'Oral' contracts are binding too. You don't necessarily have to sit down with lawyers and 'ink' a contract. It can be as simple as, "I'll fly if you buy." That means I'll go to the counter and get us a drink if you'll pay for them. If you accept my offer to 'fly' and agree to 'buy' it's a contract. You can back out on it. No big deal. But some folks may take it as a 'big deal' and be very upset if you back out.

In a songwriting collaboration the 'contract' can be that simple. Someone 'offers' a lyric for someone, anyone else to set to music. Some other party out in cyberspace 'accepts' that offer and offers to set the lyric to music.

The point is that both parties should have an understanding that the other does not have to accept their offer. The party offering the lyric wants a melody, and perhaps an arrangement (instruments), that make their lyric sound good. The lyric-party may have to specify, verbally, if not in writing, that they reserve the right to hear the treatment before accepting it. Getting that and other 'rules' or 'commitments' or 'agreements' orally stated or written up-front, before the work has been done, before the hopes have been heightened, is courtesy and good business.

Then if they come to you with standard country melody #3, and a piteous caterwauling vocal, accompanied by an imitation of an imitation of an imitation of a country musical treatment, and are broken-hearted, angry, and ready to sue because you tell them you don't think that's what you want (or, worse, the truth about their clumsy attempt to treat your lyric) you simply remind them of the 'right-to-withdraw' your offer 'clause' of the 'contract' whether it was oral or written.

If you don't discuss it beforehand, you may find, especially in a long-distance, stranger-to-stranger internet collaboration, that they have told all their friends about the collaboration and now they feel their whole self-worth is on the line. Don't assume their maturity or how much of themselves they are putting on the line. The more groundwork you do to clarify the 'offer' and the conditions of 'acceptance' the more likely you are to be able to withdraw without aggravation.


There will always be another song to be written. Someone will write it. Why not you? www.garyeandrews.com