Dana I find you attitude admirable. You stick to what you believe in and are not easily dissuaded. That is good. However with such beliefs and dogged determination comes naivety into refusing to accept the hard facts. Whilst I agree that writing a great pop song is difficult and few can really do it to a decent consistent level that does nothing to counter my actual argument that anyone can write a hit simply because the general standard of chart material and performers is so poor and the business is corrupt enough to actually allow such things to happen......two completely different things. The hard fact remains that with the way the business is set up quality counts for very little so anyone CAN potentially be a pop star or write a pop hit without showing any real quality either as a singer or writer. In fact it can be argued that writing a great pop song with a view to making any money from it is a pointless exercise. It aint gonna happen for a variety of reasons.
Here is one.
Shine bright like a diamond
Shine bright like a diamond

Find light in the beautiful sea
I choose to be happy
You and I, you and I
We’re like diamonds in the sky

You’re a shooting star I see
A vision of ecstasy
When you hold me, I’m alive
We’re like diamonds in the sky

I knew that we’d become one right away
Oh, right away
At first sight I left the energy of sun rays
I saw the life inside your eyes

So shine bright, tonight you and I
We’re beautiful like diamonds in the sky
Eye to eye, so alive
We’re beautiful like diamonds in the sky

Shine bright like a diamond
Shine bright like a diamond
Shining bright like a diamond
We’re beautiful like diamonds in the sky

Shine bright like a diamond
Shine bright like a diamond
Shining bright like a diamond
We’re beautiful like diamonds in the sky

Palms rise to the universe
As we moonshine and molly
Feel the warmth, we’ll never die
We’re like diamonds in the sky

You’re a shooting star I see
A vision of ecstasy
When you hold me, I’m alive
We’re like diamonds in the sky

At first sight I felt the energy of sun rays
I saw the life inside your eyes

So shine bright, tonight you and I
We’re beautiful like diamonds in the sky
Eye to eye, so alive
We’re beautiful like diamonds in the sky

Shine bright like a diamond
Shine bright like a diamond
Shining bright like a diamond
We’re beautiful like diamonds in the sky

Shine bright like a diamond
Shine bright like a diamond
Shining bright like a diamond
We’re beautiful like diamonds in the sky

Shine bright like a diamond
Shine bright like a diamond
Shine bright like a diamond

So shine bright, tonight you and I
We’re beautiful like diamonds in the sky
Eye to eye, so alive
We’re beautiful like diamonds in the sky

Shine bright like a diamond
Shine bright like a diamond
Shine bright like a diamond
Shine bright like a diamond
Shine bright like a diamond
Shine bright like a diamond
Shine bright like a diamond

I rest my case.......any kid with a crayon and a smattering of English could pen such rubbish. As for the vocal performance it is akin production and performance wise to the farting guy. Going through the charts there are countless examples of such rubbish. A few synths a beat and a pretty kid who can barely sing in tune. Match that with a couple of lines repeated ad nauseum add a sexy video...and voila you have a hit.....if the right people back it. Ask yourself why they chose that over some of the wonderful songs they have at their disposal or anything you or I or countless others would ever write.

As for baiting you well you obviously have no idea about me and what I do. I have no intention of rendering a judgement as you so crudely put it. I simply was offering my humble services to give a positive constructive critique in the hope you might learn something. I see nothing funny in that....the only funny thing I do see is a reluctance on your part to show what you can do especially as any aspiring songwriter tends to want to show their songs off to anyone who will listen. You obviously have your reasons. I suspect we both know what they are.
You can differ all you like from my opinions, observations and experiences of the industry.....BUT at the end of the day the general rules as I have explained them are true.....and neither of us are gonna change things anytime soon. Follow your dreams, write great songs...but keep at least one eye on reality. I wish you luck..... somehow I think you are gonna need it.