Originally Posted by Mark Kaufman
Critiques are opinions--some are priceless,


Hay Dana,

I guess that's my point. It depends upon who is doing the critique, and their level of experience.

If you wish to debate a point with Big Jim, who has forty years of industry experience, then you have to be forthright with your own experience.

It's very hard to take someone seriously when you don't know what they've done, and where they've been.

Eveyone here has great disaggreements with each other at some points in time, but they are opinional upon style, content, and experience, and with respect for the other fellows work.

I might not like someones song, but I am able to say for example " at bar 42, your timing is off on the bass" or " the whole song should be stepped up by 2-3 BPM"

These things are not opinions. They are fact, and valid criticism of a writers work, as they deal with substance over circumstance.

cheers, niteshift