Originally Posted by Fdemetrio
Tom,

You are a pretty good singer-songwriter.

I'm not a fan of this one that said. What's wrong with this site is response like Marty's and Travis. I mean, why bother?

Marty says... Nice song. Then talks about something else. Nice song? I saw him say pleasant song to others....

Wowwwww.

Then Travis says pleasing melody????

I mean Jesus Christ. They simply wanna exchange pleasantries in order to get the same. In end means nothing to you.

I'll say this ..
This one is bad. But I enjoyed both songs that came after this one. Kept me listening.

This one with the harmonica is good.

Problem with the site is we don't have enough people. Especially people who know anything about songwriting.

Cliques will form , and Buddy systems will be here.

But I would never trust a review from Marty or Travis


I use to fall in line with all those with flippant remarks towards "atta-boys". But over the years, I've began to resent all those who simply want to shred someone else's musical ideas to mirror their own. I appreciate "atta-boys" far more than the twisting and wringing of my song to a beat that makes no sense to me.
I like the first impressions I get and do appreciate comments... but often come the butcher's knives to carve out what shouldn't be touched. And sadly, when the suggestions are argued, then the ole "you just want atta-boys" speeches come out. LOL. I've learned to appreciate "atta-boys"

BTW, "Fair-Weather Friends" is a bad song?