I have to chime in here to address this "left" vs "right" labelling.

It is far too easy to dismiss discussions and ideas, no matter how good, by attacking the person as "left" or "right" because it immediately splits people into two diametrically opposed camps, at which point the idea and discussion gets lost in all the accompanying rhetoric.

The truth is far more complex.

People are first of all, not consistently "right" or "left" in their thinking. Smart, involved, empathetic people will look at an issue, see first of all how it affects them immediately, and perhaps see how it affects society, and they will make up their minds based on their experiences, preconceptions, and often through discussions with others.

This "what's in it for me" or "how does this impact me" is central to everyone's thinking. Your health care debate, for example, is a good one. Most people saw increased taxes as the immediate effect..and the benefit accruing, not to them, but the faceless uninsured. But they couched all in increased government interference etc, and of course those with most to lose (how does this affect me?) paid lobbyists to sabotage, delay and derail discussions.

Secondly, "left" vs "right" was an idea conceived by writers in the time of the French revolution, where those who supported the current elites (nobility, religious orders etc ) sat together in the right side of the assembly chamber, while those who supported the rights of the lower classes sat on the left. Left vs right is largely the product of a country that has a small ruling elite and a vaste underclass.

But the USA and many countries now have very large middle classes, upwardly mobile, and reasonably free to transact with others. Communists called them the petty bourgoisie.

So the conditions for "left" and "right" thinking are simply not there in the USA.

Still, the label is easy to throw out when you want to scare people away from ideas. What better way to destroy people than by calling them communists?

Bottom line?

Focus on the issue..not the messenger.

Here it's clearly about a government agency with legitimate responsibilities in keeping the "homeland secure" first set up to prevent foreign terrorist attacks on US soil. This is a task everyone, including us Canadians, can accept and moreover, see as a necessity in this day and age.

But to now use that agency as a general "economic" tool ( I can see that their responsibilities should touch on things like money laundering, currency manipulation etc) that primarily benefits big business (with admitted trickle down effects), is, in my considered opinion, wrong.

Especially because there are current laws, protocols and enforcement agencies available. Add to this the fact that usually, these (trademark and copyright infringement, passing off goods etc) are civil cases where it is up to the property owner to initiate the complaint and fund the court case.

So why, in these cases, did Homeland Security take the lead?

I'm willing to be educated here. If someone can make a legitimate case, and show me this is not over reach, I'm happy to change my mind.

Until then, I can only think that big business is more equal that others.








If writing ever becomes work I think I'm going to have to stop