Dominic
These are your words quoted from above;

"" Ill be the first to call myself a loser, but at least I know I am.""

That is one of your seldom lucid moments and more than anyone here, you know the subject matter. It may be the one area of expertise that you actually possess.
And yet you think that others should accept your opinions on their song, songwriting in general, recording, and all sorts of other things.

Question:
Why in the world would anyone take the opinion of a self labeled loser about anything (other than your own pathetic state of mind) seriously?