Originally Posted by Fdemetrio
Yeah music is subjective. but its also objective.

Case in point, yiur response, to Guys latest.

https://www.jpfolks.com/forum/ubbthreads.php/topics/1215445/my-little-sunshine.html#Post1215445

You LOVE, that. You are a fucking idiot, are useless to a forum, you either treat everybody the same, or it has no meaning. Everybody knows you are lying about both songs. Listen to all my songs, try and learn

Dom,
you’re right that music has both subjective and objective elements, but people are still going to hear things differently. Your reaction reminds me of a song I recently wrote:

You turn caps lock on like you’re in a fight,
But your words don’t land right.
You swing hard but you miss the mark.
All that spark, but it’s just dark.
All your noise, it’s so empty.
Loud and wrong on every entry.

I actually did love Guy’s song “My Little Sunshine”. I’m a bit surprised that you, with all your experience and expertise, don’t recognize a good song when you hear it. If you upload that track in Suno, you’ll get a very catchy song with strong hit potential. Guy is one of the few people here who record their songs live in just one take. Of course, I take that into consideration when I listen and give feedback.

I’ve given you thoughtful feedback in the past as well, both positive and critical. If you only want agreement, that’s not really how a forum works.