Originally Posted by Brian Austin Whitney
Jim,

You have to be willing to accept that it's possible people didn't like your songs as much as you think they should. But I don't think you are willing to even consider that possibility based on your comments. So you'd rather people randomly choose one song over the other which may well result in you ranking even LOWER than you do now.. which would make you even MORE unhappy. On the other hand, if they chose your song instead, then someone else may be ranked lower than they deserve. That's not good either. By voting a tie when you have no opinion of which is better than the other, you don't harm or help anyone who doesn't deserve it.

Brian


Brian Please do not think I do not know my place or worth. I have been in this business too long to have delusions. I can accept better songs than mine are plentiful and know where my songs should place after hearing the opposition. What I have difficulty accepting is songs that really suck being placed better.
Re the randomly judged songs above each other. I cannot accept that you of all people cannot judge two bad songs against each other and come up with a proper winner. I would like to think that most people with any music background can assess each song regardless of how bad it is against another and pick the best one. As for people with no backround in music I would rather take my chances than just let them be classed as all equally bad.
I thought judging was meant to be judging ALL and not just looking at the best.

http://www.soundclick.com/bands/songInfo.cfm?bandID=687727&songID=5238055