First of all, anytime there's a "hit" out there, people are going to crawl out of the woodwork with lawsuits, and sometimes an artist/writer, rather that go through a knock-down/drag-out/make-nobody-but-the-lawyers-rich fight, will acquiesce and offer a writing credit or royalty compensation.

That doesn't mean the plaintiff was correct, just that the defendant realizes the inanities of the legal system and that juries will often give awards regardless of actual legal statutes.

Getting inspired by a title/hook one has read, then changing it around and writing an entirely different premise, cannot reasonably be considered infringement.

Of course, there are those with such an overblown opinion of the value of words in general and their own words in particular that shadows will be seen where none truly exist.

That's like saying if someone here wrote a song "I Will Always Love Her" that Dolly Parton is due for a co-write credit.

I haven't heard of anyone collecting infringement on using the phrase "take these broken wings and learn to fly" either.

By the same token, should the author of this current lyric mention something in the liner notes about the movie High Noon, and give the screen writer a co-write? Or will one hypocritically claim never to have heard the immortal line delivered by Gary Cooper, or how the two stories are totally different?

Get over yourselves, folks.

Besides, it's the music that is most often the cause of infringement cases, not the words.

Words are cheap, and everyone knows how to write them. Many know how to write them well. Few know how to put them to music properly.


[This message has been edited by Holly Harden (edited 06-09-2003).]