I was thinking about the title of this thread, and it occurred to me that criticism probably is neither helpful nor hurtful...it's only our response to criticism that helps or hurts.

Until you decide to change the song, all the criticism in the world is of little or no consequence.

Critiques are opinions--some are priceless, some are worthless, some are just second-guesses based on personal preferences. As artists, we need to hone our ability to assess critiques, and I think that skill is a lot more important to understand than the critiques themselves. Without that skill and the courage to trust in it, you may end up forever confused by a nonstop merry-go-round of other people's opinions.

So is criticism helpful or hurtful? It's up to you.