Hi Dana and JPF participants:

Criticism can be a good thing if done tactfully. After all, those beginning to write or sing have pretty thin skins and are easily decimated by harsh words. It's so easy to be negative and so difficult to be positive. (Especially since the song or work involved may be stunningly horrible... LOL!) All of us started with varying proficiences. Nurturing certainly helps.

In many ways, I agree with Dan regarding what is mostly coming out of Music City these days. Don't get me wrong, there are some great songs entering the market and alot depends on the status and talent of the artist selcted to do the song for label "X" or "Y."

I also believe that talent should be the first element to consider but luck really does play a great deal in the success one can (or can't) achieve in today's overcrowded market. Still, a great song will usually find a way to be discovered. The luck factor is also heavily weighted in the cadre of friends an artist or writer has been able to cultivate with the ability to boost their career.

From my limited perspective, I don't pay much attention to the charts these days. Most are rigged to some degree by payola or other factors such as enforced playlists by the big dogs at the HQ station for a network of stations.

I like to measure the popularity and success of a song ten years down the road. Is it still bringing in the bacon? How many artists have "covered" it? That's what it is about for the most part. The rest is having the desire to have one's music hang around long after the writer is "in the ground."

No need to argue about any of this. We all have opinions and most of us are destined to follow our own path of thinking regardless of the facts or figures. I'm probably the world's worst when it comes to being opinionated... with the possible exception of my friend and "wee bairn" from across the great pond in the land of the Scots. (Big Jim, whom I enjoy alot.)

Happy New Year everyone and thanks for this interesting and often debated topic, Dana.

Dave