Considering criticism..

On the one hand I think it's important to stick with the song at hand, and not make the conversation about any other song.

After all, a critique is something the author solicits, not something that's forced down his throat. It's an offering, not an assault.

Admittably, on the other hand, it can sometimes feel like an assault, though, and in those instances it's important to understand the criteria the song has been judged with.

If you just write for your own pleasure, you can get away with anything, as long as it makes sense to yourself.

If you write for your girlfriend, it better be about loving her, or else..

If you write for people you don't know, like artist pitches, you need to be aware of that, and don't assume too much. You need to make yourself clear, and make music that makes sense to your (and their!) listeners.

If you're the artist yourself and aspire to specific uses like commercials, film, tv ect., you need to be aware of the criteria that applies for a song to be useful in those situations.

So critique is something that you can use to allign yourself with the competition and the audience (whom ever that may be), and the judgements can be a beacon for you to craft music that eventually will be well recieved by the people you'd like to recieve it well.

While it's true that good and bad is in the eye of the beholder, the same goes for how you respond to critique, and put it to work for you. Remember it's an offering, and it's up to you to determine how valid it is, in the context of your song, because you are the only one who knows all the details about your aspirations.

In that respect books are awesome resources, especially for people with few or no friends in the music business. Books are knowledgeable people's offerings to those who does not yet know, and sharing those thoughts is like walking through a front door to your dreams, as long as you remain open and stick with it. The same goes for the JPF Forums! In their signature everybody looks the same online, yet there are huge differences in how experienced people are. You learn that by listening over a longer stretch of time. But even people with no experience can tell you if they like the song or not, and then it's up to you to learn what criteria they have in mind when doing their critique.

While none can know better what you need to do, they can know more than you, and know-how and trusting it can really be the difference that makes a difference for you.. and even if they are not experts, you can always trust a judgement. You can't always use it in your situation, but that's a different thing.

If people were always completely honest, there would be no distrust.