Criticism-helpful or hurtful?

Seems these terms have to be defined, as this discussion indeed went all over the place.

IF this is about critiquing and deconstructing what is out there, you simply can't help doing it as an artist. I have clients in the film industry, and many years back lived in a house with working actors, and not one of them can simply sit back and enjoy watching what is on the screen. Everything is analysed and discussed and analysed some more.

As long as you learn from this, it is helpful, but it sure takes the simple joy out of it.

It also explains Big Jim. He cannot hear music these days without looking at what is wrong with it. It just speaks to his long association as an artist in the music industry.

Couchgrouch, arguably one of the best writers who ever posted here, said he learned by listening to classic songs, and there was one book (he never would say which one) that influenced his writing direction. Great example of learning from what is out there and learning from what has been written by others.

IF this is about critiques at JPF, then it is all about who offers it up, what they say, and how it is used by the "recipient". If it makes the "product" better, it was helpful. If the critique was bad, or ignored, then it was not.

I really can't see how this turned into such a debate smile



If writing ever becomes work I think I'm going to have to stop