Criticism can be both helpful and hurtful......it depends upon the kind of criticism given....and asked for.
With the music industry being such a closed shop it is very difficult damn near impossible to break into so most performers and songwriters just have to stand on the side lines as an observer. A heck of a lot of people, more than you can imagine, CAN write and perform songs just as good if not better than what they hear charting. It is no wonder that so many people have such a bad opinion of the pop business for that very reason. It is also a fact that some, myself included, have no interest in lowering the bar and writing to a dumbed down formula just to make a few quid. To put it another way if I were to open a restaurant it would be fine dining rather than junk food. Whilst from time to time eat junk food I would not want to make it a habit or try to make a living from it....cause like junk music it is bad for you and is not challenging enough to manufacture or prepare.