grin It's different for me...I have to try to keep them short...too much early 70's influence always telling me to write five and six minute songs.

Keep in mind that the Beatles wrote for the pop market of the 60's. The norm at the time was to keep songs less than three minutes. Look at any late 50's/early 60's pop songs and you will find lots of similar numbers. "You Really Got Me" by the Kinks was 2:14. So, at the time, no one was amazed by how short the songs were...but the eyebrows raised when they did really long ones like "Hey Jude" and "I Want You (She's So Heavy)", although it was Dylan who broke that mold in '65 with "Like a Rolling Stone". Then the 70's brought us Prog Rock and MOR and album cuts on FM, and we became used to longer songs. Now? Yeah, about 3:30.

That sort of economy of style is a great teacher for songwriters...the goal is to drill it down to the basics. Now THERE'S a songwriting challenge for us... smile