HiDee Y'All!

HiYa Brother Dana!

Somewhere during my 30+ Years Writing-Away, I quit worrying about "Is It 'Commercial'" & just focused on writing Interesting, preferably 'Different-Enough' Songs. Some HAVE made it on Others' CDs...some even make me beer money.

When I crit somebody's song, I'm sometimes thinking about making it More-Palatable to a Publisher/Singer IF it looks like a Commercial Write. But more-often, I'll offer some sugs to make it have more sense, or sing-smoother. Or Sug that it go "More Comedic"..or "Shorter"..or whatever I think the lyric/melody needs to make it a better song. (As far as An Audience is concerned.)

I'm my OWN "Worst Critic"..took a Decade-off Songwritin' '89-99, when nothing seemed to be happening in the Commercial Songwriting World (Have a FINE Early Electric Fan Collection as-a-result!) but now I'm a Decade-Behind where I'd like to be as a Writer--

WAS up 'til 4AM this morning researchin' 10 Really GREAT (IMHO) Nashville Songs that came out in 2012, as a bit of a Rebuttal to Dan's Critique on the Scene there, a bit ago. (& I didn't think TOO Much of that Dylan's Latest..lyrically..that he put up as "Exhibit A" of Fine Writing either...Google the lyrics & see Why!) I'll add I attended a Clearwater Concert a few yrs back where Dylan and Willie played back-to-back, & Willie was THE Crowd-Pleaser. Enough-Said. Bob's a Hero..Willie's onea My Favorite Writers. Different Strokes/Different Smokes... ;-)>

Here's a Sneak-Preview of 5 of my Examples that I think Both of the Above Guys'd nod their heads in-Appreciation: (No Particular Order) "Fly Over States" (Sung by Jason Aldean, co-penned by Neil Thrasher & Michael Dulaney).."Home" (Dierks Bentley).."Kiss Tomorrow Goodbye" (Luke Bryan).."Hard to Love" (Lee Brice, penned by Benjamin Glover, Billy Montana, John Ozier)..& "Cowboys & Angels" (Justin Lynch, penned by Josh Leo & Tim Nichols [who also co-ed on "Live Like You Were Dyin' a few years earlier)... (Still checkin'-up on Who Wrote What on the Other Five.) But Nashville still writes some Great Ones that ALSO "Go Commercial".... (& I, for one, sure don't poo-pooh Taylor Swift in the least...even if she Pop-Rocks AWAYYY Occasionally!)

&..my guess is she wrote that "MEAN" one just for therapy, never expecting it'd be a Hit.

So...my advice to ANY aspiring songwriter'd be Have FUN, don't let the Critics Dog-Ya-Down, just keep AT it..(& don't ever be afraid to LISTEN to the Radio to keep a Finger on "What's Commercial" Currently.) Get all the Feedback Ya CAN...but never say "die"...You may even surprise Yourself..Someday!

Last edited by "Tampa Stan" Good; 01/09/13 03:33 AM.