Originally Posted by Sunset Poet
Ben

If you all did was write the lyrics and someone else wrote the music and produced it...a jaded view is that...you paid to play...in the game.

And the V-I's point, that from where you sit, there is little difference from that and clicking a mouse a few times and letting UDIO do the heavy lifting.
He claims a few prompts fully enables him to claim the robot products as his.
You claim that a few prompts coupled with a few bucks enables you to claim that the work of others is yours.

I'll let you phrase the next question?....?

Another POV closer to mine...if Carroll's end-product song is good, or your song is good or the V-I's song is good....
the only thing that matters is that good songs were brought into existence, as long as credit is being given where actually deserved.
SIDENOTE: Legally both cases may be true.

To date:
This song is good
Carroll's Whatever For is good
Nothing from the V-I strikes me as actually good. He talks often about the city of gold, but I aint seen no gold from him yet.


But you didn't give me that kind of rationale, and with millions of ways a melody can go, it's still in the user to make sense of if it all.

My lyrics and my musical sense has paved the way for my results

And not only that, I can do it as well without udio

Last edited by Fdemetrio; 05/28/24 02:02 PM.