simply do not lend themselves well to words being sung to them.
You can call a spade a shovel if you like, but that doesn't make it one.
And both have their seperate , yet complimentary parts to play in the scheme of things.
I learned to write music because some of my poems seemed to sing to me, and I couldn't find any musicians to write music to them, even when I did the sing the melody thing on them.
I'm not wonderful at it but am still learning, and have a whole heap of fun doing it.
I spend a lot of time over on JPF theory forum and it has been a veritable feast for me clue wise.
I recommend it to anybody who want to rise above their percieved posision of "just a lyricist."
Graham



------------------
http://www.soundclick.com/bands/2/grahamhendersonmusic.htm

Joined: Jun 2001
Posts: 527
R
Serious Contributor
Offline
Serious Contributor
R
Joined: Jun 2001
Posts: 527
Is this a jelousey/ inferiority thing? Are they afraid of us being aclaimed better songwriters so they need to demeen us by stateing "They are not songwriters therefore I am more important" to make themselves feel whole?

That paragraph alone speaks volumes...

but not in the way the author intended, I think. [Linked Image]

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3

Link Copied to Clipboard
Support Just Plain Folks

We would like to keep the membership in Just Plain Folks FREE! Your donation helps support the many programs we offer including Road Trips and the Music Awards.


Newest Members
EdKreider, KyleCrawford, LukeMeyers, KimBilbrew, AdamSadowski
21,480 Registered Users
Forum Statistics
Forums118
Topics129,178
Posts1,186,197
Members21,480
Most Online236,505
Jul 1st, 2026
Just Plain Quotes
"Do not endeavor to be the smartest kid in a dumb class. Instead, you are better off being the dumbest kid in the smartest class, where you will be challenged and you will learn. If you aren't growing, you are dying." -Brian Austin Whitney
Today's Birthdays
Andrew Jackman (35), Linziellen (45)
Popular Topics(Views)
1,480,257 Prophecy anyone?
Powered by UBB.threads™ PHP Forum Software 7.7.5