Hi
I've been gone from this site for quite awhile...well not really gone I guess, just quiet.
I have to post now however because this issue has gotten me a little fired up.

Brian....your posts seem to indicate that you see this as an on-going tiff between two people who don't like each other; which can best be solved by the two just ignoring each other. This may be so but....

The cause of the tiff bothers me.
Alot of the people who have voiced their opinion have sort of indicated that they think what Graham did (does) is ok.

These are people that I use to hang our with here...that I really respect.
And they seem to be suggesting that it's ok for someone to cruise the lyric boards looking to get song ideas from others songwriters lyric efforts.

I don't get it. I'm confused.
Have we stopped respecting the very hard work that each of us puts into our lyrics?....
The special phrases/lines you sweat bullets to come up with for a lyric that make that lyric uniquely yours?

Is it really ok for somebody to cruise by and grab a phrase here or a hook there and use it for their own song, without going through the same creative process (sweating those same bullets) that you did?

I'm not talking about the legalities, or formal ethics necessarily.

I guess I'm just talking about good manners and common courtesy.

I consider it wrong to take a "hook" (any hook..title hook or not)from someone elses lyric, and use it for your own song(even if you modify it alittle).
Especially when you don't ask permission first.


Graham...
Just because you're open about it. Just because you include a posted "thank you" to the person you took the hook from, doesn't justify that fact that you "took" it. It wasn't "offered" to you by that songwriter. You just "took" it.
You've indicated in posts you've made that Lyric Boards are "gold mines" for finding good song ideas. LOL..of course they are!
Cause that's where aspiring songwriters go to post their songwriting ideas...in the form of lyrics. Hatcheries are a great place to catch fish too...but it's not very sporting.

A guy who posts a lyric is saying...
"I lay this basket of fruit before you so that you might help me polish and arrange it...not so you can grab a few pieces to take home and start your own basket"...understand?

Graham...
There is no doubt that you do alot of good stuff here at these boards and are willing to help anyone any way that you can.

But you should re-think this habit of getting your song ideas from other peoples efforts. It's very predatory. And I know you're creative enough to come up with you own ideas...right?

GJ

P.S.
Hi to all you guys I haven't seen for awhile(and you too Jersey where ever you are..lol).
I still read y'alls stuff and listen to your songs when ever I have time.





[This message has been edited by GJShades (edited 06-06-2003).]