Originally Posted by Scott Campbell


I don't think I believe this. Now my thinking here is probably too simplistic but tell me the flaw in the reasoning. Let's suppose I have $100, Joe has $10 and Bill has a share of stock. I buy the stock from Bill for $100. I hold it for awhile and then decide to sell it but no one wants to buy it. So I sell it to Joe for his $10.

At the end of the game, there is still $110 and one share of stock - it's just in different hands. If the underlying value of the stock was really $50 then Bill came out $50 ahead, Joe came out $40 ahead and I came out $90 behind. But no wealth was lost.

Scott


The missing piece here guys is that Bill paid $130 for the stock! ! You are assuming that he bought it for zero ! ! Bill lost 30% and you lost your ... well... you know


Herbie
JPF Chicago Chapter Coordinator
http://www.herbietunes.com