With well over forty years experience as a professional singer I can critique a song and a vocal performance. I pride myself on the fact that I can deconstruct a song and say constructively what can be improved by highlighting the areas that need attention and suggesting what changes may be necessary....I have experience in writing, performing, recording, production and all the various processes involved. I am also experienced enough to know a bad vocal performance from a good one and can easily spot someone who has poor vocal techniques and tonal issues. I hopefully can help anyone to improve their craft whether it be as a performer a writer or producer.

So if I say that so and so sucks as a performer and the song is poor then it probably is true. I am of the opinion that anyone in the spotlight who is supposed to be at the top of the tree deserves such criticism if they and their song are clearly not up to the standard of an average singer singing an average song. I just cannot get my head around the fact that so many can be so blind and deaf. The fact that I need to justify "why I say that" is more a reflection on the person asking the question than it is on me for saying what should be blindingly obvious to anyone with any musical talent.
To turn it back on its head.... maybe it is not up to me to say why I think something sucks but up to the people who cannot find fault to explain why they think it is any good.

That said I am quite content just listening to music and admiring the song and performance........sadly the pop charts does not contain much in that category.