Dan,

This question aroused because of an 'reoccurring' theme that is playing itself out at this moment.
No one is hiding behind anything.
If you're not one of the ones being described as having sour grapes or resentful, then don't let this discussion get under your skin.
When you pointed out a group of Successful Artists Songs as not 'Living' up to the Nashville Myth of Great Songwriters, what was your point?
What did expect to happen?
Did you expect everyone else to agree with you?
If you want to argue the Merits of your charge then let's do that.
Why are they so bad? What do you have to base that on?
Is it because of the lyrics?
Is it because of the Melodies?
Is it because the Musicianship sucks?
These songs are Successful, not because of just one thing, but for a variety of things.-Dana