Big Jim, as Bill said above, there have always been many people with boatloads more talent than those who become stars. That's probably true in almost any field but very true in music. But American Idol did not start that trend. I'm sure we've all known singers, musicians and songwriters who blew us away but never "made it." There are many reasons why this happens but it has been noted many times that persistence almost always wins over talent.

American Idol wasn't the first to "exploit" singers though it's a pretty clever way to do it. What American Idol does offer is a chance for someone who thinks he/she can sing, to have an instant audience and a chance to get exposure he/she would most likely not be able to do on their own. This is a very valuable opportunity but there's a price just like anything else. To me, if you can get up and perform well knowing 30 million people are watching and you don't choke, you are deserving of at least the attention you are getting.

I used to watch AI more but it doesn't bother me to miss any shows. I like to record it and play it back later so I can zip through commercials and most of the banter. I think the appeal of the show is mostly for those who just want to enjoy something on TV a couple of nights a week. It's not for everyone but clearly, a lot of people like it. That doesn't make anyone wrong. It's just a preference. You don't want anything to do with it and that's no problem. Some of us enjoy it and that shouldn't be a problem either.

That said, a part of me totally understands your POV so I certainly don't begrudge what you are saying. I just don't think shows like AI are as responsible for the ills of the current state of the biz as you seem to think.

Van Borden
a.k.a. Buzz Grudge