Originally Posted by Rob B.
Dom,
you posted a song, I listened to it start to finish, and I gave you honest feedback. You’re free to disagree with it — that’s part of a critique forum. But responding by saying that every song I write is bad is just an insult, not a discussion.
If you don’t want critique, then say so when you post. Otherwise, don’t attack people for not giving you exactly what you asked for.
I pointed out a specific issue — the flow of that line — and instead of addressing it, you blamed AI. That’s your choice, but it doesn’t change the criticism.
Dom, don’t expect me to listen to your future songs if this is how feedback is received.
Because it's not terrible, and you know it.

I mean I read your critique of Guys latest song, it was Beautiful...

But this is just so terrible.

And just about everybody else you tell them how good it is.

I don't deserve that kind of review, and it doesn't matter really cause you have no clue about good songwriting.

If you don't like this , oh well. There are people who don't like Hotel California too.

The fact that you think I'm stupid enough to believe your approach is what causes me to fire back.

If you don't like the song but like Guys latest, then so be it

Don't try to attack me in the process.

A little respect for somebody who consistently posts pretty good stuff is appropriate.

Im a musician as well as singer and writer, spent alot of time at this.

I respect your opinion, I just know the difference between critique and an attack

Last edited by Fdemetrio; 11/14/25 02:40 AM.