Here's another reality....I wasn't always at the level I am at now. Brian can attest to that. Lol In my opinion, at one point in the past (until I improved), I didn't exactly "suck", but I wouldn't let anyone hear a lot of my earlier works. haha So even if someone ISN'T commercially viable, that also doesn't mean they won't be in the future. If they got the RIGHT advice from the RIGHT people, they can make leaps and bounds. I just don't think a lot of the people offering "critiques" on the boards are the right people for it (unless their intent isn't to get their songs on the radio or on major artist albums), then by all means, ignore what I say too. :-)