Bill, although it has the TM beside it, and that carries some common law rights, I do not believe it has been registered. That would allow Brian to add a little "R" inside a circle, much like the copyright sign has a "C" in it...

That tag line has been used by political campaigns as well....so I think it would be hard to get it "broadly trade marked", meaning that Brian could definitely register and protect its use for an on line music community, and perhaps even an on line community in general....

But beyond that, wide protection against infringement would be impossible I would think. In fact, should Brian try to register it, seems to me he'll run into a lot of opposition unless he narrows the "market" for which he is wanting protection.

As I own some trade marks, (a tag line can be registered as a trade mark) here's a funny story...from personal experience.

I was in the process of registering a trade mark, and ran into some opposition, but I was convinced I could use it because not only were they (the "opponents" as they are called here) in a different market, the trade mark is "weak" to begin with.

(Weak" is a term used to describe how original a phrase is. For example, it is unlikely you'll ever get a trad mark for coca cola cars, or xerox diapers, or kleenex burgers...because the name is so strongly associated with one product, and the words are "made up".....BTW, the entire concept of trade marks is based on the concept of "passing off" one product for another....causing "confusion in the minds of a consumer" that will have them think they are buying one thing, but really getting another...McDonald's Hamburgers and McDonald's Deli springs to mind...)

In any event, they dropped their opposition when I sent them a photo copy of about 4 pages of our local phone book that had businesses ...in their broad market space...with their key word in it...

Lesson?

For a trade mark\tag line to be effective, the word\phrase should be unique (which is why you see so many made up words like Xerox, Kleenex etc), and when it is registered, it should clearly, but not "over broadly", define the market for which you (intend to) use it.

So, for example, there MAY be nothing wrong with, say Ford, "stealing", ... "just slightly ahead of our time" which was used by Panasonic for consumer electronics...and using it for cars...or taking the slogan "the quality goes in before the name goes on" from (was it??) RCA televisions.




If writing ever becomes work I think I'm going to have to stop