Not sure if this response is even on target anymore, but I completely understand the frustration of hearing "crappy" songs on the radio and feeling like what you write is much better. Having been a professional songwriter for years, I've had loads of songs put on hold only to hear the songs the artists cut instead that are nowhere near as good as the ones my publisher(s) had pitched them. That said, I also realized a long time ago that the saying "It's all about the song" is only true in ideal theory. It's called the music BUSINESS for a reason. It's business, and a lot of times that also means politics.

The other reality is that the music business is not about music, it's about ENTERTAINMENT. To use movies as an example, there are documentaries and blockbusters. From a "craft" standpoint the documentary may be a lot better but no one is under the illusion that it is going to make as much money as the flashiness of the blockbuster. That's what pop music is supposed to be - the flashy blockbuster that appeals to the masses who want to be entertained and aren't interested in the "craft".

The holy grail for us songwriters is a song like "The House That Built Me" - one that is both excellent from a craft standpoint but also appeals to the masses because of it's message.

So to be critical of other's work is completely pointless in my opinion and a waste of time and energy . . . that is unless they ask you for it. And then it should be constructive. As the old saying goes, no one has ever raised a statue in honor of a critic.


http://WWW.ACOUSTICVOCAL.COM
simple and affordable demo solutions for songwriters