Admittedly, I've only read a few of the preceding posts, so I may be going completely astray...

I believe that there are huge differences in the style of lyrics with respect to different musical genres*. Therefore, there are no common criteria as to what is good or bad. Most pop and dance songs do NOT tell stories, for example.

I do NOT believe that songwriters/artists can be sucessful over a stretch of time if they are no good. The record companies may be able to push beautiful young girlies up to the top to create a one-hit wonder, but that's about it. Those who stay at the top for years are there BECAUSE they are good (marketing campaigns do their part, of course).

I like being criticized. It helps me get better with respect to my own personal criteria.

Cheers,
Bernd

* one of the more ridiculous aspects of JPF is dividing the lyrics sections into "one", "two", "three" instead of as for genres. When my lyrics are criticized I often have to take into account that (most) others come from the country genre which I do NOT write for, so many contributions are slightly off.

Last edited by Bernd Harmsen; 01/23/13 01:48 PM.

Bernd
[url]http://bernd-harmsen.com[/url]