Welcome to the Just Plain Folks forums! You are currently viewing our forums as a Guest which gives you limited access to most of our discussions and to other features.
By joining our free community you will have access to post and respond to topics, communicate privately with our users (PM), respond to polls, upload content, and access many other features. Registration is fast, simple, and absolutely free; so please join our community today!
|
|
Ana Schon
by Gary E. Andrews - 11/16/26 12:11 AM
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Lot Long
by Gary E. Andrews - 11/10/26 11:20 AM
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781
Top 500 Poster
|
OP
Top 500 Poster
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781 |
Hi Donna,
I'm so glad you agree with me about the Book! Like you said it's 'Dynamite'! You make excellent points all around. Thanks for responding.-Dana
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781
Top 500 Poster
|
OP
Top 500 Poster
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781 |
Hi Songcabinet,
Lots of good points in your posts also. The kind of Criticism I am speaking of is not The kind one provides to a writer on how they think they might improve a Song.
I'm speaking of the kind where someone lumps a group of Songwriters from a particular genre and Criticize them as not being Great or Lacking something because they happen to be on the Charts. Thanks for your input!-Dana
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781
Top 500 Poster
|
OP
Top 500 Poster
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781 |
Thanks Tom!
I'm just hoping this might help someone on their Journey. Lots of wonderful information to be soaked in from so many great people on this forum.-Dana
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Oct 2007
Posts: 3,865
Top 100 Poster
|
Top 100 Poster
Joined: Oct 2007
Posts: 3,865 |
Well, I was going to respond until I read further and see the initial questions had taken on a life of their own.
I will say, don't ask for input if you don't want the true feelings of anyone offering a critique. Don't forget to mention just sharing, if that's your intent. Don't get your feelings hurt, it's only words. You may agree or disagree but it is only one persons opinion.
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Aug 2010
Posts: 48
Serious Contributor
|
Serious Contributor
Joined: Aug 2010
Posts: 48 |
Big Jim,
I think I may not have been clear. I wasn't speaking of the kind of constructive feedback you are referring to. I agree with everything you said. The point I was making is that it is pointless as a songwriter to be critical of others . . . as in sour grapes.
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 8,463
Top 20 Poster
|
Top 20 Poster
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 8,463 |
Jay I disagree. Sour grapes has nothing to do with it. The standard of pop music has declined rapidly over the past few years and the young and easily influenced pop fans who are the target market for this rubbish seem to be getting easier and easier to please and now readily accept this mediocrity cause they know no better. Nepotism is rife and it seems that with reality TV shows like X factor etc just about anybody given the backing and hype can make a hit record. We have a situation where a few powerful people can ultimately control the charts and they have the final say in deciding who gets to become famous what they can record and what we see on TV and hear on the radio. Somebody has to make a stand. When someone with very little obvious talent is hailed as something special it is not sour grapes to point it out just honesty. If people were more honest and discerning then the standard would have to improve. Not only does our art suffer irreparable damage but the livelihood of real musicians suffers also. By our silence and failure to criticise we are condoning this corrupt system and perpetuating its mediocrity.
At the end of the day by staying silent we are cutting our own throats. Now I am under no illusion that one man saying that Taylor Swift, Rihanna and One Direction et al suck and that they are no better than the hundreds of wannabes who could replace them will make much difference but if millions start saying it then it might encourage people to be more discerning and more honest.
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Dec 2000
Posts: 12,255 Likes: 56
Top 10 Poster
|
Top 10 Poster
Joined: Dec 2000
Posts: 12,255 Likes: 56 |
Criticism-helpful or hurtful? Seems these terms have to be defined, as this discussion indeed went all over the place. IF this is about critiquing and deconstructing what is out there, you simply can't help doing it as an artist. I have clients in the film industry, and many years back lived in a house with working actors, and not one of them can simply sit back and enjoy watching what is on the screen. Everything is analysed and discussed and analysed some more. As long as you learn from this, it is helpful, but it sure takes the simple joy out of it. It also explains Big Jim. He cannot hear music these days without looking at what is wrong with it. It just speaks to his long association as an artist in the music industry. Couchgrouch, arguably one of the best writers who ever posted here, said he learned by listening to classic songs, and there was one book (he never would say which one) that influenced his writing direction. Great example of learning from what is out there and learning from what has been written by others. IF this is about critiques at JPF, then it is all about who offers it up, what they say, and how it is used by the "recipient". If it makes the "product" better, it was helpful. If the critique was bad, or ignored, then it was not. I really can't see how this turned into such a debate
If writing ever becomes work I think I'm going to have to stop
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Aug 2010
Posts: 48
Serious Contributor
|
Serious Contributor
Joined: Aug 2010
Posts: 48 |
John - again, I'm not talking about either scenario. I'm talking about the critical attitude that says, "So and so sucks. I can't believe a label would sign such crap". Analysis and tearing songs apart from a craft standpoint are how you get better. That's a given.
And to your point, Big Jim - while I agree with a lot of what you said in your post, railing against the system isn't going to change a thing. Labels sign artists they think will sell. The great thing about the free market is that you get to vote with your wallet. If you don't like it, don't buy it. That's the only thing that labels understand.
On a side note, you might enjoy Bob Lefsetz' emails. He has a ton of great insight into the industry and how it's changing.
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Dec 2000
Posts: 12,255 Likes: 56
Top 10 Poster
|
Top 10 Poster
Joined: Dec 2000
Posts: 12,255 Likes: 56 |
Thanks for defining your terms Jay.
IMO simple criticism without any attempt to learn from it is useless, and amounts to simple venting and an expression of opinion on the part of the critic. To get anything constructive out of that behaviour, you have to keep asking them "why do you say that"
If writing ever becomes work I think I'm going to have to stop
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 8,463
Top 20 Poster
|
Top 20 Poster
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 8,463 |
With well over forty years experience as a professional singer I can critique a song and a vocal performance. I pride myself on the fact that I can deconstruct a song and say constructively what can be improved by highlighting the areas that need attention and suggesting what changes may be necessary....I have experience in writing, performing, recording, production and all the various processes involved. I am also experienced enough to know a bad vocal performance from a good one and can easily spot someone who has poor vocal techniques and tonal issues. I hopefully can help anyone to improve their craft whether it be as a performer a writer or producer.
So if I say that so and so sucks as a performer and the song is poor then it probably is true. I am of the opinion that anyone in the spotlight who is supposed to be at the top of the tree deserves such criticism if they and their song are clearly not up to the standard of an average singer singing an average song. I just cannot get my head around the fact that so many can be so blind and deaf. The fact that I need to justify "why I say that" is more a reflection on the person asking the question than it is on me for saying what should be blindingly obvious to anyone with any musical talent. To turn it back on its head.... maybe it is not up to me to say why I think something sucks but up to the people who cannot find fault to explain why they think it is any good.
That said I am quite content just listening to music and admiring the song and performance........sadly the pop charts does not contain much in that category.
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 8,463
Top 20 Poster
|
Top 20 Poster
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 8,463 |
Here is a song that illustrates and even proves the main points of my argument. Most pop music is just crap and it is so easy to take a simple song add a thumping beat and it could become a hit....... anyone can do it......please please please take a listen. It will be an education. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vzsvUMsqbi0
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781
Top 500 Poster
|
OP
Top 500 Poster
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781 |
That's really Gross and deteriorating to this discussion.
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 8,463
Top 20 Poster
|
Top 20 Poster
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 8,463 |
Yeah but it is funny to anyone with a sense of humour and it makes a point. I see no difference comparing that to the Rihanna soft porn videos which are just as gross not funny and are musically and lyrically just as simple.
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781
Top 500 Poster
|
OP
Top 500 Poster
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781 |
I have a sense of humor but this for me goes beyond that. For someone who might give you the benefit of the doubt and think might have some validity to your points of view, I think will find this insulting. you should really rethink this.
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 8,463
Top 20 Poster
|
Top 20 Poster
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 8,463 |
I am sorry you are so easily offended. This does not detract from my argument it just illustrates my point albeit in a humorous way. A lot worse happens in Rihanna and Gaga videos and these are aimed at kids. I bet even kids would have a laugh at the harmless YouTube clip.
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781
Top 500 Poster
|
OP
Top 500 Poster
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781 |
Hi John,
Great Points! Thanks for responding.-Dana
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781
Top 500 Poster
|
OP
Top 500 Poster
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781 |
Hi Jay,
Again, I agree with you. This post has gotten a bit off Target about the kind of Criticism I was speaking of. You are Spot on. Thanks for posting.-Dana
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Apr 2001
Posts: 20,017 Likes: 34
Top 10 Poster
|
Top 10 Poster
Joined: Apr 2001
Posts: 20,017 Likes: 34 |
I saw Lady Gaga live in Paris in October and she was FANTASTIC and I've seen over 30K artists perform live around the Western World. Great songwriting, great vocal work. Great theatrics.
I guess she's not the Bay City Rollers for you Jim, but unless you've seen her live, you can't really judge. And seeing a video is not more valid than the extended Fart Joke video you posted.
By the way, for many years in France and Europe there was a wildly famous guy who made his living Farting songs and sounds for real.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Le_P%C3%A9tomane
So anything is possible and this guy did it for real, not using samples and sound effects like the guys in Jim's youtube video.
Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery right?
Brian
Brian Austin Whitney Founder Just Plain Folks jpfolkspro@gmail.com Skype: Brian Austin Whitney Facebook: www.facebook.com/justplainfolks"Don't sit around and wait for success to come to you... it doesn't know the way." -Brian Austin Whitney "It's easier to be the bigger man when you actually are..." -Brian Austin Whitney "Sometimes all you have to do to inspire humans to greatness is to give them a reason and opportunity to do something great." -Brian Austin Whitney
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: May 2002
Posts: 2,043 Likes: 3
Top 200 Poster
|
Top 200 Poster
Joined: May 2002
Posts: 2,043 Likes: 3 |
One of the best concerts I have ever been to was a Prince concert during his Musicology tour.
It was in 2004 and I was on a Temporary Duty Assignment for some training at Keesler Air Force Base. As base housing was fully booked, I was staying in at the Gulfport Beachfront Hotel on Beach Blvd, where behind the hotel, was the big concert venue was that Prince was performing at. I was in my hotel room and I saw crowds of people flocking over to the venue. Curiously, I left my room and went to the box office to see who was performing. I bought my ticket ($80 bought me a seat two rows from the stage and a Prince Musicology CD) and I was blown away by an amazing performance from a five star musician.
There's a lot of GOOD talent out there right now, but unfortunately, they don't match up with the GREATS. Legends are legends for a reason.
What does this have to do with the topic? Simply this. Opinions are subjective. I bet you there was at least one person in that venue that night who thought it was the worst performance they have ever seen. Can't please everyone.
So, follow your heart and write with the pen made from your soul. Don't worry about anything else until YOU are satisfied first. Opinions are like ***holes, everyone's got one. Be objective when you're done and really listen to your work. If it isn't any good, you'll be the first to know. Trust me on that.
Jim, EVERYBODY on this board knows what your opinion is. I respect you buddy, but I still like McDonalds! :-D (Not really, I hate McDonalds, but I'm sure you understand the analogy)
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Jan 2008
Posts: 2,764
Top 100 Poster
|
Top 100 Poster
Joined: Jan 2008
Posts: 2,764 |
By the way, for many years in France and Europe there was a wildly famous guy who made his living Farting songs and sounds for real.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Le_P%C3%A9tomane
So anything is possible and this guy did it for real, not using samples and sound effects like the guys in Jim's youtube video.
Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery right?
Brian I don't even have to look at the Wiki article to know who you're talking about Brian. I saw him perform once on an award show. Afterwards, Kelsey Grammer, who was hosting said "And now you know why in France, Jerry Lewis is a god." Imitation is the sincerest form of flatulance, perhaps? Midnite
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 8,463
Top 20 Poster
|
Top 20 Poster
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 8,463 |
Greg I agree with you about Prince. I am a fan. I have never seen him live but have seen a dvd of a live concert "Rave 2000" he was great and I love the way he changes style to accommodate the different guests he had. OK the guy has a screw or two loose but there is no mistaking his playing and writing talent.
Brian the Rollers were a joke. Only very young girls liked them. I knew them and worked with some of the original line up before they were famous. I still bump into some of the guys. The original singer uses the same studio as me. Whilst they were a popular band playing pop covers live in and around Edinburgh in the 60s the line up changed when they got a record deal. It is obvious that with boy bands looks are more important than musicianship. Anyway they were totally manipulated and manufactured when they hit the big time. By the way their management ripped them off and stole all the money they earned. It has vanished and despite a police investigation and many court cases the guys will never get their hands on a penny of the millions they earned during their short fifteen minutes of fame. Although their manager went to prison, it was for sexual offences against young boys and drug offences not for stealing their money.... he died a couple of years ago taking the secrets of the whereabouts of their money to the grave. Re the farting guys well I thought it would be a light hearted way of showing that any ditty with a bit of production and crassness can potentially become a hit. I see little difference between that and the pop stuff that does chart.
Whilst I do not like Gaga and Rihanna (subjective) the point that I was making is that their videos are just soft porn. It is obvious that this will sell to the hormone laden adolescents whilst the music is secondary and on its own average at best.
Greg I understand...... you only like Macdonalds cause everybody else is suckered into liking junk and you follow suit. I hope you get the analogy. Deep down you know they suck but are too afraid to spoil your cred by admitting it.
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Sep 2011
Posts: 458
Top 500 Poster
|
Top 500 Poster
Joined: Sep 2011
Posts: 458 |
"Is it possible that those who Criticize another Writer's work in this way are Hurting Themselves?" Yes, because I think they've not undestood the RULE. there's not necessarily a link between quality and what make a song perfect for the market LOL. The question I think is: do you want to sell? then find someone who know how to sell and be ready for to do what you're told (and probably you will not be able to do it! LOL). As a 60/70 music fan, I heard lot of stories of really good writers that hadnt had a hit, but they had following (unwillingly and then regreating, LOL) good suggestions from producers and labels. But they had.
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Dec 2000
Posts: 12,255 Likes: 56
Top 10 Poster
|
Top 10 Poster
Joined: Dec 2000
Posts: 12,255 Likes: 56 |
Big Jim, you lost me when you posted that video as an example of pop. Even if some guy got a few minutes of fame farting a tune, it in no way shape or form constitute anything other than a novelty act, and a bad one at that. You alluded though that you posted this "in fun". I guess you could not find a better example of bad pop?
And I've lost respect for your opinion by your arrogant stance that you should never have to explain your opinion on music if challenged on it or asked to explain it, because the mere questioning of your opinion by someone just demonstrates how blindingly obvious it is that they are far beneath you in musical talent.
You may want to rethink your position on this.
You really have to explain yourself more when you offer up an opinion as to why you think the way you do.
The Bowie thread is a good example.
After you stated your opinion that you did not like it, I explained why I thought it all hung together, the video, the lyric, the music. But all you did was come back with "it does not rock my boat, and it is somewhat of a dirge. C'est tout. Only a rehash of of your opinion and some allusion that all dirges are bad.
Oops you did say that parts of the video were derivative..which was factual, but does carry a value judgement in it...ie, some might have said "paid homage to"
If writing ever becomes work I think I'm going to have to stop
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: May 2002
Posts: 2,043 Likes: 3
Top 200 Poster
|
Top 200 Poster
Joined: May 2002
Posts: 2,043 Likes: 3 |
HOLY MOLY!!! We AGREED on something?!! (goes outside and then comes back in)....Nope, the sky isn't falling. Wow. We agreed.... Muses over that fact for a while.... Greg I agree with you about Prince. I am a fan. I have never seen him live but have seen a dvd of a live concert "Rave 2000" he was great and I love the way he changes style to accommodate the different guests he had. OK the guy has a screw or two loose but there is no mistaking his playing and writing talent.
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: May 2002
Posts: 2,043 Likes: 3
Top 200 Poster
|
Top 200 Poster
Joined: May 2002
Posts: 2,043 Likes: 3 |
And I'm done musing....The agreement ends here. I enjoy pop music, not because everyone else does, but because I GENUINELY LIKE it. That does not mean I like ALL pop music. There are songs and artists I will not listen to, who I will change the channel if they come on the radio/tv. I personally like songs with a good melody, good story/lyric, and the musical production/arrangement has more than 2 chord changes. I hate "BEATS", those start to finish imitations that don't have much variety or change in them. Sometimes, an artist can pull it off, but not often. My favorite POP artist of all time is Michael Jackson so to speak. I also love PRINCE, and I could list many others, but I won't bore you with the details. Greg I understand...... you only like Macdonalds cause everybody else is suckered into liking junk and you follow suit. I hope you get the analogy. Deep down you know they suck but are too afraid to spoil your cred by admitting it.
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 8,463
Top 20 Poster
|
Top 20 Poster
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 8,463 |
John and Greg you are twisting my words. I never said or implied that anyone was beneath me or that I was superior to anyone in any way shape or form. I am not like that. What I did say is that a lot of the pop songs are puerile by even basic standards and some artists have very little talent and are undeserving of their chart position or success...I also said that anybody regardless of talent can be a pop star if they have the backing of someone like Simon Cowell..... and that just about anyone can write a song of a similar standard to some of the rubbish we hear in the charts.....BIG difference to what you infer. I did say however that with a degree of musical ability folk should be able to spot these undeserving artists cause it is blindingly obvious in their songs and performances therefore there is no need for me to point them out or give any specifics or analysis as to why they suck. Now you said that certain things get turned off the second you hear them cause you hate them and refuse to listen........I think we have more in common than you think.
I also like good pop music but I tend to be more discerning than the average pop fan perhaps because I can see through the smoke and mirrors. The vast bulk of pop SEEMS TO fall into the category of things that you dislike by your own definition so you must dislike almost as much as me. The industry is run by crooks who have no interest in musical quality, art, talent or anything HONORABLE they are only concerned about making a buck. They will exploit anybody and anything if they think there is a buck to be made and drop them like a hot potato at a whim..... a heck of a lot of pop stars these guys take on are shallow, naïve and show similar singing talent to the pub karaoke on any given Saturday so it is no wonder that I have an intense dislike of the way things are run and some of the people involved who make most of the decisions about what is recorded and who records it.
Re Bowie...after all the comments and bad feelings against me for what I said about his latest song I thought that I was bound to be the only one who was disappointed in the new single....well just tonight I was playing a gig, I am just back, and a guy I knew who does a Bowie tribute act and is a huge fan, I mean huge, was in the audience with his band. We chatted for a while after the gig and when asked about the new single to a man they felt it was nothing special. Comments included The lyrics were weak and boring it was not one of his best videos ever and that it seemed to be a rehash of some of his gratuitous self indulgent unreleased rejected work possibly from "Heathen" which they had managed to get their hands on and listened to some years back. I even heard the word dirge used by a couple of band members. The guy also said that even he as a Bowie devotee realised that Bowie did produce more than his fair share of crap in amongst the diamonds....He felt this was a bit of a doodoo. However on a lighter note They had heard the full album and said that some of the songs were pretty good....Strange to pick the worst song on the album as a single to promote.
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: May 2002
Posts: 2,043 Likes: 3
Top 200 Poster
|
Top 200 Poster
Joined: May 2002
Posts: 2,043 Likes: 3 |
It appears we're finally in agreement and on the same page then. :-) Now you said that certain things get turned off the second you hear them cause you hate them and refuse to listen........I think we have more in common than you think.
I also like good pop music but I tend to be more discerning than the average pop fan perhaps because I can see through the smoke and mirrors. The vast bulk of pop SEEMS TO fall into the category of things that you dislike by your own definition so you must dislike almost as much as me. The industry is run by crooks who have no interest in musical quality, art, talent or anything HONORABLE they are only concerned about making a buck. They will exploit anybody and anything if they think there is a buck to be made and drop them like a hot potato at a whim..... a heck of a lot of pop stars these guys take on are shallow, naïve and show similar singing talent to the pub karaoke on any given Saturday so it is no wonder that I have an intense dislike of the way things are run and some of the people involved who make most of the decisions about what is recorded and who records it.
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Dec 2000
Posts: 12,255 Likes: 56
Top 10 Poster
|
Top 10 Poster
Joined: Dec 2000
Posts: 12,255 Likes: 56 |
Thanks for explaining those statements Big Jim..I must simply have drawn the wrong conclusion when you said "The fact that I need to justify "why I say that" is more a reflection on the person asking the question than it is on me for saying what should be blindingly obvious to anyone with any musical talent. To turn it back on its head.... maybe it is not up to me to say why I think something sucks but up to the people who cannot find fault to explain why they think it is any good."
So lets put that behind us.
As to the state of things, I can't disagree with you.
I used to do a lot of hiring out of university for the firm I was with.
Now I started by sorting resumes, so that everyone I would interview had roughly the same skill sets, intellectual capability, etc, then relied on the interview where I looked primarily to their communication skills.
I think a similar thing happens at the music company level. They see many artists who have similar skills, but get behind those they feel they can promote the best and earn the most from...
...so good music is lost because the arbitration is not through the music and talent itself but through the economics of the industry.
Its why these televised talent shows are so smart. It makes finding and promoting the talent a profit making venture. As a business model it is genius.
Back to Bowie. I agree his latest single is not his best..all I wanted from you was more than your opinion. I wanted to know what this opinion was based on....more of a critique.
Later..
If writing ever becomes work I think I'm going to have to stop
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 8,463
Top 20 Poster
|
Top 20 Poster
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 8,463 |
John I could give an in depth critique but see no reason to. Cant a guy simply say that he is not a big fan of a certain song or video and that it in his opinion it is not up to the artists usual standard..... heck I am a fan just not keen on this latest song.....it did get mixed reviews so I am not alone. I am sure you have made this self same criticism or judgement countless times about an artists latest song. If you said that you did not like something then I cannot make you like it and I cannot make you dislike something you like.....I hate the taste of sage but some people love it. I have no idea why I simply feel sick at the very smell or taste of it. That is why we are all different. I did not say Bowie sucks or the song is crap. I just said it does not rock my boat and IMO is not up to his usual standard.
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Dec 2000
Posts: 12,255 Likes: 56
Top 10 Poster
|
Top 10 Poster
Joined: Dec 2000
Posts: 12,255 Likes: 56 |
Generally yes, simple opinion is fine, especially because it is subjective. But in the dynamic of our discussion here and at the Bowie thread, I had expected more from you because you asked me to justify why I thought the way i did, which resulted me in asking why you felt the way you did...beyond simple opinion. But I'm happy to let it rest 
If writing ever becomes work I think I'm going to have to stop
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781
Top 500 Poster
|
OP
Top 500 Poster
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781 |
Hopefully we can learn something from this discussion. I appreciate all the comments. Whether I agree with them or not. Thanks for joining in.-Dana
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Jun 2006
Posts: 7,712
Top 30 Poster
|
Top 30 Poster
Joined: Jun 2006
Posts: 7,712 |
I think most criticism is meant to be hurtful.
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Feb 2007
Posts: 10,943 Likes: 3
Top 10 Poster
|
Top 10 Poster
Joined: Feb 2007
Posts: 10,943 Likes: 3 |
I think most criticism is meant to be hurtful. Hmmm, I certainly hope this is not true. The MP3 and Lyric boards seem to be totally dependent on peer to peer "criticism". If we are all trying to be hurtful, that would be a major bummer.
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781
Top 500 Poster
|
OP
Top 500 Poster
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781 |
Hi Jim,
There's a difference between Constructive Criticism and the kind that this discussion is about. Thanks for responding.-Dana
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 8,463
Top 20 Poster
|
Top 20 Poster
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 8,463 |
I am all for constructive criticism......sorry to be blunt but If you read my posts properly and had any experience and understanding of the business and were not so easily offended then you would see exactly where I am coming from.
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 8,463
Top 20 Poster
|
Top 20 Poster
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 8,463 |
Sorry double post. My laptop is playing up.
Last edited by BIG JIM MERRILEES; 01/21/13 09:05 PM.
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Dec 2008
Posts: 10,927 Likes: 91
Top 10 Poster
|
Top 10 Poster
Joined: Dec 2008
Posts: 10,927 Likes: 91 |
I think criticism that leads to improving the music and recording is priceless. I’m never offended by honest criticism. Big Jim helped me address a volume issue I had in my earlier recordings. Clipping and unintentional distortion or volume levels too low frequented my earlier tracks. Don’t know if I ever thanked Jim. Just in case I didn’t, THANK YOU BIG JIM! However, I had a musician on another website tell me one of my tracks didn’t make any sense. Then he continued to lecture me on harmony, counterpoint, melody, etc. Was I offended? No, he was an idiot that didn’t know what he was talking about.  Anyway, the track in question ended up receiving a Recording Magazine's 5-Star “Spotlight” rating by none other than Marty Peters. http://www.recordingmag.com/tapereviews/2010/05/107.htmlBest advice is to welcome all criticism. Then objectively consider it. There's always going to be people that find pleasure in destroying another's motivation, inspiration and productivity (conflict between the destroyers and the producers). Don't give the destroyers a second thought. Best, John
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 8,463
Top 20 Poster
|
Top 20 Poster
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 8,463 |
Dana post something and I will give you an honest in depth constructive critique. Perhaps you might learn something and change your opinion of me at the same time...... any song or a lyric written by you will do. If you do not want to post it on the boards for everyone to see I will be happy to do it via PM.
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781
Top 500 Poster
|
OP
Top 500 Poster
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781 |
Jim,
I don't have a 'negative' opinion of you. I just differ with some of your opinions. I do appreciate hearing them though, they are quite amusing.-Cheers!-Dana
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 8,463
Top 20 Poster
|
Top 20 Poster
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 8,463 |
On what do you differ? and why? just curious. I do not mind criticism of any kind or you expressing different opinions from me just would like to know the reasons why and what experiences you have had that make you see the music business and songwriting in a completely different light from me. I also find some of your opinions amusing they seem to come from someone quite inexperienced easily offended and often a tad naïve. I notice no mention of taking up my offer. I am disappointed and can only wonder about a reason for this.
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781
Top 500 Poster
|
OP
Top 500 Poster
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781 |
Hi Jim
Jim's quote-
"The difficulty is not writing pop songs.... I am sure most people can write a song that is as good/bad as any of Rhiannas etc etc etc and I know for a fact that there are countless wannabes who are every bit as bad a singer.....
I dissagree. Pop Songs are written everyday. Writing a great one is not an easy task. I think Rihanna is a very talented and capable Singer.
it is getting anybody to promote them....or even listen to them. I can show you songs on this very forum that are far better than the charts...
Not saying it isn't possible but I would be interested in seeing what you believe could compete with what's on the Charts.
They have no hope of charting.......the record industry is a closed shop....where only the invited few for whatever reason stand a chance..
I disagree. The Record Industry is closed to those who believe it to be. Everyone must Navigate their Journey through to the Success they want from themselves, regardless of the 'Roadblocks' placed by others. No one is 'Born' into the Business. They make their way.
....I can tell you that talent or song quality is not a prerequisite."
Everyone has a different view of what Talent or Song quality is, they are one of many factors in Record Labels deciding who to put their support behind.
Those are a few things. We may disagree on. Not everything on the Charts are great, but that can be said, has been said from as long as Music has been on them.
Jim,
Your attempt at 'baiting' me to post My Music so you can 'Render' your judgement on it, is 'amusing.'
You are free to think I'm easily offended or naive about the Music Business, to debate you on such foolish assumptions is not something that interests me.
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 8,463
Top 20 Poster
|
Top 20 Poster
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 8,463 |
Dana I find you attitude admirable. You stick to what you believe in and are not easily dissuaded. That is good. However with such beliefs and dogged determination comes naivety into refusing to accept the hard facts. Whilst I agree that writing a great pop song is difficult and few can really do it to a decent consistent level that does nothing to counter my actual argument that anyone can write a hit simply because the general standard of chart material and performers is so poor and the business is corrupt enough to actually allow such things to happen......two completely different things. The hard fact remains that with the way the business is set up quality counts for very little so anyone CAN potentially be a pop star or write a pop hit without showing any real quality either as a singer or writer. In fact it can be argued that writing a great pop song with a view to making any money from it is a pointless exercise. It aint gonna happen for a variety of reasons. Here is one. Shine bright like a diamond Shine bright like a diamond
Find light in the beautiful sea I choose to be happy You and I, you and I We’re like diamonds in the sky
You’re a shooting star I see A vision of ecstasy When you hold me, I’m alive We’re like diamonds in the sky
I knew that we’d become one right away Oh, right away At first sight I left the energy of sun rays I saw the life inside your eyes
So shine bright, tonight you and I We’re beautiful like diamonds in the sky Eye to eye, so alive We’re beautiful like diamonds in the sky
Shine bright like a diamond Shine bright like a diamond Shining bright like a diamond We’re beautiful like diamonds in the sky
Shine bright like a diamond Shine bright like a diamond Shining bright like a diamond We’re beautiful like diamonds in the sky
Palms rise to the universe As we moonshine and molly Feel the warmth, we’ll never die We’re like diamonds in the sky
You’re a shooting star I see A vision of ecstasy When you hold me, I’m alive We’re like diamonds in the sky
At first sight I felt the energy of sun rays I saw the life inside your eyes
So shine bright, tonight you and I We’re beautiful like diamonds in the sky Eye to eye, so alive We’re beautiful like diamonds in the sky
Shine bright like a diamond Shine bright like a diamond Shining bright like a diamond We’re beautiful like diamonds in the sky
Shine bright like a diamond Shine bright like a diamond Shining bright like a diamond We’re beautiful like diamonds in the sky
Shine bright like a diamond Shine bright like a diamond Shine bright like a diamond
So shine bright, tonight you and I We’re beautiful like diamonds in the sky Eye to eye, so alive We’re beautiful like diamonds in the sky
Shine bright like a diamond Shine bright like a diamond Shine bright like a diamond Shine bright like a diamond Shine bright like a diamond Shine bright like a diamond Shine bright like a diamond
I rest my case.......any kid with a crayon and a smattering of English could pen such rubbish. As for the vocal performance it is akin production and performance wise to the farting guy. Going through the charts there are countless examples of such rubbish. A few synths a beat and a pretty kid who can barely sing in tune. Match that with a couple of lines repeated ad nauseum add a sexy video...and voila you have a hit.....if the right people back it. Ask yourself why they chose that over some of the wonderful songs they have at their disposal or anything you or I or countless others would ever write.
As for baiting you well you obviously have no idea about me and what I do. I have no intention of rendering a judgement as you so crudely put it. I simply was offering my humble services to give a positive constructive critique in the hope you might learn something. I see nothing funny in that....the only funny thing I do see is a reluctance on your part to show what you can do especially as any aspiring songwriter tends to want to show their songs off to anyone who will listen. You obviously have your reasons. I suspect we both know what they are. You can differ all you like from my opinions, observations and experiences of the industry.....BUT at the end of the day the general rules as I have explained them are true.....and neither of us are gonna change things anytime soon. Follow your dreams, write great songs...but keep at least one eye on reality. I wish you luck..... somehow I think you are gonna need it.
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781
Top 500 Poster
|
OP
Top 500 Poster
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781 |
Hi Jim,
We can agree to disagree then. Feel free to think what you like about why I haven't taken your 'bait' I have no desire to entertain your 'humble services' as you put it.
Jim,
These are some of the things sent to me in a PM by a very Successful Accomplished Hit Songwriter.
"Dear Dana. I loved your Song" "I admire what you did." "I remember your writing and respect you"
I won't reveal who this person is or everything said to me out of respect that it was a PM. But this person helped Validate what I always believed about my Songwriting.
So thanks very much for your 'offer' but I'm good.-Dana
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Oct 2007
Posts: 3,865
Top 100 Poster
|
Top 100 Poster
Joined: Oct 2007
Posts: 3,865 |
Brian, You might have to add a caveat when people join up.
"If you ask for someones honest opinion you just might get one"
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 8,463
Top 20 Poster
|
Top 20 Poster
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 8,463 |
Dana we will agree to disagree then. Just remember that one day of sunshine does not make a summer. The whole idea of posting on feedback boards is to get lots of feedback from different sources to obtain a consensus of opinion and hopefully figure out where strengths and weaknesses lie. You seem to be under the misapprehension that I would attack your song in some negative way...Nothing could be further from the truth. Check out some of my critiques and you will see that not only am I honest and fair but I pinpoint the specifics that IMO are weak and highlight areas of strength. I thought that is exactly what you were looking for from any critique.
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781
Top 500 Poster
|
OP
Top 500 Poster
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781 |
Hi Caroline
I'm not sure if you are following the thread closely but I am not speaking about a Critique someone might give another on the Forum.Cheers-Dana
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781
Top 500 Poster
|
OP
Top 500 Poster
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 781 |
Hi Jim,
Again, it seems the thread is off Target. You seem to be under the assumption that I would care to have your Opinion, I did not ask for it. Again, I am not speaking of the kind of Critique of a Song someone would post on a Forum. I think you know that by now.-Dana
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Dec 2006
Posts: 5,830
Top 50 Poster
|
Top 50 Poster
Joined: Dec 2006
Posts: 5,830 |
Hi Jim,
We can agree to disagree then. Feel free to think what you like about why I haven't taken your 'bait' I have no desire to entertain your 'humble services' as you put it.
Jim,
These are some of the things sent to me in a PM by a very Successful Accomplished Hit Songwriter.
"Dear Dana. I loved your Song" "I admire what you did." "I remember your writing and respect you"
I won't reveal who this person is or everything said to me out of respect that it was a PM. But this person helped Validate what I always believed about my Songwriting.
So thanks very much for your 'offer' but I'm good.-Dana Hey Dana, With ctitiques, they are many and varied. But they are weighted upon someones experience in the field. That experience is clearly and freely demonstrated via a link to your work. If you are either unable, or unwilling to demonstrate your craft, then who is going to take you seriously ? You don't have a link to your work under your signature. Is it all just make believe ? cheers, niteshift
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Dec 2009
Posts: 413
Top 500 Poster
|
Top 500 Poster
Joined: Dec 2009
Posts: 413 |
Admittedly, I've only read a few of the preceding posts, so I may be going completely astray...
I believe that there are huge differences in the style of lyrics with respect to different musical genres*. Therefore, there are no common criteria as to what is good or bad. Most pop and dance songs do NOT tell stories, for example.
I do NOT believe that songwriters/artists can be sucessful over a stretch of time if they are no good. The record companies may be able to push beautiful young girlies up to the top to create a one-hit wonder, but that's about it. Those who stay at the top for years are there BECAUSE they are good (marketing campaigns do their part, of course).
I like being criticized. It helps me get better with respect to my own personal criteria.
Cheers, Bernd
* one of the more ridiculous aspects of JPF is dividing the lyrics sections into "one", "two", "three" instead of as for genres. When my lyrics are criticized I often have to take into account that (most) others come from the country genre which I do NOT write for, so many contributions are slightly off.
Last edited by Bernd Harmsen; 01/23/13 01:48 PM.
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Dec 2000
Posts: 12,255 Likes: 56
Top 10 Poster
|
Top 10 Poster
Joined: Dec 2000
Posts: 12,255 Likes: 56 |
Hi Bernd
One of the reasons there is a 1 2 and 3 board is that traffic was so heavy, and boards became so full, that Brian thought he would divide up the traffic.
Your point is good, but the history of this place kinda dictated how it is grwon.
If you rebuild from the ground up, your approach would make sense.
I also like your point about quality and talent having staying power, while manufactured popularity will fall by the wayside.
I guess there are always exceptions to both, but there will always be.
If writing ever becomes work I think I'm going to have to stop
|
|
|
|
We would like to keep the membership in Just Plain Folks FREE! Your donation helps support the many programs we offer including Road Trips and the Music Awards.
|
|
|
Forums118
Topics129,178
Posts1,186,197
Members21,480
| |
Most Online236,505 Jul 1st, 2026
|
|
|
"Do not endeavor to be the smartest kid in a dumb class. Instead, you are better off being the dumbest kid in the smartest class, where you will be challenged and you will learn. If you aren't growing, you are dying." -Brian Austin Whitney
|
|
|
|