Gee TT, I tried so hard to be Canadian [Linked Image], and recognize that neither side was entirely right or wrong here.


And on the subject of honesty, Graham gave credit, and was entirely open about his actions. No "mens rea".


Should he have taken the hook and ran with it? You, Shades and others would not, and consider it dishonest. Myself and some others would consider more of the circumstances "surrounding the act" before passing judgement.


This is not a manipulation of the truth, simply trying to understand and place things in context.


I do respect your opinion, and your integrity, and I think people are much more sensitive to this issue now than before, but not allowing people here to alter a hook and taking it in a different direction goes against the nature and spirit of THIS FORUM.


Now IF we are talking about THE REAL WORLD and TWO SUCCESSFUL SONGWRITERS, where one takes a hook from the other, publishes it, and comes out with a song using it, I would probably think differently.


And I do see the point where Graham probably should have waited for the spot light to fade on Couch's lyric. There Couch has a fair complaint.


Like I said earlier, this is not a completely black and white issue for me, at least I am not yet convinced that it is.


Ciao


If writing ever becomes work I think I'm going to have to stop