This is a pretty interesting subject.

Shoppin' around

I've often encountered a practice where you part ways with your own product intact. There seem to be lot of 'shopping around' in this area.

Say a lyricist don't like the music put to his lyrics. Then, if both agrees, the lyricist can take his lyrics somewhere else and have it 'musicated'. Same goes for the musician, of course.

The jumping point is where the song is in the process. If a lyricist is just looking for music at an early stage, this seems viable, allthough not a very comitted way to engage in cowriting with. But if the song is about to be recorded and copyrighted, this could cause way more controversy, I'd think.

I do understand that lyricists have limited options, and would like some kind of break with their work, though.

Melody first in contemporary music

Another thing is, though, that the send-off-a-lyric-and-have-it-musicated approach very rarely results in contemporary and commercially viable music (Bernie & John WAS the 70ies, remember..).

The reason for this is that most contemporary artists have a style they'll need to have the songs in. And contemporary styles are so melodic and rhythm driven, that if the lyric can't adhere to that, it just won't work. Therefore the most viable strategy to write contemporary songs is to write melody first. If you don't do this, there might not be an open market for your songs at all.

I think this is particularly troublesome for the lyricist only, as the trend is to have songwriters do more, even produce. So this puts the lyricist in an even worse position when lyrics are to merge with music.

Collaboration overvalued and underappreciated

Furthermore, I think the nature of collaboration in commercial music business is often overvalued by the go-getters. If you read ASCAP VP Ralph Murphy's list of what publishers value the most http://www.ascap.com/nashville/murphy/murphy2.html , the ability to write alone is Top 4, and ability to co-write is further down. This suggests that it's not a quest for higher quality that drives the co-writing cirquit, it's the incresed opportunities that comes from merging two or more networks, and the need for songwriters to be flexible in terms of co-writing with artists (that may, or may not be good songwriters at all).

For new and ambitious writers, this means that untill you've actually entered the pro-cirquit of songwriters and publishers, you may well be better off writing alone, to prove your worth, than to cowrite a bunch of songs with other newcomers, as it's then harder for a publisher to sort out, that YOU are the ONE.

Of course you may want to collaborate for a bunch of reasons - GETTING a network being one fundamental one. But just don't expect a publisher to prefer a co-written song before one you've penned alone. They just want GREAT songs.

I think this suggests that you should be VERY large with the terms and agreements when it comes to co-writes, when your purpose is to expand your network. You basically just want to make good friends, that you can involve at a later stage of your journey.

If you end up being a top dawg, you might need to protect yourself more, but you won't be getting hits before then anyway, so why not give your co's a little slack.

Maybe "slack before smack" could make it as a cowriting dogma laugh

justmythoughts (nocentsinvolved)