I don't think the hitwriters can be blamed, like this. In all businesses Brand names are exploited. So why not offer yourself as a consultant, when you have proven yourself in the music business? Who would else have the expertise?

On the other hand, these fees are steep, and these people can't offer any more opportunities to get the "cut", than anyone else. So, I would assume very few can actually use this service strategically.

I'd say it's expensive coaching, but it can be worth it if their coaching skills are as great as their songwriting skills (which I highly doubt they are).

I would need real documentation that these people are equally great to make sure you actually LEARN something from their involvement, so they can't just get away with anything. The problem with this is acountability! I pay for stuff, but only when I know what I'm going to get.