Just read Ben's post....yes we have locked horns on a few occasions but we do not bear grudges and have a mutual respect. I would call him a friend. As I would just about everybody on this forum. If we all agreed upon everything then life would be pretty dull. One thin I did learn early on is to have a thick skin and the persistence and determination of a wild cat.
To get back to the original topic.... criticism is good....it helps build confidence and a thick skin which you need if you want to go anywhere in this business. It is a good way of finding out what needs fixing and what you are doing right. My motto is if you do not know it is broke then how are you ever going to fix it. That said you need encouragement as well. Getting the mix right is the big problem...some backpat so much they fail to see the elephant in the room and others can only criticise. I try to be balanced. That said people who are in the big time are fair game especially if they do not reach minimum standards. If you think I am being harsh towards them then you should meet my agent....they would not last five minutes with him.