John - again, I'm not talking about either scenario. I'm talking about the critical attitude that says, "So and so sucks. I can't believe a label would sign such crap". Analysis and tearing songs apart from a craft standpoint are how you get better. That's a given.

And to your point, Big Jim - while I agree with a lot of what you said in your post, railing against the system isn't going to change a thing. Labels sign artists they think will sell. The great thing about the free market is that you get to vote with your wallet. If you don't like it, don't buy it. That's the only thing that labels understand.

On a side note, you might enjoy Bob Lefsetz' emails. He has a ton of great insight into the industry and how it's changing.


http://WWW.ACOUSTICVOCAL.COM
simple and affordable demo solutions for songwriters