Originally Posted by Sunset Poet
Originally Posted by Fdemetrio
If Ai does everything, song, performance, production, your listening to an illusion, this is
"Johnny Thunderpants"

But he plays live and sucks, there goes the illusion, write him off as an Ai fraud.

That debate is showing up a lot of places.
And it is interesting to watch.

Being capable of performing live as a human for other humans appears to be the human musicians last stronghold.

AI is writing , not just songs, but everything. Some universities are returning to face-to-face oral exams because stoner students are clicking a couple prompts and turning in term papers.

As for songwriting, there has always been a prevalent belief in the musical world that a true songwriter has to be "musical."
"Musical" includes being able to play an instrument and/or sing with reasonable skill levels.

Makes logical sense. I'm not necessarily talking virtuoso either.

But ai makes it that somebody who has never written a song, capable of writing one. Maybe not very good but

lyricist should have a good sense of melody.

If the song is three chords, and you are performing, play those three chords.

Basicly saying, if you are stamping your name as an artist, be that artist

Last edited by Fdemetrio; 09/04/26 08:33 AM.