It's not the length that will determine if any song we do now will have the same affect as those great freakin songs of The Beatles, it's the quality of every placed chord, melody line and sound of the lyrics, (even more than the meaning of some, which were of course creative after some time of them writing.

Long intros, instrumental breaks,,,,whatever! No assume affect, time or otherwise, if the "song" is just OK, or worse. The least concerns should be time by adding a long intro or a lead. Should be on trying to write great songs, (melodies and the sounds of them).

Point of how even a short song can feel longer: They would get two bridges in, after even having an intro and a couple verses, WITH a chorus, and still be under 3 minutes! And none if it sounds crammed. You can listen to some of those songs and swear it must be over three minutes by a good margin,,,but they're not! Time was not the issue, only a writing skill at the highest level for Pop Rock was.

Be concise, tell something, and then get out, was their way of writing. No boring long intros or leads that had nothing to do with the "song", just catchy melodies with a sound and feel. Magic to have known that at such early ages. Most bands are only getting to be booked regularly around their area when in their mid twenties. They were on Ed Sullivan at just around 20, up to 23 or 24, (for Ringo), if I have that right. George being 20?

Lennon and McCartney especially in the early days wrote songs within a 1/4 of a day, and every time they set out to do so!
Neither has said they had a stop watch for the song length. They just knew what felt great for them, and with them having great musical instincts that can't be taught. No click tracks either. Just counted off what the pocket of the song could be, and Martin took it from there, either asking or telling them to slow or speed it up, (as in Please Please Me). That was first written in the style of Roy Orbison, after he and The Beatles were touring in Europe before Beatlemania, and The guys heard Roy composing one of his future hits in the back of the tour bus. Paul has said that he turned to Lennon and said, "We have to write songs like THAT!. So they composed Please Please Me in that slow ballad style of Roy's. George Martin heard it, and said it's a great song, but needs to be faster to have more energy from the guy's vocals. (Play that song in Roy's style sometime and see how it was first written)!

The time of the song or songs was not talked about as far as some studio notes books have it. Probably was of course, but it looks like The Beatles just had a great sense of getting to the heart of the song fast and then get to the ending. (For they had so much going on in both work load and creative writing that the top must have been spinning fast all the time.

When I started to write a song for an album not to be, with a friend who was going to write in the style of Lennon, I came up with sort of a Paul tune somehow, and didn't think of song length of anything....Just started singing and playing a tune, wanting to come up with something in a short time period, to see if it could be done like that. The song comes in at 2:04, the same length as Yesterday,,,but it is a faster song. Intro, Verse, Chorus, Intro break, Verse, Chorus, Chorus, Chorus, Ending. See? Lots there, but not taking up time with just adding whatever to do get it at any particular time. No waste. Paul and friends heard it, (from one of the guitar players in his current band getting it by email from his screener), and got back to me saying "Rusty and friends like the song, and it is a good Paul-like write, Good luck with it".

The point is a song is good or not, not by the length, but by how it moves someone. How it does in the music business is another story, for all the factors that then have to be dealt with, like marketing. That song would be, and is tough to know where to place it, with how radio is now. That's cool, for that song ends all our shows and is just fun to play for all of us, and is a tribute of sorts to The Beatles.

Many of us boomers try to capture some things in our bands and songs,,,,,BUT it is a bar SO high as to just look up and say, HOW the hell did they come up with ALL that great material and sound, and do it, like Sub said, in 6 years? (once they had Beatlemania going that is). They started around 1957 in one way or another, with various members coming and going at first. But it was Lennon who was the foundation, the leader of all the versions of his band. He choose who was to be in the bands, and his greatest decision was to include a young Paul, (because Paul could tune a guitar the right way, and knew all the words to a certain song that I can't think of the title right now, (something "Rock" as the title). Damn!!!!

When I watch their videos now, and put on an album when driving on vacations, it feels and sounds fresh still.

Magic caught on tape, for sure!

Imagine their songs ONLY being found in written music years later, and someone plays it and says, "This is Beatles music"!

I don't think so. And maybe just how Mozart isn't really being heard today either. But even more so with The Beatles, for having all the sounds and skills of all the instruments and Martin's production.

Better keep those CD's around,,and transfer them onto whatever the future sound formats will be invented. Just have to hope ears aren't evolved ot hear just pitch control and clicked songs!

John


Actually a Member Since 1996 or 97 (Number One Hundred Something).
https://www.soundclick.com/bands3/default.cfm?bandID=1409522