Yup, should that song "hit" I would expect some credit for you too Couch..in fact there was a court case here in Canada (I think it was Jann Arden) where a collaborator sued.

Expert witnesses gave evidence of a "point system" where hooks and other components are individually recognized.

AND I recall a story where the Rolling Stones inadvertently borrowed something which, when they found out about it, resulted in a co write credit.


So I would definitely back you up there, at least to giving your claim serious consideration. And the fact Graham openly acknowledged your contribution adds credence to your position.

But my point is wholly predicated on this being more of a development forum, a place where we help educate one another. "Hits" here only tell us we're on the right track.


Thereafter, its music and sell sell sell. Then, maybe, if you're lucky, its a hit.


But maybe we should give more "formal" consideration to your point about what should "officially" happen HERE, TODAY, when hooks inspire riffs of it.


What would you suggest? How much further than an acknowledgement should Graham have gone? Should he have emailed you as a courtesy to warn you, to ask permission (as you stated), to acknowledge you as a "headline co writer"?




[This message has been edited by John Voorpostel (edited 06-07-2003).]


If writing ever becomes work I think I'm going to have to stop