interesting thread. smile I was content simply to read, but when the word 'books' entered the conversation I felt compelled to step up to their defence. wink

I've learned so much from books on songwriting/lyric writing, especially regarding the craft. I come from a journalistic/short story/poetry-writing background, so the transition to lyrics of course called for a different type of focus and craftmanship.

I'm with Dana regarding Eric Beall's book on writing and producing songs that sell. It's dynamite. I bought it a couple of months ago, and was captivated from the first page. This guy knows the business inside out. While reading the book, I went through a range of emotions like curiousity, shock, bewilderment, anger, amazement, despair (that I'd never be able to do anything with a song or songs), excitement, delight, and finally a wonderful sense of being inspired and challenged - and wanting to meet that challenge because I now have a few more weapons in my arsenal.

Note, though, that the book isn't about how to write a good song. The author presumes the reader already knows how to do that. What he does is offer information and guidance on what a songwriter needs to do so that his/her song stands out from the competition.

The book impressed me so much, I sent a copy as a Christmas gift to one of my collaborators in Scotland. He's a brilliant musician, and has been playing and composing for over 35 years. I know he'll be able to apply what he learns from the book. I'd already sent him Sheila Davis's excellent book on writing songs for film/tv (as we both want to do more in that direction). He told me he was so excited and inspired by that book that he'd spent three days in a row - including late into the night - re-visiting some older tracks.

Anyway. This is simply my two cents' worth where books are concerned. wink

As for criticism: There's not one of my lyrics that hasn't been improved - sometimes dramatically - after I've re-written it - often multiple times - on the basis of constructive critiques from both amateur (e.g. songwriting forum members) and professional songwriters.

Donna


Honour the Earth. Without it, we'd be nowhere.

Life is too important to take seriously.