This thread began with a straw man argument postulating that those of us critical of the lyrical merit of commercial hit songs were simply resentful and envious of those who have gotten what we secretly wish for but have failed to achieve. In other words, our criticism is nothing more than sour grapes. By beginning with such a false premise, the poster can then dispense with having to argue the merits of the charge - that is that the writing we criticize is in fact bad writing - by attributing a bad motive to the accuser. You won't win many court cases with that kind of reasoning and logic.

It's now morphed into a discussion of the merits of how-to-do books and how people teach and learn songwriting. That kind of discussion can go on endlessly. Things can be learned from books and things can be learned through trial and error. Monkey see - Monkey do and direct observation is another way to learn. A lot can be absorbed by reading the classics.

When all is said and done, each of us has to find our own way using whatever tools we have at our disposal. There is no one-size-fits-all formula. As Mackie often says, Write on.



Write from your heart, not what you think others want to hear.

https://dansullivan2.bandcamp.com

http://www.cdbaby.com/cd/dansullivan2