Who's Online Now
4 members (Everett Adams, Gary E. Andrews, texritter, bennash), 182,864 guests, and 5,970 robots.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Register Today!
Welcome to the Just Plain Folks forums! You are currently viewing our forums as a Guest which gives you limited access to most of our discussions and to other features.

By joining our free community you will have access to post and respond to topics, communicate privately with our users (PM), respond to polls, upload content, and access many other features. Registration is fast, simple, and absolutely free; so please join our community today!
ShoutChat
Comment Guidelines: Do post respectful and insightful comments. Don't flame, hate, spam.
What's Going On
Ana Schon
by Gary E. Andrews - 11/16/26 12:11 AM
::: SEXY LADY :::
by bennash - 11/15/26 06:08 PM
The Legend of Martha's Bridge
by texritter - 11/13/26 06:40 PM
Beato back at it
by bennash - 11/10/26 06:37 PM
Lot Long
by Gary E. Andrews - 11/10/26 11:20 AM
Jefferson Thomas
by Gary E. Andrews - 11/10/26 10:43 AM
Everything But The Girl
by Gary E. Andrews - 11/10/26 10:08 AM
Paris Is Burning
by bennash - 11/10/26 04:10 AM
Alacranes RVA Richmond VA
by Gary E. Andrews - 11/09/26 11:39 PM
Earth Libraries, Rock Creek SK
by Gary E. Andrews - 11/09/26 12:10 PM
Truths To Expensive
by bennash - 11/08/26 10:50 PM
Politics HERE only!
by bennash - 11/08/26 02:43 AM
McVie Miller Tribute
by Gary E. Andrews - 11/07/26 11:05 PM
Will We Still Have Songwriters in the Year 5000?
by Fdemetrio - 11/06/26 02:08 PM
SPACE FREQ, Beckley, Charleston WVa
by Gary E. Andrews - 11/05/26 11:49 PM
Blind Pig, Ann Arbor
by Gary E. Andrews - 11/04/26 09:47 AM
Live at The Complex, Dear Banshee
by Gary E. Andrews - 11/04/26 09:28 AM
Just say no to Suno
by Pat Hardy - 11/03/26 02:00 AM
Ian Stahl, Burbank
by Gary E. Andrews - 11/02/26 07:50 AM
This is insane
by bennash - 11/01/26 11:19 AM
Just Another Copyright Lawsuit...
by bennash - 10/29/26 03:19 PM
Radio Is A Box Of Fairy Tales
by bennash - 10/29/26 08:50 AM
Momentum Studios
by Gary E. Andrews - 10/27/26 11:56 PM
Anthony Gomes, Romania
by Gary E. Andrews - 10/27/26 11:47 PM
Vern Riffe Center For The Arts, Motown, Portsmouth
by Gary E. Andrews - 10/27/26 10:56 PM
Vern Riffe Center For The Arts, Motown, Portsmouth
by Gary E. Andrews - 10/27/26 10:55 PM
Andy Frasco
by Gary E. Andrews - 10/27/26 10:08 PM
ConnieConverse
by Bill Draper - 10/27/26 12:21 PM
Dakota Free, The Tape Cassettes
by Gary E. Andrews - 10/27/26 01:34 AM
Benny Sidelinger, Anacortes WA
by Gary E. Andrews - 10/24/26 09:07 PM
Top Posters
Calvin 19,858
Travis david 12,380
Kevin Emmrich 10,943
Jean Bullock 10,330
Kaley Willow 10,240
Two Singers 9,649
Fdemetrio 9,239
Joice Marie 9,186
Mackie H. 9,003
glynda 8,688
Mike Dunbar 8,574
Tricia Baker 8,318
couchgrouch 8,240
Colin Ward 7,911
Corey 7,357
Sunset Poet 7,230
Vicarn 6,916
Mark Kaufman 6,589
ben willis 6,114
Lynn Orloff 5,788
Louis 5,725
Linda Sings 5,608
KimberlyinNC 5,210
Neil Cotton 4,909
Derek Hines 4,893
DonnaMarilyn 4,700
bennash 4,655
Blake Hill 4,528
Bob Cushing 4,389
Roy Cooper 4,303
MFB III 4,237
Bill Osofsky 4,199
Tom Shea 4,195
Cindy Miller 4,178
TamsNumber4 4,172
nightengale 4,096
E Swartz 4,029
beechnut79 3,878
Caroline 3,865
Kolstad 3,845
Dan Sullivan 3,710
Dottie 3,427
joewatt 3,411
Bill Cooper 3,279
John Hoffman 3,199
Skip Johnson 3,027
Pam Hurley 3,007
Terry G 3,005
PopTodd 2,901
Nigel Quin 2,891
Harriet Ames 2,870
MidniteBob 2,764
Nelson 2,616
Tom Tracy 2,558
Jerry Jakala 2,524
Al Alvarez 2,499
Eric Thome 2,448
Hummingbird 2,401
Stan Loh 2,263
Sam Wilson 2,247
Wendy D 2,236
Judy Hollier 2,232
Erica Ellis 2,202
maccharles 2,134
TrumanCoyote 2,096
Rob B. 2,069
Marty Helly 2,041
DukeWill 2,009
floyd jane 1,985
Clint Anglin 1,904
cindyrella 1,888
David Wright 1,866
Clairejeanne 1,851
Cindy LaRosa 1,824
Ronald Boyt 1,675
Iggy 1,653
VNORTH2 1,652
Noel Downs 1,633
Rick Heenan 1,608
Cal 1,574
Bill Draper 1,570
GocartMoz 1,559
Jack Swain 1,554
Pete Larsen 1,537
Ann Tygart 1,529
Tom Breshers 1,487
RogerS 1,481
Tom Franz 1,479
David Gill 1,464
IronKnee 1,455
Chuck Crowe 1,441
Ralph Blight 1,440
Rick Norton 1,435
Kenneth Cade 1,429
Deej56 1,419
bholt 1,411
Letha Allen 1,409
in2piano 1,404
Stan Simons 1,402
mattbanx 1,384
Jen Shaner 1,373
Charlie Wong 1,347
KevinP 1,324
Vondelle 1,316
Tom W. 1,313
Jan Petter 1,301
scottandrew 1,294
lane1777 1,280
Gerry 1,280
DakLander 1,265
PeteG 1,242
Ian Ferrin 1,235
Glen King 1,214
IdeaGuy 1,209
AaronAuthier 1,177
summeoyo 1,174
ckiphen 1,162
Diane Ewing 1,162
joro 1,082
BobbyJoe 1,075
S.DEE 1,040
yann 1,037
9ne 1,035
WesRyan 1,018
Tony A 1,016
argo 986
peaden 984
90 dB 964
Wolvman 960
Jak Kelly 912
krtinberg 890
Petra 883
RJC 845
Brenda152 840
Nadia 829
ant 798
Juan 797
TKO 784
Dayson 781
frahmes 781
teletwang 762
Irwin 757
Andy Kemp 751
Andy K 750
tbryson 737
Jackie444 731
Pat Hardy 706
3daveyO3 704
Dixie 701
Joy Boy 695
Knute 686
Moosesong 679
Lee Arten 678
Katziis 652
R.T.MOORE 638
quality 637
CG King 622
douglas 621
R&M 614
Mel 614
NaomiSue 601
Shandy 590
Ria 587
TAMERA64 583
qbaum 570
nitepiano 566
pRISCILLA 556
Tink2 553
musica 539
BB Wilbur 536
deanbell 528
RobertK 527
BonzaiWag 523
Roderic 522
goodfolks 499
Zeek 487
Stu 486
Steve P. 481
KathyW 462
allenb 459
MaxG 458
Philjo 454
fanito 448
trush48 448
dmk 442
Rob L 439
arealrush 437
DGR 436
avweek 435
Stephen D 433
Emmy 431
marquez 422
kit 419
Softkrome 417
kyrksongs 415
RRon 408
Laura G. 407
VNORTH 407
Debra 407
eb 406
cuebald 399
EdPerrone 399
Dannyk1 395
Hobart 395
ddreuter 394
Davyboy49 393
Smile 389
GJShades 387
Alek 386
Ezt 384
tone 380
Marla 380
Ann_F 379
iggyiggy 378
coalminer 377
java 374
spidey 371
sweetsong 370
danny 367
Jim Ryan 360
papaG 353
Z - man 350
JamesDF5 348
John K 348
Jaden 344
TheBaz 340
Steggy 339
leif 339
tonedeaf 336
rickwork 334
Eddie Ray 332
Johnboy 328
Bob Lever 328
Helicon1 327
lucian 326
Muskie 321
kc 319
Z. Mulls 318
ptondreau 313
ONOFFON 312
Chris B. 310
trush 304
ed323 297
Ellen M 294
markus-ky 294
lizzorn 291
nicnac49 290
Char 286
ktunes 285
Top Likes Received
bennash 148
Rob B. 103
Fdemetrio 103
VNORTH2 68
Previous Thread
Next Thread
Print Thread
Rate Thread
Page 1 of 3 1 2 3
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781
D
Dayson Offline OP
Top 500 Poster
OP Offline
Top 500 Poster
D
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781
Hi Guys,

As Songwriters, I believe we can be some of the Harshest Critics about Songwriting and that can be a good thing, but can it also be a detriment to our being able to make a Career at of it?

I notice there's always on ongoing debate between those writing for the Commercial Market and those that do not.
I don't know if it's just me, but there seems to be a bias by some who believe that Writing for the Commercial Market is somehow 'Shallow' 'Easy' 'Unworthy' ect.

The Music on the Charts are always pointed out as an example of what's Wrong with Today's Music.
There always seems to be some Resentment towards the people who are Successful in the Commercial Market by those who are Not but want to be Successful in whatever Market their Songs fit.
Why is this?

Is it possible that those who Criticize another Writer's work in this way are Hurting Themselves?

If you are able to point out What's So Bad in another Writer's Work, why aren't YOU able to point out What's stopping YOU from being Successful in the Field that you Target?

If you are Criticizing that a Song is Too Simple- or Could be written by a 5th Grader,then why aren't YOU able to adjust your Overly Intellectual Lyric into something that is easily Consumed by the Masses to have that kind of Success that you crave?

If you fail to see why a Song whether you like it or not is Successful, how do you tell If YOURS will be?
I think this kind of Thinking is the #1 factor or difference between those who have Attained Success and Those who have not.

I'm not asking this question to start a 'Fight' with anyone, I just want to know why the Judgement?
-Dana





Joined: Jul 2010
Posts: 3,710
Top 100 Poster
Offline
Top 100 Poster
Joined: Jul 2010
Posts: 3,710
Dana, If you're referring to my criticisms of the Nashville songwriter myth, you're hiding behind a straw man. My point is only that you won't find any great songs on the country charts, which seems to undermine the legend of Nashville being a center of great songwriting. All the other accusations you toss around about shallowness, unworthiness, resentment and envy are your own observations. Answer the questions yourself if you think they're interesting. I don't argue with straw men.


Write from your heart, not what you think others want to hear.

https://dansullivan2.bandcamp.com

http://www.cdbaby.com/cd/dansullivan2
Joined: Dec 2006
Posts: 5,830
Top 50 Poster
Offline
Top 50 Poster
Joined: Dec 2006
Posts: 5,830
Hey Dana,

It's just the idealogical point of view between a Big Mac and a five star restaurant. If you've studied food, you clearly know the difference. Same with songs. Some are made with a musicians point of view in mind, others are made for mass consumption.

Each has it's place. Neither is better or worse, just designed for a particular purpose. I prefer real food, but occasionally I love a grease burger too. To each his own. smile

cheers, niteshift

PS - You want to make a career out of songwriting ? Good luck !


Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781
D
Dayson Offline OP
Top 500 Poster
OP Offline
Top 500 Poster
D
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781
Hi Dan,

I am in part referring to your post about Nashville Songwriters and a lot of other posts with the same content.
I think I'm asking a legitimate question based on my observation of these types of posts.
If you think I am 'Hiding' behind a 'Straw Man' by asking this question, then you are free to think that way.
I'm not pointing a finger at you personally.
I am speaking to my own observations, you are free to disagree or not.
Based on your observation there are no great Songwriting being done in Nashville?
The Songs you listed are all Contemporary Country.
The ones that by my observations tend to be more Commercial than the Bob Dylan one you posted as Great?
So back to my question why the Judgement?

Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781
D
Dayson Offline OP
Top 500 Poster
OP Offline
Top 500 Poster
D
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781
Hi Nite=)

Can't we accept that there are two different views and still
appreciate what each has to offer?
I'm not depending on 'Luck' in the Music Business.
Thanks for posting.-Dana

Joined: Jul 2010
Posts: 3,710
Top 100 Poster
Offline
Top 100 Poster
Joined: Jul 2010
Posts: 3,710
Dana, I have no idea what you mean when you ask "Why the judgement?" Everybody makes musical judgments. You, me, everybody.


Write from your heart, not what you think others want to hear.

https://dansullivan2.bandcamp.com

http://www.cdbaby.com/cd/dansullivan2
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781
D
Dayson Offline OP
Top 500 Poster
OP Offline
Top 500 Poster
D
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781
Hi Dan,

I agree, we all make Musical Judgements,
My point in asking the question, is must we point to another Writer's Work and take it down a notch or so in order to justify
Why we don't like it?

Can't we find a way to express that we don't care for that particular kind of Song instead of saying it's 'Lacking' something great in it?

I'm not making a Judgement on you personally Dan, that's not my intention.


Joined: Jul 2010
Posts: 3,710
Top 100 Poster
Offline
Top 100 Poster
Joined: Jul 2010
Posts: 3,710
Dana, I knew a lawyer who asked fewer questions during a trial than you do in the forum. You're not an attorney, are you?

There are very few good songs, fewer great songs and even fewer great songwriters. But that's just my subjective opinion.

I suppose there are different ways to express the opinion that a particular song doesn't meet my standard of greatness. But other than a roll of the eyes, the easiest way to convey my criticism is to simply say I don't think it's a great song. Which I did in the story sampling the top 5 country songs.

What's the point of beating around the bush?


Write from your heart, not what you think others want to hear.

https://dansullivan2.bandcamp.com

http://www.cdbaby.com/cd/dansullivan2
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 8,463
Top 20 Poster
Offline
Top 20 Poster
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 8,463
Criticism can be both helpful and hurtful......it depends upon the kind of criticism given....and asked for.
With the music industry being such a closed shop it is very difficult damn near impossible to break into so most performers and songwriters just have to stand on the side lines as an observer. A heck of a lot of people, more than you can imagine, CAN write and perform songs just as good if not better than what they hear charting. It is no wonder that so many people have such a bad opinion of the pop business for that very reason. It is also a fact that some, myself included, have no interest in lowering the bar and writing to a dumbed down formula just to make a few quid. To put it another way if I were to open a restaurant it would be fine dining rather than junk food. Whilst from time to time eat junk food I would not want to make it a habit or try to make a living from it....cause like junk music it is bad for you and is not challenging enough to manufacture or prepare.

Joined: Dec 2008
Posts: 10,927
Likes: 91
Top 10 Poster
Offline
Top 10 Poster
Joined: Dec 2008
Posts: 10,927
Likes: 91
"but I know many people say they cant listen to a song without analyzing it"

I'll leave the analyzing up to the honorable music professors. I’m more interested in making music.

John smile

Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781
D
Dayson Offline OP
Top 500 Poster
OP Offline
Top 500 Poster
D
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781
LOl,

Dan, what does my 'asking' questions have to do with this?
is it a crime to ask questions?
That you are uncomfortable with one that might pertain to you is not my problem.
If I ask a question it's because I might learn something that I didn't know before.
I might learn what someone thinks about a certain situation, like the one we are discussing.
You are free of course not to answer any of them.
But I hope it will not come to that.
Btw, How are you today?

Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781
D
Dayson Offline OP
Top 500 Poster
OP Offline
Top 500 Poster
D
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781
Hi Jim,

I can understand your point of view about the challenges of being heard, it's very competitive out there.
But my point was about looking down on another Songwriter's work and passing judgement as being less than.
Though we are in competition we are not 'enemies'

So I don't see the need to bring out the 'Firing' squad lol
When someone else is having the Success we wish we were having.

When I first started on my Songwriting Journey, I started to think
along the same lines, but as I became more confident in my own abilities as a Songwriter, I realized that I was only hurting myself with that kind of view.

I don't like everything that is out there today on the charts, but I can certainly respect what it took to get them there.
Thank you for your post.-Dana

Joined: Feb 2005
Posts: 7,831
Top 30 Poster
Offline
Top 30 Poster
Joined: Feb 2005
Posts: 7,831
Hi Dana and JPF participants:

Criticism can be a good thing if done tactfully. After all, those beginning to write or sing have pretty thin skins and are easily decimated by harsh words. It's so easy to be negative and so difficult to be positive. (Especially since the song or work involved may be stunningly horrible... LOL!) All of us started with varying proficiences. Nurturing certainly helps.

In many ways, I agree with Dan regarding what is mostly coming out of Music City these days. Don't get me wrong, there are some great songs entering the market and alot depends on the status and talent of the artist selcted to do the song for label "X" or "Y."

I also believe that talent should be the first element to consider but luck really does play a great deal in the success one can (or can't) achieve in today's overcrowded market. Still, a great song will usually find a way to be discovered. The luck factor is also heavily weighted in the cadre of friends an artist or writer has been able to cultivate with the ability to boost their career.

From my limited perspective, I don't pay much attention to the charts these days. Most are rigged to some degree by payola or other factors such as enforced playlists by the big dogs at the HQ station for a network of stations.

I like to measure the popularity and success of a song ten years down the road. Is it still bringing in the bacon? How many artists have "covered" it? That's what it is about for the most part. The rest is having the desire to have one's music hang around long after the writer is "in the ground."

No need to argue about any of this. We all have opinions and most of us are destined to follow our own path of thinking regardless of the facts or figures. I'm probably the world's worst when it comes to being opinionated... with the possible exception of my friend and "wee bairn" from across the great pond in the land of the Scots. (Big Jim, whom I enjoy alot.)

Happy New Year everyone and thanks for this interesting and often debated topic, Dana.

Dave

Joined: Jul 2010
Posts: 29,275
"
Top 10 Poster
Offline
Top 10 Poster
"
Joined: Jul 2010
Posts: 29,275
HiDee Y'All!

HiYa Brother Dana!

Somewhere during my 30+ Years Writing-Away, I quit worrying about "Is It 'Commercial'" & just focused on writing Interesting, preferably 'Different-Enough' Songs. Some HAVE made it on Others' CDs...some even make me beer money.

When I crit somebody's song, I'm sometimes thinking about making it More-Palatable to a Publisher/Singer IF it looks like a Commercial Write. But more-often, I'll offer some sugs to make it have more sense, or sing-smoother. Or Sug that it go "More Comedic"..or "Shorter"..or whatever I think the lyric/melody needs to make it a better song. (As far as An Audience is concerned.)

I'm my OWN "Worst Critic"..took a Decade-off Songwritin' '89-99, when nothing seemed to be happening in the Commercial Songwriting World (Have a FINE Early Electric Fan Collection as-a-result!) but now I'm a Decade-Behind where I'd like to be as a Writer--

WAS up 'til 4AM this morning researchin' 10 Really GREAT (IMHO) Nashville Songs that came out in 2012, as a bit of a Rebuttal to Dan's Critique on the Scene there, a bit ago. (& I didn't think TOO Much of that Dylan's Latest..lyrically..that he put up as "Exhibit A" of Fine Writing either...Google the lyrics & see Why!) I'll add I attended a Clearwater Concert a few yrs back where Dylan and Willie played back-to-back, & Willie was THE Crowd-Pleaser. Enough-Said. Bob's a Hero..Willie's onea My Favorite Writers. Different Strokes/Different Smokes... ;-)>

Here's a Sneak-Preview of 5 of my Examples that I think Both of the Above Guys'd nod their heads in-Appreciation: (No Particular Order) "Fly Over States" (Sung by Jason Aldean, co-penned by Neil Thrasher & Michael Dulaney).."Home" (Dierks Bentley).."Kiss Tomorrow Goodbye" (Luke Bryan).."Hard to Love" (Lee Brice, penned by Benjamin Glover, Billy Montana, John Ozier)..& "Cowboys & Angels" (Justin Lynch, penned by Josh Leo & Tim Nichols [who also co-ed on "Live Like You Were Dyin' a few years earlier)... (Still checkin'-up on Who Wrote What on the Other Five.) But Nashville still writes some Great Ones that ALSO "Go Commercial".... (& I, for one, sure don't poo-pooh Taylor Swift in the least...even if she Pop-Rocks AWAYYY Occasionally!)

&..my guess is she wrote that "MEAN" one just for therapy, never expecting it'd be a Hit.

So...my advice to ANY aspiring songwriter'd be Have FUN, don't let the Critics Dog-Ya-Down, just keep AT it..(& don't ever be afraid to LISTEN to the Radio to keep a Finger on "What's Commercial" Currently.) Get all the Feedback Ya CAN...but never say "die"...You may even surprise Yourself..Someday!

Last edited by "Tampa Stan" Good; 01/09/13 03:33 AM.
Joined: Apr 2001
Posts: 8,574
JPF Mentor
Offline
JPF Mentor
Joined: Apr 2001
Posts: 8,574
Criticism should be taken in the spirit in which it is given. If it is not in a helpful spirit, then it is best ignored.

Of course, it is hard to ignore a criticism of something as important to someone as their art. It becomes helpful to develop a perspective which considers the source of the criticism.

Is the critic someone you would want to like your work? Is your belief in your work so weak that you would change it to please a critic? My wife has a wonderful saying that applies to the harmful critic. "Do me a favor...don't like me."


You've got to know your limitations. I don't know what your limitations are. I found out what mine were when I was twelve. I found out that there weren't too many limitations, if I did it my way. -Johnny Cash

It's only music.
-niteshift

Mike Dunbar Music

Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781
D
Dayson Offline OP
Top 500 Poster
OP Offline
Top 500 Poster
D
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781
Hi Dave,

I can appreciate you letting us in on your view of this.
Yeah, I guess for some it can be easier to go 'Negative'
I'm simply trying to shed a little light on how it could possibly be holding someone back from their own Successes.

Dave's Quote-

"The luck factor is also heavily weighted in the cadre of friends an artist or writer has been able to cultivate with the ability to boost their career."

This seems to be another big area of disagreement between a lot of us. Talent is an important factor, but I don't believe it should entitle you to Success.
That Cultivating of friends is the other 'Skill Set' we as Songwriters must learn. It's part of the Job.
Just like in any Business one wants to be Successful in.

Sometimes the word 'Luck' can be used by some as a way of saying 'You don't really deserve to be where you are because I know someone who is far more Talented than you.' As another way of tearing down another Writer's Success. jmo

So the broader point is, how does that help us?


Joined: Jul 2010
Posts: 3,710
Top 100 Poster
Offline
Top 100 Poster
Joined: Jul 2010
Posts: 3,710
Stan, You've got a great point. There's no accounting for taste. What I like you may loathe. I may consider a song great, and you may shake your head and wonder why. Some like jazz, some like classical. Some like hip hop, some like Nashville music. Some believe the greatest collection of songwriting talent in the world can be found at latitude/longitude 36.1658° N, 86.7844° W. Others chuckle at the notion.

Nobody likes criticism. But everyone gets it. Mostly, it's best ignored.


Write from your heart, not what you think others want to hear.

https://dansullivan2.bandcamp.com

http://www.cdbaby.com/cd/dansullivan2
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 8,463
Top 20 Poster
Offline
Top 20 Poster
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 8,463
I think honesty is key. If a person displays very little talent yet has made the big time they deserve fair criticism. I for one could never say one thing and think another. If I think they are undeserving I say it. Whilst there is no accounting for taste even within the context of one mans meat is another's poison there are minimum standards that those pop stars who make it should display...sadly few pop stars display these standards. To say that they are no better than the rest is not sour grapes just a simple provable fact.
Most people who make it big are under no illusions......they will freely admit that they are no better or harder working JUST luckier. They should NEVER be immune from criticism.

Joined: Feb 2001
Posts: 2,448
A
Top 200 Poster
Offline
Top 200 Poster
A
Joined: Feb 2001
Posts: 2,448
Writing for the Commercial Market is not 'Shallow' 'Easy' 'Unworthy', It's difficult and an easy area for unsuccessful writers (from a commercial success POV) to have sour grapes.

what's Wrong with Today's Music is my songs aren't on the charts.

Why is this?
Resentment comes from
attempting and failing,
not attempting and failing,
weak attempts and failing and
ignorant attempts and failing.

There are those who are unwilling to change, learn or do what it really takes to be successful.

What's stopping YOU from being Successful in the Field that you Target?


If you fail to see why a Song whether you like it or not is Successful, how do you tell If YOURS will be?
Part of the problem is writing a great song/ creating a great demo. The next and greater problem is to get your song recorded by a relevant artist or a soon to be relevant artist.

#1 factor or difference between those who have Attained Success and Those who have not.
There are many factors that indicate the difference between the haves and the have nots.
"Your First Cut" addresses it well
http://www.yourfirstcut.com
do their Questionaire:
http://www.yourfirstcut.com/questionnaire.php

SongU can be very helpful
http://www.songu.com/IFS

Part of the process is developing the ability to write amazing songs. To do that we need a filter, we need to be able to critique our own songs to create excellence. We need to be able to tell the difference between, writing an exceptional song or if we are once again polishing another turd that needs flushed.

Another part of success comes from relationships, friendships and contacts. Being able to work yourself into situations that are more likely to lead to success. I know a truly talented writer but he's such a pain in the butt, people don't want to work with him.
Some people have a poisoned attitudes.
Some people aren't willing to learn and really do what it takes to be successful.

Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 8,463
Top 20 Poster
Offline
Top 20 Poster
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 8,463
I am sixty this year and have been singing professionally for over four decades. In that time I have gained much experience of just how the music business is run and just how corrupt it can be. I also know just how fickle, gullible, easily influenced and stupid the general public are. I have had first-hand experience of the sharks that control the music industry and prey upon these easily led people. They also exploit performers and songwriters who they control in every way. This has made me sceptical, cynical, disillusioned and arguably wiser. If you do not accept what I am saying then just watch any reality TV like X factor, AI, got talent etc etc. where this whole process is in plain view.
The charts and the shallow pop stars that fill them are generally fairly untalented people put there by luck rather than any other factor. The songs themselves are usually of a pretty poor structure and are heavily reliant on their production quality which the artist has very little influence over, backed by the hype, marketing and the payola etc we all know about. All these things are the main sometimes only reason why songs and artists get to their chart positions. Now there are exceptions to this but they are too few to prove anything other than the rule.
Now I have no wishes or intentions to be a part of this corruptness and am quite happy doing what I do to make a living. I can understand that the lure of the $ and £ sign attracts a lot of people who want a piece of this action. I can also understand that some people genuinely cannot see my stand point in that it is all a big con. They may think they are on a level playing field with a genuine chance to be a star. I wish them luck. I suspect that one day they will grow wiser and be able to see exactly what I am talking about. If I were in their position, did not have the political and moral issues I have and wanted to make the big time I would do all the networking, collabs and other things they do to try to make it. Frankly I think most of it is a complete waste of time unless it gets you introductions to the people who control this sham. You do not really need talent, skill or a great song…you need backing from somebody who controls the industry, you and your future.

Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781
D
Dayson Offline OP
Top 500 Poster
OP Offline
Top 500 Poster
D
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781
Hi Ande,

Great Response post.
I was at Barnes and Noble yesterday reading some new books about
how to improve your Songwriting and it touched on this very subject, about how other Writers limit themselves with this type of thinking. I was like 'wow'!
Haven't had a chance to read the the links but I will, thanks again!-Dana

Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 8,463
Top 20 Poster
Offline
Top 20 Poster
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 8,463
Books on songwriting are a great way to make money...for those who write books on songwriting.....for most others who read these books they are a waste of time.....they either state the blindingly obvious or are totally inappropriate for most aspiring writers needs....I have read a few and none are much good.

The only way to improve is to learn how to play an instrument to a decent level, practice and learn about music composition and lyric writing. ...preferably by proper coaching and mentoring by someone with proven teaching skills.

Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781
D
Dayson Offline OP
Top 500 Poster
OP Offline
Top 500 Poster
D
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781
Hi Jim,

I would have to disagree with you.
I bought a book a couple of months ago, that has changed the game for me.
It affirmed some things that I knew, and made me see the Craft from a different perspective, that makes a invaluable difference.
I re-read it over and over.
Btw, books are considered a form of 'Coaching and Mentoring.'
If you read and write Musical Compositions, obviously you learned from someone who 'Wrote' the book on it.-Cheers-Dana

Joined: Apr 2001
Posts: 20,017
Likes: 34
Top 10 Poster
Offline
Top 10 Poster
Joined: Apr 2001
Posts: 20,017
Likes: 34
If you are someone who thinks all society is so stupid, then why aren't you easily running things,or at least way ahead of the moronic pack in all measurable success (or any for that matter). Food for thought.

The reason people can tell you (correctly sometimes) why your song isn't going to be a hit in its current form, or how to improve the odds etc. but can't make their own songs hit quality is very very simple. It is far more difficult to identify the weaknesses of your own material than others. Some learn to do it but usually it's the last skill mastered. Also, people can teach any number of things they can't do. There's not a single NBA, NFL or MLB etc. coaches who could play well enough today to play on their team, let alone be the star. Teachers rarely have the needed skills ready to go to compete at the highest level because they are two very different skill sets. Most successful writers and artists are HORRIBLE at teaching ANYTHING, at least not until they stop being successful. Are there exceptions? Only a handful. (Steve Seskin comes to mind, he may be the finest songwriting teacher I have ever seen and still writes for major stars).

Anyone who says pop songs are crap and are beneath them or that they could easily write crap like them, why not DO it, then tout it to the world while using the money to fund poor talented artists and some charities? I guess if it is so easy to do and you don't, you must hate starving children and other people in desperate need right?

Brian


Brian Austin Whitney
Founder
Just Plain Folks
jpfolkspro@gmail.com
Skype: Brian Austin Whitney
Facebook: www.facebook.com/justplainfolks

"Don't sit around and wait for success to come to you... it doesn't know the way." -Brian Austin Whitney

"It's easier to be the bigger man when you actually are..." -Brian Austin Whitney

"Sometimes all you have to do to inspire humans to greatness is to give them a reason and opportunity to do something great." -Brian Austin Whitney
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 8,463
Top 20 Poster
Offline
Top 20 Poster
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 8,463
Brian there is a difference between "ALL society" and the "general public"
I did not and never will say that all people are stupid. But I will say that the public in general can be conned and will buy anything at any price if it is marketed well.
"there is one born every minute" springs to mind. Without getting into a whole other political debate the fact remains that we are controlled by market forces and people with power and money. There is no way that I as an individual can change that anytime soon. History has proved that the general public can be conned and are suckers. Heck over the centuries millions have gone to war to fight for tyrants so that they can be richer and greedier at the expense of those who fought their wars. Look at all the scams and cons people fall for. You and others on this forum have uncovered quite a few. Pop music and the pop star are just another example of how easily influenced people can be and how easily they can be scammed into believing the myth that someone with relatively little talent is something special or that their music is so much better than others. If you cannot grasp this then my opinion of you has to change.
FOOD FOR THOUGHT.
As for writing pop songs...well time is to short for me to waste and I have absolutely no need or desire to be a part of this nonsense.
The fact remains that whilst anybody, with a modicum of talent, can be a star or write a hit song as good or bad as songs that are charting depending on your POV....few get the chance because of the way the industry works. There are too many examples of bad singers and bad songs to make me believe anything other than that the whole business is a corrupt con where skill and talent counts for nothing but having a promoter or backer with great influence is everything.

Last edited by BIG JIM MERRILEES; 01/11/13 12:53 PM.
Joined: Jul 2010
Posts: 3,710
Top 100 Poster
Offline
Top 100 Poster
Joined: Jul 2010
Posts: 3,710
This thread began with a straw man argument postulating that those of us critical of the lyrical merit of commercial hit songs were simply resentful and envious of those who have gotten what we secretly wish for but have failed to achieve. In other words, our criticism is nothing more than sour grapes. By beginning with such a false premise, the poster can then dispense with having to argue the merits of the charge - that is that the writing we criticize is in fact bad writing - by attributing a bad motive to the accuser. You won't win many court cases with that kind of reasoning and logic.

It's now morphed into a discussion of the merits of how-to-do books and how people teach and learn songwriting. That kind of discussion can go on endlessly. Things can be learned from books and things can be learned through trial and error. Monkey see - Monkey do and direct observation is another way to learn. A lot can be absorbed by reading the classics.

When all is said and done, each of us has to find our own way using whatever tools we have at our disposal. There is no one-size-fits-all formula. As Mackie often says, Write on.



Write from your heart, not what you think others want to hear.

https://dansullivan2.bandcamp.com

http://www.cdbaby.com/cd/dansullivan2
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781
D
Dayson Offline OP
Top 500 Poster
OP Offline
Top 500 Poster
D
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781
Dan,

This question aroused because of an 'reoccurring' theme that is playing itself out at this moment.
No one is hiding behind anything.
If you're not one of the ones being described as having sour grapes or resentful, then don't let this discussion get under your skin.
When you pointed out a group of Successful Artists Songs as not 'Living' up to the Nashville Myth of Great Songwriters, what was your point?
What did expect to happen?
Did you expect everyone else to agree with you?
If you want to argue the Merits of your charge then let's do that.
Why are they so bad? What do you have to base that on?
Is it because of the lyrics?
Is it because of the Melodies?
Is it because the Musicianship sucks?
These songs are Successful, not because of just one thing, but for a variety of things.-Dana



Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 8,463
Top 20 Poster
Offline
Top 20 Poster
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 8,463
Brian my last word on this subject...possibly my last post on this forum....you said

"Anyone who says pop songs are crap and are beneath them or that they could easily write crap like them, why not DO it, then tout it to the world while using the money to fund poor talented artists and some charities? I guess if it is so easy to do and you don't, you must hate starving children and other people in desperate need right? "


That is preposterous even by your standards. First off I am not saying that I am any good as a songwriter I am saying that the general standard of pop music is pretty bad....both sides of the pond.... most people within music are capable of producing as good if not better songs than a lot of the songs that do chart. They will never get the chance regardless of how talented they are.
If you feel so strongly about starving kids in Africa...God knows how they got into this debate.....then ask ALL the pop stars with dubious talent like BEIBER AND RHIANNA and THE SPICE GIRLS ETC ETC ETC ETC plus the multimillionaires who control the industry to spend their ill gotten money on these starving kids and talented artists rather than on themselves......

The point I am making is simple..... the difficulty is not writing pop songs.... I am sure most people can write a song that is as good/bad as any of Rhiannas etc etc etc and I know for a fact that there are countless wannabes who are every bit as bad a singer..... it is getting anybody to promote them....or even listen to them. I can show you songs on this very forum that are far better than the charts....They have no hope of charting.......the record industry is a closed shop....where only the invited few for whatever reason stand a chance......I can tell you that talent or song quality is not a prerequisite.
Now I have been generalising and admit that there are exceptions to the rule but that does not mean that the rule itself does not stand up.......on the other side of the coin I am sure that some of these guys are deliberately trying to prove the rule by pushing the worst acts they can find to see just how far they can con folk into buying their stuff.

Check out just how bad these guys are......sadly they all reached the final of X factor and had pop hits.
1. Rylan I do not mind the camp I just have to hold my ears when he sings.

2. Wagner........bad in oh so many ways.

3. Jedward....... tone deaf annoying teenage twins who act like toddlers....I blame the mother......

http://www.digitalspy.co.uk/tv/s103...he-the-worst-x-factor-finalist-ever.html

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fq49Gv3wFB0

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MnyAUXx40tU


Now after watching that tell me I am talking rubbish........
(edited to insert correct links)

Last edited by BIG JIM MERRILEES; 01/11/13 08:01 PM.
Joined: May 2006
Posts: 7,911
Likes: 1
Top 30 Poster
Offline
Top 30 Poster
Joined: May 2006
Posts: 7,911
Likes: 1
Jim,

You are right - they are all awful. I don't think any of them would appeal to the audience of the American version of the show. Perhaps the British are kinder and feel sorry for them.

Maybe you should stop watching the show!


Colin

I try to critique as if you mean business.....

http://colinwardmusic.com/

http://rosewoodcreekband.com/


Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 8,463
Top 20 Poster
Offline
Top 20 Poster
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 8,463
Funny thing Colin. It was Nicole Scherzinger of Pussycat Dolls, one of the x factor judges and a fellow American who chose the Rylan guy above the hundreds of hopefuls that she had to mentor to be one of her final three. Sadly if I am not working I am forced to watch the show as the women in my house control the remote. I am sure they do it just to see me squirm and start shouting at the TV screen.
I hope that the X factor in America goes viral like it did here....maybe then will some of the folks who think I talk nonsense take me seriously about just how crap some of those pop stars are.....and how corrupt the music and entertainment business is.

Thankfully I am 59 and well past any ambitions to be a famous star......otherwise I would be pulling my hair out. On a serious note I know some young guys who have a great band yet cannot get enough work to make a living wage from playing...it makes you sick.

Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781
D
Dayson Offline OP
Top 500 Poster
OP Offline
Top 500 Poster
D
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781
Hi Jim,

We may disagree on our views of this discussion.
Why is that reason for a possible last post?
If nothing else, we know how you feel about it.
There's no reason to leave the forum over a point of view.
I hope you'll stick around.-Dana

Joined: Apr 2006
Posts: 6,114
Top 40 Poster
Offline
Top 40 Poster
Joined: Apr 2006
Posts: 6,114
Just my opinion and not speaking for anyone, but Big Jim ain't going nowhere. He has the persistence and determination of a wild cat. He'll never concede or say "I was wrong". I've been around here long enough to know that as fact. I've had a few run-in's with Big Jim myself, but I still hold him in high regard and respect. I actually agree with him in regard to the state of the music business, but he can explain it much better than I can.

Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 8,463
Top 20 Poster
Offline
Top 20 Poster
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 8,463
Sorry Dana...we are separated by a common language. "This might be my last" and adding "song" or "post" or "cigarette" or "drink" or whatever is a Scottish slang expression that should not be taken literally. I have a pretty thick skin and it would take more than a debate to stop me posting. We do not disagree on views we disagree on facts. My criticism of the recording and entertainment industry is backed by facts and events which I have experienced and witnessed over my forty plus years as a professional singer and performer. When singers cannot even stay in tune yet are hailed as top professionals I think I have a right to state this and criticise their lack of talent. The same applies to songs...if you can call them songs that contain a simplistic beat and riff and a few words repeated ad nauseum. Anyway you get the jist of what I am saying perhaps it may give you food for thought.
I would be interested to hear just what songwriting book you got and what it contains that made you change so much and why you read and re read.
Is there a link you can give so I can hear your work? You do not provide any links to your music. Interested to find out what style and genres you write in if you are a performer and what instruments you play.

Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 8,463
Top 20 Poster
Offline
Top 20 Poster
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 8,463
Just read Ben's post....yes we have locked horns on a few occasions but we do not bear grudges and have a mutual respect. I would call him a friend. As I would just about everybody on this forum. If we all agreed upon everything then life would be pretty dull. One thin I did learn early on is to have a thick skin and the persistence and determination of a wild cat.
To get back to the original topic.... criticism is good....it helps build confidence and a thick skin which you need if you want to go anywhere in this business. It is a good way of finding out what needs fixing and what you are doing right. My motto is if you do not know it is broke then how are you ever going to fix it. That said you need encouragement as well. Getting the mix right is the big problem...some backpat so much they fail to see the elephant in the room and others can only criticise. I try to be balanced. That said people who are in the big time are fair game especially if they do not reach minimum standards. If you think I am being harsh towards them then you should meet my agent....they would not last five minutes with him.

Joined: Aug 2010
Posts: 48
Serious Contributor
Offline
Serious Contributor
Joined: Aug 2010
Posts: 48
Not sure if this response is even on target anymore, but I completely understand the frustration of hearing "crappy" songs on the radio and feeling like what you write is much better. Having been a professional songwriter for years, I've had loads of songs put on hold only to hear the songs the artists cut instead that are nowhere near as good as the ones my publisher(s) had pitched them. That said, I also realized a long time ago that the saying "It's all about the song" is only true in ideal theory. It's called the music BUSINESS for a reason. It's business, and a lot of times that also means politics.

The other reality is that the music business is not about music, it's about ENTERTAINMENT. To use movies as an example, there are documentaries and blockbusters. From a "craft" standpoint the documentary may be a lot better but no one is under the illusion that it is going to make as much money as the flashiness of the blockbuster. That's what pop music is supposed to be - the flashy blockbuster that appeals to the masses who want to be entertained and aren't interested in the "craft".

The holy grail for us songwriters is a song like "The House That Built Me" - one that is both excellent from a craft standpoint but also appeals to the masses because of it's message.

So to be critical of other's work is completely pointless in my opinion and a waste of time and energy . . . that is unless they ask you for it. And then it should be constructive. As the old saying goes, no one has ever raised a statue in honor of a critic.


http://WWW.ACOUSTICVOCAL.COM
simple and affordable demo solutions for songwriters
Joined: Sep 2009
Posts: 9,003
Likes: 1
Top 20 Poster
Offline
Top 20 Poster
Joined: Sep 2009
Posts: 9,003
Likes: 1
JAY SPEIGHT--

THERE MUST BE SOMETHING IN THE DRINKING WATER HERE IN NASHVILLE--I AGREE 100% WITH WHAT YOU ARE SAYING--I HAVE WRITTEN 1000'S OF SONGS SINCE I CAME TO NASHVILLE IN 1960--I HAVE BOXES OF OF REEL TO REELS, CASSETTES, MINIDISC'S, AND CD'S--I DON'T THROW THEM AWAY, BECAUSE THEY ARE PART OF ME--

I USED TO HANG ON BROADWAY--PLAYING FOR TIPS IN THE 8O'S AND 90'S--BACK THEN AN OUTSIDER COULD GET BASIC WORKING TAPES LISTENED TO--THEY MAY EVEN RECEIVE A FEW POINTERS--HAD A COUPLE ON HOLD RIGHT AFTER 2000 ROLLED IN--

THE SONG WRITING CRAFT, HAS TO BE DEVELOPED TO AN EXCEPTIONAL FINE POINT OF PROFESSIONALISM, KNOWING THE TRENDS IN MUSIC--IN TUNE WITH THE BIZ--WHO ONE KNOWS IN HIGH PLACES--NETWORKING, AND TIMING --ONE'S BEST SUITED MATERIAL--EVERYTHING MUST BE KEPT IN MIND--MERCY….MERCY!!!!!!!!!!!!

CONSTRUCTIVE CRITICISM FROM OTHER WRITERS IN THE BIZ (JIMMIE C NEWMAN, HARLAN HOWARD, MAC VICKERY, SKIP EWING AND TONY MULLINS) HAS HELP ME THROUGH THE YEARS--JPF-ERS HAVE HELPED ME AS I FOUND NEW DIRECTIONS AND IDEAS IN SEVERAL GENRES--

THEREFORE, I FEEL CRITICISM HAS BEEN A GREAT HELP FOR ME--BOTH GOOD AND BAD--

LIKE THE SCOTSMAN JIM SAYS: TRENDS COME AND GO WITH LOTS OF BAD SONGS--SOMEBODY MADE THE MONEY--LOTS OF PAY-OLA STILL WORKING IN THE WINGS--

I ALWAYS ASK--WHO WILL BUY THIS SONG--OTHERWISE IT MAY JUST BE A PERSONAL SONG FOR MY SCRAPBOOK--I HAVE HUNDREDS IN MY BOOK--

GREAT SONGS HAVE A LONG LIFE--OTHERS ARE JUST A PASSING FAD--
A SONG LIKE "WIND BENEATH MY WINGS" IS ONE OF THE GREAT SONGS -- OVER 400 ARTISTS HAVE RECORDED THAT SONG.

I THINK A LONG LIFE OF EXPERIENCES, BOTH GOOD AND BAD, GIVE A WRITER SO MANY AVENUES TO EXPLORE AND WRITE ABOUT--I ALWAYS TRY TO SPIN MY SONGS WITH ENOUGH TRUTH, AT THE SAME TIME, KEEPING BASIC IDEAS CURRENT: HAPPENING TODAY! I DON'T EXPERIENCE WRITERS' BLOCK, MAINLY BECAUSE I HAVEN'T WRITTEN EVERYTHING I WANTED TO-I AM STILL DRIVEN BY EVERY DAY GRIEF, HAPPINESS, HAEARTACHES, AND REAL LOVE--COWBOY AND BLUES, I'VE WRITTEN A FEW ALONG WITH IDEAS FROM MY VIVID DREAMS!

THE CRITICISM I'VE RECEIVED THROUGH THE YEARS, I FEEL, HAS MADE ME A BETTER SONGWRITER--I FEEL EVERY WRITER COULD HAVE A GREAT SONG IF GIVEN A CHANCE--MAYBE ONE DAY, THE CARDS WILL FALL FOR ONE OF US!

ALL WE CAN DO IS WRITE ON!

Mackie




Joined: Jul 2010
Posts: 3,710
Top 100 Poster
Offline
Top 100 Poster
Joined: Jul 2010
Posts: 3,710
Mackie, It sounds like you got a tip or two from the legendary Harlon Howard. If that's true, it might make a good song. "Here's what Harlon Said." You could write it from the perspective of a scuffling songwriting trying to make his mark and the advice Harlon gave you. You could use poetic license if need be to make the story better.


Write from your heart, not what you think others want to hear.

https://dansullivan2.bandcamp.com

http://www.cdbaby.com/cd/dansullivan2
Joined: Sep 2009
Posts: 9,003
Likes: 1
Top 20 Poster
Offline
Top 20 Poster
Joined: Sep 2009
Posts: 9,003
Likes: 1
DAN--

I HAVE A CD HE GAVE ME BACK IN THE NINETIES ( ON IT HE DOES HIS OWN SONGS: IT HAS HIS GREATEST HITS)--I WENT TO A COUPLE OF HIS BIRTHDAY BASHES WAY BACK--WORE TO THREADS, A TEE SHIRT WITH HIS NAME ON IT!

HOWARD WAS BORN IN DETROIT IN '27 AND GREW UP IN KY--THE CD HE GAVE US AT THE PARTY HAD HIM IN A FLAT TOP HAIR DO--PIX FROM THE 60'S--HE DIED IN 2002---HOWARD WAS ONE OF THE GREAT TRADITIONAL COUNTRY WRITERS!

I TOLD HIM ONE TIME, I MAY DO A BOOK ON REAL COUNTRY MUSIC, TITLED FROM THE TRENCHES OF MUSIC CITY--HE SAID HE WANTED TO BE IN IT--SOMEBODY SHOULD WRITE THE BOOK!

Mackie

Joined: Aug 2010
Posts: 48
Serious Contributor
Offline
Serious Contributor
Joined: Aug 2010
Posts: 48
Mackie,

I agree that criticism can be very helpful if it is constructive, but I think the kind Dana was speaking of was more along the lines of being critical of other songs that are out there and not the type of feedback I believe you're speaking of.


http://WWW.ACOUSTICVOCAL.COM
simple and affordable demo solutions for songwriters
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781
D
Dayson Offline OP
Top 500 Poster
OP Offline
Top 500 Poster
D
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781
Hi Jim

I'm glad to hear that! lol.
I'll just say we disagree on the 'Facts according to Jim'
The Book I am speaking of is The Billboard Guide to Writing and Producing Songs that Sell. By Hit Songwriter and A&R Eric Beall.
Because I aim for the Commercial Market, it's been a great asset to me.

It made me see the industry from an A&R perspective as well as a Songwriter.
It affirmed a lot of qualities that I found in my own work as well as some I did not.
It hasn't so much made 'Me' Change but it Changed my perceptions and views and allowed me to see things in a way that I believe will push me further than if I had not read it.

As far as my Music, I write POP/Contemporary Country/R&B
I am currently working on my New Music, and I am very excited about it.
I'm not a performer, I'm a Songwriter.-Dana


Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781
D
Dayson Offline OP
Top 500 Poster
OP Offline
Top 500 Poster
D
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781
Hi Jay,

Your post is spot on. It has gone off target a bit.
Much of what you say is also touched on in the book I mentioned.

"So to be critical of other's work is completely pointless in my opinion and a waste of time and energy."

So True! Thanks for responding=)Dana

Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781
D
Dayson Offline OP
Top 500 Poster
OP Offline
Top 500 Poster
D
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781
I was also speaking to the Commercial vs. Non Commercial aspect of this. -Dana

Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781
D
Dayson Offline OP
Top 500 Poster
OP Offline
Top 500 Poster
D
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781
Hi Mackie,

"
THE SONG WRITING CRAFT, HAS TO BE DEVELOPED TO AN EXCEPTIONAL FINE POINT OF PROFESSIONALISM, KNOWING THE TRENDS IN MUSIC--IN TUNE WITH THE BIZ--WHO ONE KNOWS IN HIGH PLACES--NETWORKING, AND TIMING --ONE'S BEST SUITED MATERIAL--EVERYTHING MUST BE KEPT IN MIND"

Great point!
Thanks for responding=)-Dana

Joined: Aug 2008
Posts: 4,700
Likes: 2
Top 100 Poster
Offline
Top 100 Poster
Joined: Aug 2008
Posts: 4,700
Likes: 2
interesting thread. smile I was content simply to read, but when the word 'books' entered the conversation I felt compelled to step up to their defence. wink

I've learned so much from books on songwriting/lyric writing, especially regarding the craft. I come from a journalistic/short story/poetry-writing background, so the transition to lyrics of course called for a different type of focus and craftmanship.

I'm with Dana regarding Eric Beall's book on writing and producing songs that sell. It's dynamite. I bought it a couple of months ago, and was captivated from the first page. This guy knows the business inside out. While reading the book, I went through a range of emotions like curiousity, shock, bewilderment, anger, amazement, despair (that I'd never be able to do anything with a song or songs), excitement, delight, and finally a wonderful sense of being inspired and challenged - and wanting to meet that challenge because I now have a few more weapons in my arsenal.

Note, though, that the book isn't about how to write a good song. The author presumes the reader already knows how to do that. What he does is offer information and guidance on what a songwriter needs to do so that his/her song stands out from the competition.

The book impressed me so much, I sent a copy as a Christmas gift to one of my collaborators in Scotland. He's a brilliant musician, and has been playing and composing for over 35 years. I know he'll be able to apply what he learns from the book. I'd already sent him Sheila Davis's excellent book on writing songs for film/tv (as we both want to do more in that direction). He told me he was so excited and inspired by that book that he'd spent three days in a row - including late into the night - re-visiting some older tracks.

Anyway. This is simply my two cents' worth where books are concerned. wink

As for criticism: There's not one of my lyrics that hasn't been improved - sometimes dramatically - after I've re-written it - often multiple times - on the basis of constructive critiques from both amateur (e.g. songwriting forum members) and professional songwriters.

Donna


Honour the Earth. Without it, we'd be nowhere.

Life is too important to take seriously.






Joined: May 2008
Posts: 4,195
Likes: 1
Top 100 Poster
Offline
Top 100 Poster
Joined: May 2008
Posts: 4,195
Likes: 1
Great points ----- well thought out Dana


Thomas Shea

Thomas Shea - Songwriting
http://www.soundclick.com/thomasshea

Justice - Songs
http://www.soundclick.com/justice-nebraska

Joined: May 2006
Posts: 7,911
Likes: 1
Top 30 Poster
Offline
Top 30 Poster
Joined: May 2006
Posts: 7,911
Likes: 1
I'd be willing to bet that these same discussions occur on bulletin boards frequented by authors, artists, TV producers, movie producers, and even manufacturers of consumer goods sold to the masses. "why do they buy that crap instead of the fine sophisticated stuff I am trying to sell?" My wife who is an artist tells the story of Georgia O'Keefe who was a lousy artist who became famous because she was married to a wealthy promoter who promoted her relentlessly.


Colin

I try to critique as if you mean business.....

http://colinwardmusic.com/

http://rosewoodcreekband.com/


Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 8,463
Top 20 Poster
Offline
Top 20 Poster
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 8,463
"So to be critical of other's work is completely pointless in my opinion and a waste of time and energy."


I fail to see any logic in that statement. We all rely on criticism, both received and given. That is true in every aspect of life not just songwriting. Without this the world stand still and never advance. Self criticism is good but will only take us to a certain level. To get to the next level we have to have outside input including much constructive criticism from all sources. Every company I know relies on feedback both positive and negative and any artist I know needs to tweak things according to how their audience reacts and the criticisms they receive..
Perhaps the reasons that the recording industry is in such a state and that so much crap can find its way into the charts is that people do NOT criticise....they just accept without question what is thrown at them.
The reasons why the public are not outspoken are varied. Apathy is rife amongst the general public most are too apathetic or perhaps too ignorant or afraid to air their views which might be seen as controversial or against the trends their peers follow.
I as music lover have to send a message to the powers that be and to the artist about the crap they produce and how they are causing the industry to stagnate. Now if more did the same then they would have to get their act together and the quality of the pop music they produce can only get better. So for those who fail to criticise or think it is a waste of time then I can only say that you are responsible for the state of the industry....and the reason why the Cowells, Rylans and Jedwards etc of this life get away with producing mediocrity they do.

Donna made a great point about books and I agree with much of what she said. However she more or less stressed my point that most books on songwriting can be a waste of time. For example no point in reading a book about selling, marketing and promoting your song if you do not have a decent song to promote.
It is the old adage on the book that says....how to make a million...you start with two million. No point in buying the book if you do not have the two million...and even if you have two million you probably have worked it out for yourself how to turn it into one million.
As I said most of these books state the blindingly obvious or are irrelevant to the person buying it.
To be a good songwriter you have to learn the craft....learn to play an instrument to a decent level, learn about music theory, composition, and lyric writing. Learn how music is constructed and how sound technology comes into play. Get some great songs together...then worry about making a buck from them. Probably along the way you will have met people who you can work with and who you can co-write with or can introduce you to people who can help you. Whilst you can do that from books to a certain degree it is possibly not the best way.

Joined: Aug 2008
Posts: 4,700
Likes: 2
Top 100 Poster
Offline
Top 100 Poster
Joined: Aug 2008
Posts: 4,700
Likes: 2
Originally Posted by BIG JIM MERRILEES

Donna made a great point about books and I agree with much of what she said. However she more or less stressed my point that most books on songwriting can be a waste of time. For example no point in reading a book about selling, marketing and promoting your song if you do not have a decent song to promote.


Jim, just to clarify. smile My point was that well-written, well-informed books by reputable professionals in the field can help a determined, dedicated lyric-writer or songwriter to perfect her/his craft, and to the extent that the product then becomes ready to be promoted. wink

Donna


Honour the Earth. Without it, we'd be nowhere.

Life is too important to take seriously.






Joined: Dec 2008
Posts: 3,845
K
Top 100 Poster
Offline
Top 100 Poster
K
Joined: Dec 2008
Posts: 3,845
Considering criticism..

On the one hand I think it's important to stick with the song at hand, and not make the conversation about any other song.

After all, a critique is something the author solicits, not something that's forced down his throat. It's an offering, not an assault.

Admittably, on the other hand, it can sometimes feel like an assault, though, and in those instances it's important to understand the criteria the song has been judged with.

If you just write for your own pleasure, you can get away with anything, as long as it makes sense to yourself.

If you write for your girlfriend, it better be about loving her, or else..

If you write for people you don't know, like artist pitches, you need to be aware of that, and don't assume too much. You need to make yourself clear, and make music that makes sense to your (and their!) listeners.

If you're the artist yourself and aspire to specific uses like commercials, film, tv ect., you need to be aware of the criteria that applies for a song to be useful in those situations.

So critique is something that you can use to allign yourself with the competition and the audience (whom ever that may be), and the judgements can be a beacon for you to craft music that eventually will be well recieved by the people you'd like to recieve it well.

While it's true that good and bad is in the eye of the beholder, the same goes for how you respond to critique, and put it to work for you. Remember it's an offering, and it's up to you to determine how valid it is, in the context of your song, because you are the only one who knows all the details about your aspirations.

In that respect books are awesome resources, especially for people with few or no friends in the music business. Books are knowledgeable people's offerings to those who does not yet know, and sharing those thoughts is like walking through a front door to your dreams, as long as you remain open and stick with it. The same goes for the JPF Forums! In their signature everybody looks the same online, yet there are huge differences in how experienced people are. You learn that by listening over a longer stretch of time. But even people with no experience can tell you if they like the song or not, and then it's up to you to learn what criteria they have in mind when doing their critique.

While none can know better what you need to do, they can know more than you, and know-how and trusting it can really be the difference that makes a difference for you.. and even if they are not experts, you can always trust a judgement. You can't always use it in your situation, but that's a different thing.

If people were always completely honest, there would be no distrust.

Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781
D
Dayson Offline OP
Top 500 Poster
OP Offline
Top 500 Poster
D
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781
Hi Donna,

I'm so glad you agree with me about the Book!
Like you said it's 'Dynamite'!
You make excellent points all around.
Thanks for responding.-Dana

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3

Link Copied to Clipboard
Support Just Plain Folks

We would like to keep the membership in Just Plain Folks FREE! Your donation helps support the many programs we offer including Road Trips and the Music Awards.


Newest Members
EdKreider, KyleCrawford, LukeMeyers, KimBilbrew, AdamSadowski
21,480 Registered Users
Forum Statistics
Forums118
Topics129,178
Posts1,186,197
Members21,480
Most Online236,505
Jul 1st, 2026
Just Plain Quotes
"Do not endeavor to be the smartest kid in a dumb class. Instead, you are better off being the dumbest kid in the smartest class, where you will be challenged and you will learn. If you aren't growing, you are dying." -Brian Austin Whitney
Today's Birthdays
Andrew Jackman (35), Linziellen (45)
Popular Topics(Views)
1,479,978 Prophecy anyone?
Powered by UBB.threads™ PHP Forum Software 7.7.5