It's changed very much that way. Part of it is that the focus changed to home recording, instead of the song. Now it's "good song, but you might need some EQ on the vocals"

The other part is that almost nobody writes to get cuts any more. Some still do or think about it, but if there's no goal to do anything with it, then there's no point in commenting on it.

It does get annoying reading the same response to every song. It's nice in a way, but also stupid in a way.

It's kind of like asking your mother if you're handsome...