Derek,
I tend to divide their career into two eras. From their first album up to Revolver and then from Pepper till Abbey Road. I liked more of Lennon's songs in the first era and more of what Paul did in the latter. Paul was more melodic in his songs for the most part although Lennon was as well. If you look at their early albums, Lennon had the slightly more of the cuts where later it was more of Paul than Lennon.

Paul's bass lines from Paperback Writer on were very melodic and ground breaking in their own right, especially on Pepper and Magical Mystery Tour. My two favorite albums personally were A Hard Day's Night and Magical Mystery tour because the bulk of my favorite songs as a kid came from those two. My top five favorite songs are:

Penny Lane
I Should Have Known Better
I'll Cry Instead
I'm Happy Just To Dance With You
I Am the Walrus

From the rest I couldn't choose. As for I'M HAPPY JUST TO DANCE WITH YOU, you'll never a better or more creative rhythm guitar part. Amazing.

Pepper was great musically and lyrically, especially "A Day In The Life" and Paul played bass like a lead instrument which is still amazing for the bass lines he played. Listen to the bass line on "Little Help From My Friends." The second side of Abbey Road, the medley is amazing. What a way to thread together a bunch of unfinished songs into one cohesive unit.

Those are a few thoughts for a lifelong Beatlemanic. I've suffered from B.M. (Beatlemania0 from the Sulivan shows till now. There's no cure for me. I still listen to their music more than anything else along with the post surf/car songs of the Beach Boys. Brian Wilson truly is a musical genius. Ask Paul or George Martin.

Steve


I'm the only person here who is not unique.